Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 86

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

860

Views

30.8k

Users

25

Likes

4k

Frequent Posters

ChaoticTangles thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 3 hours ago

Originally posted by: FUITV

Okay so the marriage without a witness, priest, we are considering that to be legal marriage?

If it was any other show or if it was not between the main leads of a show, all of us would be like the guy fooled the girl under the guise of marriage.

For me, to even like ManVik again, they need to get the redemption properly otherwise there is always the FF button to just watch dua and bunty scenes

Manit guy played similar role in kundali bhagya where he was married to the FL but FL just respected him.

Bold : yes,its funny..smiley37marriages are joke in itv.. In mukta's previous show the ML took 4 pheras and smashed kumkum on FL'S forehead and that's considered legal marriage..smiley37

But if at all they want to show manvik's marriage as legal they might show they completed the rituals and registered their marriage the day after terrace marriage and just were waiting for social marriage to reveal it to everyone so family won't be upset... Warna it's doesn't make sense why vik is so sure that he is married and mannat signed divorce papers..

moonwearer thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 3 hours ago

I am drawing my impression based on what is being shown. I agree that Vikrant has taken on the responsibility of mallas So called child. Are the folks in SM capable of nurturing a child ? No idea .only Vikrant seems to be interested genuinely in Yuvi.

Yuvi is presented as a brat looking down on people and agrees to go along with what Vikrant asks him to only after his demand is agreed upon.

That definitely is not the way a kid needs to be handled.

We say a village is required to raise a child. The village is missing on SM and the bandwidth is missing at present in Vikrant. He needs to definitely change the tone and tenor with which je handles Yuvi and when time comes with Fua as well.

The values and goodness which made Vikrant such an adorable human has gone for a toss since he embraced the Aman Kumar identity.

As of today seeing how Vikrant deals with the folks around I have this doubt. His redemption has to be in terms of how he sets boundaries is dealing with people.

Kidult104 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 3 hours ago

Originally posted by: Daman17

I agree with what you’ve said, but at the same time these portal narratives are usually driven by the makers themselves to test the waters. Whether negative or positive the intent is to create hype around the show. As Moor rightly pointed out, he mentioned that things will eventually get resolved but given the current track, that it feels like an eternity especially when the story has barely moved beyond the characters just crossing paths. The core issue lies with the writers and the execution team and that is precisely why Ayesha and Mannat are facing backlash. Viewers tend to connect with a character’s core and perspective. From the audience’s POV, she is a single woman living with her brother in law, who himself acknowledged her as a sister in the pre leap episodes. Now, showing him developing feelings for her based on time spent together under changed circumstances is not being received well. The confusion arises when actors give IV stating that the character is a strong single mother only for the narrative to later shift towards co-parenting with another man. The outrage is not about future plot possibilities but about what is being shown currently especially when the writers reuse the same dialogues that were once used for Manvik. Sadly, audiences often overlook men’s actions and instead direct their frustration towards the woman. What viewers expected was a pure, untainted friendship with no emotional milawat. However, the flipped dialogues and DK’s partial acceptance of his feelings give the audience an impression of intent, especially when viewed in light of pre-leap incidents. Even if he hadn’t fallen for her earlier he clearly has now, while the girl remains completely unaware of his feelings and continues to give him lifetime assurances without knowing the full truth and here DK also uaware of Vik’s truth, but it feels like the team is deliberately cashing in on negative hype similar to what they did during the Malla-Vik angle. Perhaps this is also why the Y character was introduced, after audiences reacted against the two sisters and one man dynamic, calling it a bad social example. To course-correct, the makers added a new female character in Vik’s life. In our society, such relationships still face limited acceptance, and that is why the backlash is spilling across all platforms.

Daman, you said it right. I guess they are testing waters. The leap started from addressing Mannat's trauma but slowly shifted to DK's conflict. Eventually it will move to Vikrant's side

The story is stuck because i feel there are multiple reasons. First they wanna align with aarambhi to give them push, second is due to cricket season. Mannat returning to Mumbai is a high point of the show, it will be milked alot. Third, indore setup gave them a good start so they are taking time to wrap it up well. Fourth, idk if you all know, but saluja mansion set is used for arambhi show, thats why they might be taking some time to adjust things. Fifth, rn they wanna establish few things, few bonds which will be broken once they go back to mumbai. They are creating new mus to delya the expose of the vamps because all their exposures are interlinked with each other. One starts, another follows.

Kidult104 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 3 hours ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

All of this could have still happened without DK developing romantic feelings if the point was to extend the MU...

Theres no clarity on when he started feeling this way nor I want to know smiley11


This flip actually serves Vik in the long run with Neetu as his vociferous advocate now that her voice is back smiley44.... the blame will fall squarely on Mannat for writing DKs name on birth certificate, letting Dua think DK is her baba and going against Vik...


All without Vik having to do anything on his part to correct things...

Neetu might even justify YV like she justified Malla.... Thats the really really sad part... smiley7

What I think moor is, Ronnie will be a deciding factor here. Even if we want or not, I feel Dk's monologue will be there someday or I am expecting a conversation between him and ronnie. Its not that I ship them or something, I want that clarity and monologues before drawing some conclusions on Dk's character. One can deny he has been a strong pillar for them all and has been giving dua some good values. So if Mukta is going forward with this, she better clears these things sooner or later.

About Neetu giving clean chit to Vikrant. I feel somewhere down the line even neetu knows dk isnt a bad guy. He was present in her dream as well. She just sees him as a hurdle in her son's happiness. I feel even though dk's feelings for mannat might give some edge to Vikrant, this can be used for other purpose as well. Somewhere down the line Vikrant still has a doubt that whether Mannat actually moved on or not and I feel he will always have that. This can be a good opportunity to test the trust factor. He will know Dk loves Mannat but will he accept mannat also loves dk since the start? What I feel, he will be uncertain and this uncertainity will help him to redeem. He will be on the edge about Mannat's stance and what if she also starts feeling for dk after 7 years? This push might help him to question his relationship with Yashika.

WittyKittyVixxy thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 hours ago

Originally posted by: Daman17

I didn’t have any issue during the first 2-3 weeks of the track. In fact, it felt like a sensible move showing how a certain set of people come together as a family and jointly handle responsibilities. However, from last week onward, the narrative has started shifting towards creating negative hype, and that’s where my problem begins. My main issue is with the writing, and I will call it out for what it is a complete dragfest. The same dialogues are being repeated by the show’s protagonist again and again, and it feels forced. There are obvious undercurrents, but the writers had several better options to fill the gaps. For instance, they could have shown DK actually functioning as a cop and handling a case, explored how Mannat established Dua’s kitchen, or delved into Ronnie’s trauma after losing everything. What disappoints me even more is the absence of Mannat Ronnie scenes. They suffered the most as a family, neetu being unwell and Vik left them at alter yet we are not shown how they rebuilt their live as a family. In comparison, DK never had that deep emotional bond with Vik, so the excessive focus on his pain feels disproportionate. If the intent is to address Mannat’s trauma, I would be happy because that is what the audience wants. But doing it under the constant DK mahaan baba narrative in every single episode is not ok with me. This is Mannat’s story, yet the writing conveniently positions DK as the primary victim of Neetu’s rage to generate sympathy. I was actually expecting a proper DK–Vik face-off, but nothing of that sort happened. Instead, DK’s emotional acceptance is indirectly pushed through Neetu, a character whose behaviour was repeatedly WW by the FL herself. After DK’s confession, the sudden shift in his expressions makes the entire arc look uncomfortable and poorly executed. I am not okay with this dragfest. I don’t mind other characters discussing their inner turmoil, but not at the cost of the FL character arc. Such narratives inevitably lead to FL character assassination, and that is something I strongly object to. The separation between Manvik happened for a reason, yet instead of highlighting the pain and suffering of both of them, the writing once again chooses to focus on the pain of just one character. That is again biased storytelling. I had called out the writers even before the leap for consistently pushing the narrative through vamps while sidelining the leads, and I will do so again now. DK, as a character, was initially written well, but this sudden change in direction is not working for me. I didn’t question his actions earlier because they felt pure and untainted. But now, the idea that only one person’s suffering matters feels forced and unnatural. On the other hand, the show has started portraying Vik as someone who has no romantic feelings for Y and still holds Mannat somewhere in his heart. Once again this shift works against Mannat’s character alone, not DK’s. Neetu, as a mother, committed multiple crimes many of which were conveniently WW or brushed under the rug. While her karma being served in the form of health issues is understandable, going overboard with sympathy is not. Mannat was absolutely right in calling her out for Vik’s behaviour and even supporting DK’s sacrifice to an extent. However, taking it too far and glorifying him completely ignores the fact that he is also the same man whose mistakes contributed to her present trauma. Years of support cannot simply erase his past actions, and portraying it otherwise is poor and disappointing writing.

This endless praise of DK must be after all she brought him from KB so praise to banta hai.

The 2nd person who got a lot of focus this week was Neetu. The sceptic in me says Suwati threatened to quit, so to satisfy her, she is the focus now. Let’s see how much TRP she brings in 🤪

truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 2 hours ago

Originally posted by: Resham

Tum log thake nahi yeh sab likhte likhte ...koi faayda hai bhi...smiley37

Main to padhke hi thak gayi ..smiley37

a woman is holding a glass with the words jal pijiye on itThis is mera jaanbujhke wala...so tagging only those who share same to same thoughts smiley37

Why not me?😜😢

WittyKittyVixxy thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 hours ago

Originally posted by: Kidult104

Daman, you said it right. I guess they are testing waters. The leap started from addressing Mannat's trauma but slowly shifted to DK's conflict. Eventually it will move to Vikrant's side

The story is stuck because i feel there are multiple reasons. First they wanna align with aarambhi to give them push, second is due to cricket season. Mannat returning to Mumbai is a high point of the show, it will be milked alot. Third, indore setup gave them a good start so they are taking time to wrap it up well. Fourth, idk if you all know, but saluja mansion set is used for arambhi show, thats why they might be taking some time to adjust things. Fifth, rn they wanna establish few things, few bonds which will be broken once they go back to mumbai. They are creating new mus to delya the expose of the vamps because all their exposures are interlinked with each other. One starts, another follows.

Clothes bhi mannat ka, set bhi mannat ka! 🙄🤦🏻‍♀️

truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 2 hours ago

Originally posted by: moonwearer

I am drawing my impression based on what is being shown. I agree that Vikrant has taken on the responsibility of mallas So called child. Are the folks in SM capable of nurturing a child ? No idea .only Vikrant seems to be interested genuinely in Yuvi.

Yuvi is presented as a brat looking down on people and agrees to go along with what Vikrant asks him to only after his demand is agreed upon.

That definitely is not the way a kid needs to be handled.

We say a village is required to raise a child. The village is missing on SM and the bandwidth is missing at present in Vikrant. He needs to definitely change the tone and tenor with which je handles Yuvi and when time comes with Fua as well.

The values and goodness which made Vikrant such an adorable human has gone for a toss since he embraced the Aman Kumar identity.

As of today seeing how Vikrant deals with the folks around I have this doubt. His redemption has to be in terms of how he sets boundaries is dealing with people.

That’s what I said right?

Without giving him a chance how will he learn? Right now he is oblivious to truth and people around him. He himself is dealing with aftermath of truth which was hidden from him and came out in worst way possible.

Even we want to see his redemption but for that matter some truth has to come out. Not just for Vikrant but Indore side also. They also have to know some hard hitting truth.
About Yuvi I already made my point . Vikrant is not his so called father or pretending father so for me that doesn’t matter. At least he tries to tell him good things. And like he said Yuvi is family friends son. He is not Yuvi’s father but friend like he says Buddy.

What SM folk has to do with it?

Dua is Vikrant’s daughter so he have to take responsibility of her and in that process he has to learn some priorities when it comes to her. He has to learn to love and to protect her from any harm. And that’s why I feel some truth has to come out to open his eyes and see things clearly. Otherwise it’s same rinse and repeat cycle 🤬

🤗

Edited by truptishree - 2 hours ago
truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 2 hours ago

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Guys yesterday one of my friend who also watch mannat pointed out one thing...

She said ,at time of wedding track she felt sad at the coincidence of vish being in the hall at exactly the same time as video of rotu-vish came out, It was vish presence at same time which triggered aman's trauma even further where he was unable to listen to anyone...until then he was ready to go into room as mannat asked to resolve the issue but vish presence as biological mother triggered vik's past memories even more.....and apparently before this vish was locked in room by mannat and dk was the one who got her out, at that time she didn't feel anything wrong with it because it was shown that dk just got her out to leave the town forever... Now after dk's confession she feels that maybe dk purposely got her out...

And I watched the scene, she was right vish was already locked in room by mannat and mannat asked dk to take vish away after wedding is done... But dk in the middle of phera ceremony got her out... I still don't think dk intentionally did it and he actually wanted to take her away from there to leave mumbai but were writer's actually planning to show dk was planning all along???...... Because if writer needed vish in hall , they could have made malla/aish to get vish out..?

Dont know what writers are planning ahead , they can flip the narrative at anytime.....

If dk developed feelings during these 7 years then it's okay but if at all he had feelings for mannat since pre-leap then dk is definitely wrong... smiley19

Welcome aboard!

That’s what we were saying no? Your friend is bang on👏👏

Yes Vikrant was really ready to listen calmly when RoTu and Mannat asked him.

I also made this point that he only let Vish out when Pheras were going on. Easily he could’ve wait for some time. After pheras could’ve given his blessing and then left but no he wanted to leave in middle of pheras and that too with Vish. Then all this fiasco happened. If you see he really kept quiet when Vish was doing all her drama, Mannat was accused but he didn’t say anything at that time was just giving sad expressions😡

Bettyscar thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: an hour ago

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Bold : Before leap, who goes to a bride's room so frequently on some pretext not involving his brother in their conversations whom he desperately searched for twenty years,he was more interested in her than his brother in preleap also, it was clearly evident..

Vikrant never misunderstood them inspite of seeing them together in her room many times..In fact he was cool with their intimacy though he didn't know, that he was his brother at that time. The memory had faded from his mind because it held so little importance to Vik; it did not even appear in his flashbacks..DK had soft corner for M in preleap also..

During an old age home visit with DK, Vik was puzzled by them going together. He also said sorry when they met in the kitchen after seeing them hugging after the haldi fiasco.

When DK and M became aware of Vik's thoughts, they should have taken more cautious steps and been more transparent in their actions, rather than hiding things from him. This lack of transparency led to the uncontrollable damage.

Had DK and M been more transparent in their actions and taken caution after learning of Vik's thoughts, they might have avoided the catastrophe..without giving chances to the vamps to question their intimacy while investigating dadi case...I am talking about the photo which was shown to Vik where M leaned on DK to say something in his ear..

I would like to see his face, when he knows, Vik isn’t married and Yuvi isn’t his son ..Due to M's lifetime assurances, and Baba jaap ,he is flying high ♥️..He thought his line was clear with Vikrant' s fake wife and fake son..He enquired very slyly about her Mumbai meet up with Vik...

I felt pre-leap he was drawn to Mannat but he may not have been aware. When you are unaware you tend to act a certain way that others may observe and question whereas when you become aware you can control how you act.

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 21 days ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 37 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 6 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 · 1 years ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 years ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 36 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".