Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41 - Page 13

Yaar.. for last 2 episodes mere dimag mei bahut sare sawal arahe hai....

I am so pro vikranth ( no chapals please yaaar, hu kya karu), but I still can see his mistakes... pre leap i know he felt like complete dhoka by all his loved ones but also the way he responded drastically is also not completely right.... tho obviously I was so waiting for vikranth to know truth and for his guilt... but from last two days mujhe na vikranth mei ithna guilt nahi dhik raha hai, kyu ?( i can't blame acting because I saw adnan guilt scenes and he is awesome in them)... mujhe na vikranth ka behavior more practical lagraha hai like he realized he did mistake and for that he feel sorry that's it, no pain or nothing, he is not even feeling that pain that his loved ones felt, isse zadha tho he was in pain when he saw them moved on in indoor... am I the only one feeling like that or am I missing something... and after all truth why is he still thinking mannath had baby with dhairya during their marriage, how why... I am so confused with vikranth expressions in today's episode

Won't go into too much since this was discussed to death on forum & I no longer post anything for debates . Per me Vikrant & Mannat both are at fault and I don't like the post leap narrative where Mannat absolved herself of all her mistakes.I also don't agree with constant lies, deception and when caught claim you don't trust me, quite hypocritical.

About Dua, again my understanding, he didn't say Mannat conceived Dua while being married to him, he was infact shocked when he saw them as family in Indore with Dua. He believes she moved on, where as Mannat believes Vikrant rejected Dua, sent Divorce papers. Regarding MU both are right from where they stand and what they know.

Why??? On the contrary I liked that convo ...

Its not as if everything is going to come out in one go... it will take time... there are years that have passed between them when they didnt even meet each other.

What I understood is Mannat is salty about him believing she cheated.

Vish cooked a story and fed him and he got influenced. Which is what he has just realized... hasnt yet absorbed completely... all of them are still coming to terms with the reveals... unka din khatam nahi hua hai abhi 🤣

But thats the point where Mannat and RoTu are right... because they were telling him the other side of truth. He didnt see it that way. He accepted that to Vish didnt he? That he supported Vish against everyone.

I kept saying Vish ke reveal main kuch naya proof nahi hai... all the truths were out... Vik had to see Mannats version of story... which he did. And thats his guilt and not apology.

Duas truth is a much bigger issue and has multiple people involved.. And Mannat almost blurted out the truth. I think she still feels Vik will become upset and snatch Dua from her. This is my assumption.

As per many post leap convos... Mannat believes Vik thinks Dua is DKs child... which is what he said again today.

They haven't yet talked about whether he has realized she never cheated him with DK pre leap or Mannat was never having an affair with DK.

Also it hasnt crossed Mannats mind yet that Vish could be behind this. Mannat doesnt yet know Mallas role in this. When she came to inform him about the pregnancy only Vish was around. Mallas role is on funeral day when the divorce papers came.

Till that is out, ye dono apna kuch bhi resolve nahi karenge. Aise hi baat karte rahenge.

We were waiting for Viks redemption... it has just started... Mannats side of redemption will happen after Mallas role is exposed. Till then she wont realize either.

Mannat gave a good enough clue to Vik... but he hasnt thought on that yet. Hopefully he will. I liked that she mentioned the chawl wala incident. That is the Vik she knows and wants with her. And Vik realized that even though she knows somewhere he will keep his issues aside and help her, she is not counting on him.

As rdigest mentioned i agree both mannath and vikranth are at fault.... and I also understand how vikranth might have felt... I still think he expected they will stay back and try to convince him (rotu and mannath) that they didn't cheated him instead he saw them as happy family which tore him, i understood that... (frankly I didn't saw much of pre leap episodes , so not sure how mannath hide the truth , how vishaka convinced vikranth that mannath and dairya are together , or vikranth complete behavior towards them)... however I understood one thing both sides are at fault...

But I am still not able to understand keeping mannath dairya aside ,he got to know vish is horrible and rotu ,mannath dairya are right about her, I seriously thought there will be a moment between reni and vikranth... but I think @moor is right that , their day is not over and he is busy in saving duva , so let's wait...

Coming mannath... in recent episodes I felt somewhere he got compromised with mannath and dhairya being couple and he loves duva...although he still feel sad but he is keeping his distance from mannath... may be that is making him act like this...

Waise I really wanted manvik ka kuch Tasha vala shadi hojay may be for duva and fell in love all over again... but itha acha naseb hamara kaha

Also do you think , as vikranth got to know all truths , in guilt he wants to give all his property to rotu and mannath and leave... then yashika will be

Lol Sai, you mentioned that 1 character who is equal to Malla .......Run 🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️

Me and RD have gone over pages and pages of this

What I feel is there are multiple layers to everything that happened pre leap... its not one person and its not one simple truth that has any bearing.

Pre leap Mannat wanted to reveal the truth to Vik but Neetu blackmailed her into silence. When Vish was exposed, all of them agreed that its a shocking truth which needs to be hidden from Vik.

Why they couldnt tell him quietly and sensibly is beyond everybody's understanding.. but they agreed to hide... (btw that doesn't mean they lied).

Also inko leap Lena tha and lets be honest... only something as disturbing as this would have separated ManVik.

Mannat took a decision on his behalf as his partner... which some people believe is wrong. I have different views.. lets not go over it.

During the wedding, while Vish agreed to stay quiet and leave... she was plotting with Aish to stop the wedding... they staged a video and played it during the wedding. Mannat RoTu or DK didnt knew about it. What happened during the entire wedding fiasco was them trying to control the aftermath.

(Which is why I said Vishs truth is out, Vik chose ti believe her version and not Mannats version)

Within which Vik got upset that Mannat was defending DK and Vish manipulated him that Mannat is 2 timing him with DK. DK is a bhola bhala insaan jisko Mannat ne fasa liya.

When she came back again to tell him about pregnancy... Vish showed him a picture of Mannat DK hugging (in reality Mannat was whispering something in DKs ears). DK has proposed to Mannat and she had accepted and whatever she says don't believe her.

Vik ended the relationship... never got to know Mannat was pregnant while she heard him saying he thinks she cheated on him with DK. She was under the impression that Vik knows about the pregnancy... and ye abhi bhi clear nahi hai ki exactly use kya lagta hai. Post leap main bhi.

Post leap whatever Vish had told him is visible as it is. DM are pretending to be married and they have a daughter. Only vamp camp (except Y) knows Dua is Viks daughter and RoTu know DM are fake married.

My point always has been that even though both sides are wrong... its little more on Viks side. As the biggest issue between them is him thinking Mannat will 2 time him with his brother. Thats a very low opinion for a person you claim to love.

His issue is she didnt stand by him.

My question after todays episode is has he realized Vish could have lied to him about Mannat DK??? That she never cheated. Hasn't happened yet and I want to see if it happens. I dont expect it will happen instantly either. Aise hi ek din main and ek convo main sab kuch resolve nahi hoga.

But there have been ample hints from Mannats side about this, including aaj ka episode.

From Mannats side I want to see her wonder the same thing... if Vish manipulated Vik pre leap. She knows Vish did about RoTu... but whether Vish did the same about Mannat DK. Vik told Mannat Vish showed him a picture. She needs to go over that with Vish expose. And wonder if he knew about the pregnancy or something else entirely.

But ye sab itna easily nahi hoga... they will drag this obviously...

Most importantly Mallas role needs to come out. She is even bigger culprit who drove a wedge between Manvik with the divorce papers.

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

Yaar.. for last 2 episodes mere dimag mei bahut sare sawal arahe hai....

I am so pro vikranth ( no chapals please yaaar, hu kya karu), but I still can see his mistakes... pre leap i know he felt like complete dhoka by all his loved ones but also the way he responded drastically is also not completely right.... tho obviously I was so waiting for vikranth to know truth and for his guilt... but from last two days mujhe na vikranth mei ithna guilt nahi dhik raha hai, kyu ?( i can't blame acting because I saw adnan guilt scenes and he is awesome in them)... mujhe na vikranth ka behavior more practical lagraha hai like he realized he did mistake and for that he feel sorry that's it, no pain or nothing, he is not even feeling that pain that his loved ones felt, isse zadha tho he was in pain when he saw them moved on in indoor... am I the only one feeling like that or am I missing something... and after all truth why is he still thinking mannath had baby with dhairya during their marriage, how why... I am so confused with vikranth expressions in today's episode

He should have kicked this woman out right there. Kaun sa extra ordinary news ka wait kar raha hai? Dua is Mannat's daughter the woman he loved ...but she loved him more than him. Not okay with him. Not at all

Originally posted by: Moor278

Me and RD have gone over pages and pages of this

What I feel is there are multiple layers to everything that happened pre leap... its not one person and its not one simple truth that has any bearing.

Pre leap Mannat wanted to reveal the truth to Vik but Neetu blackmailed her into silence. When Vish was exposed, all of them agreed that its a shocking truth which needs to be hidden from Vik.

Why they couldnt tell him quietly and sensibly is beyond everybody's understanding.. but they agreed to hide... (btw that doesn't mean they lied).

Also inko leap Lena tha and lets be honest... only something as disturbing as this would have separated ManVik.

Mannat took a decision on his behalf as his partner... which some people believe is wrong. I have different views.. lets not go over it.

During the wedding, while Vish agreed to stay quiet and leave... she was plotting with Aish to stop the wedding... they staged a video and played it during the wedding. Mannat RoTu or DK didnt knew about it. What happened during the entire wedding fiasco was them trying to control the aftermath.

(Which is why I said Vishs truth is out, Vik chose ti believe her version and not Mannats version)

Within which Vik got upset that Mannat was defending DK and Vish manipulated him that Mannat is 2 timing him with DK. DK is a bhola bhala insaan jisko Mannat ne fasa liya.

When she came back again to tell him about pregnancy... Vish showed him a picture of Mannat DK hugging (in reality Mannat was whispering something in DKs ears). DK has proposed to Mannat and she had accepted and whatever she says don't believe her.

Vik ended the relationship... never got to know Mannat was pregnant while she heard him saying he thinks she cheated on him with DK. She was under the impression that Vik knows about the pregnancy... and ye abhi bhi clear nahi hai ki exactly use kya lagta hai. Post leap main bhi.

Post leap whatever Vish had told him is visible as it is. DM are pretending to be married and they have a daughter. Only vamp camp (except Y) knows Dua is Viks daughter and RoTu know DM are fake married.

My point always has been that even though both sides are wrong... its little more on Viks side. As the biggest issue between them is him thinking Mannat will 2 time him with his brother. Thats a very low opinion for a person you claim to love.

His issue is she didnt stand by him.

My question after todays episode is has he realized Vish could have lied to him about Mannat DK??? That she never cheated. Hasn't happened yet and I want to see if it happens. I dont expect it will happen instantly either. Aise hi ek din main and ek convo main sab kuch resolve nahi hoga.

But there have been ample hints from Mannats side about this, including aaj ka episode.

From Mannats side I want to see her wonder the same thing... if Vish manipulated Vik pre leap. She knows Vish did about RoTu... but whether Vish did the same about Mannat DK. Vik told Mannat Vish showed him a picture. She needs to go over that with Vish expose. And wonder if he knew about the pregnancy or something else entirely.

But ye sab itna easily nahi hoga... they will drag this obviously...

Most importantly Mallas role needs to come out. She is even bigger culprit who drove a wedge between Manvik with the divorce papers.

People expect Mannat to forget everything and move on in a jiffy in the name of love which is obviously not possible. People also expect her to tell Dua's truth but why she doesn't want to and how & why all these started, no one wants to hear or dwell on that. (Aman's truth also she wanted to say but she knew what would be the repercussion if she did this herself & hence begged, pleaded RoTu to tell but Neetu EBed her & abhi all of a sudden Neetu as per her own convenience wants to tell Dua's truth to Vikrant without thinking about the outcome)

Vikrant on the other hand also needs time to process things. Bande ka luck kharab hai everytime 2-3 things get exposed in one go 😅 and i have mentioned many times that makers have not made any efforts to show his inner thoughts ever, hardly 2-3 times may be.

Even now in a span of 7 years none of us as audience know how Vikrant's life went by, in SM while Indore family dynamics was shown properly to us. All of us have a very vague idea about Vikrant's life.

Vikrant’s inner thoughts characterization has always been a problem, never explored properly by makers.

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

People expect Mannat to forget everything and move on in a jiffy in the name of love which is obviously not possible. People also expect her to tell Dua's truth but why she doesn't want to and how & why all these started, no one wants to hear or dwell on that. (Aman's truth also she wanted to say but she knew what would be the repercussion if she did this herself & hence begged, pleaded RoTu to tell but Neetu EBed her & abhi all of a sudden Neetu as per her own convenience wants to tell Dua's truth to Vikrant)

Vikrant on the other hand also needs time to process things. Bande ka luck kharab hai everytime 2-3 things get exposed in one go 😅 and i have mentioned many times that makers have not made any efforts to show his inner thoughts ever, hardly 2-3 times may be.

Even now in a span of 7 years none of us as audience know how Vikrant's life went by, in SM while Indore family dynamics was shown properly to us. All of us have a very vague idea about Vikrant's life.

Vikrant’s inner thoughts characterization has always been a problem, never explored properly by makers.

The moment you say this Mona.. it will be termed as hating Vik... which I will never understand why... Vik is a fictional character... if someone is pointing out his mistakes... it means the writing is being criticized ... not Adnan 🤦‍♀️

Vik ke liye monologues almost nill hai... we are never given an insight into his mind. So we are left to guessing based on our interpretations and assumptions. Agar de diya to kuch clarity audience ko milegi bhale hi characters ko na mile 😕

I feel a lot will depend on which truth comes out first and through whom??? Just like this expose, Duas truth and DM fake marriage are also linked. One would lead to another.

But they obviously want to drag it tabhi to Neetu is gayab. 🤣 Mannat has taken a promise for Duas truth from Neetu. But not for DM fake shaadi... all Neetu has to do is tell that to Vik... phir vo khud sochega 🤪🤪

But ye log to use milne bhi nahi de rahe.. neither he goes to meet her. 😆

Neetu is another strange character. Her first task should have been to stop VY shaadi. Uske baad sach batati Dua to kya fayda hota. Vik ka second divorce karvati kya? 😆😆😆. Shouldn't putting a break on shaadi be a priority for her? 😁. For ManVik and Duas sake 🙄

I have longed believed Mannat herself will tell about Dua to Vik. Lets see 🤞🤞

Funniest part which I have never understood is people believe RoTu ne sach bataya hota to Vish chali jaati

Vish never cared about Vik or even DK... usko bas paise ki padi hai. Even Aish is better than her that she cares for Malla atleast. And is on your face with her motives. Vish usse jyada cunning and cruel hai. 😡

Agar Vik ko sach bataya bhi hota to aisa to nahi hai ki Vish manipulate nahi karti???? Vo chup chaap chali jaati.

This scenario of Vik siding with Vish was still possible. And Vish manipulating Vik against Mannat was also possible.

Neetu did do wrong in causing the accident and drugging Vik. Ro was wrong in falling for a emotional trap of buying a kid.

But they realized they were wrong and asked for forgiveness pre leap itself.

This is same as offscreen Neetus blaming Mannat for not agreeing for Aishs blood test.

As if Aish pyar se apna test hone deti and Mannat ko prove karne deti ki vo Arzoo nahi Aish hai 🤪🤪🤪🤪

I mean come on really 🫡