Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 01 Sep 2025 EDT - Page 11

Originally posted by: sammmmmyyyyyy

As much as intention was to save Ruhi, but you don't give another trauma to save her from one trauma .....what will a kid go through when heard from her Massi that she killed her mother, that's not the way or feels intention of saving

Ruhi didn't murder her mother..... It happened as vehicle malfunction which Aarohi was talking to a mechanic on phone in shopping... Which half conversation was muted with BGM & Akshu-Ruhi spat.... But i know people won't consider it & will go on endlessly with Akshu presented false narratives that Ruhi is the reason Aarohi died....

Tanya shouting on Maira is totally wrong... I agree with that

As per karma analysis that is very famous in this forum, she also get back her karma. She did the same to poor Manjari and left her to die in the road hence, she also died in the same manner

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

Arey whatever yaar that kid was indeed traumatized na??? What was his plan and what couldn't happen is not the question... He on first place should have prioritise Ruhi instead of anyone... Akshara ko arrest karwa sakta thaa, so that she couldn't run What was Manjari doing??? Why was she not with her???

Bold- As much as I wanted it.... That's Abhi's fault, Agreed, ghatiya women 🤢🤢 ko arrest karna chahiye tha😤😤

But for that, he thought of analysing the whole situation & collecting total Truth with evidence as he felt this whole Accident/Murder thing is a misunderstanding which he discuss with Shefali.... So that he could save 3 kids lifes from trauma's... He died before anything happened

But even that wasn't explored in Gen4

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

Arohi died due to her own ignorance. Pehle choti bacchi ko keys de diya, fir beech road mein phone pe baat karne lagi that too unaware of people yelling her name.

As per karma analysis that is very famous in this forum, she also get back her karma. She did the same to poor Manjari and left her to die in the road hence, she also died in the same manner

I agree on Aarohi getting her karma

I disagree with solely Aarohi's fault... It was even Achaara's fault included Along with Ruhi shouldn't have start car, it's more Achaara's fault of manipulating situation like that instead of explaining families

It's Achaara who couldn't control the car properly.... It's team fault which she could have explained to families rather than misguiding ABHI & Misleading families with self inflicted mistery on Every other person

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

First of all I'm not going into the never ending debate of what Akshara or Abhimanyu could've done and bla bla bla....

I just said that Unlike Tanya who was clearly shouting at Maira by declaring that her mother has murdered her brother, Akshara never traumatized Ruhi by disclosing the fact that it was due to Ruhi's act the car malfunctioned and hit Arohi... That's it.

I also support Tanya in her bashing to the lusty couple but her bursting on Maira was unnecessary.

Tanya should bash abhira and armaan but dragging maira was not necessary.Maira has that bad memory etched now and she cannot get over it.

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

More than her maasi, Ruhi needed her poppy and dida to be with her at that emotional time. She had already started to hate Akshara when she overheard suvarna/surekha asking Akshara as to why can't she control the car and what was she doing in the driving seat??? Akshara just accepted that allegation (which was unnecessary).... Had Abhi and Manjari stayed back with her she wouldn't have been more traumatized. I know people will say Abhimanyu was worried for Abhir so he run behind Akshara but sadly it was a selfish act by him as well to run for his own child leaving behind an orphan niece, who was more close to him than Abhir. What made Manjari leave Ruhi all alone still confuses me??? In short Ruhi's trauma was a result of everyone's negligence and not alone Akshu.

And what Tanya did that day was unnecessary and unpleasant.

Manyu obv went behind ak for abhir and he could have prioritised ruhi as honestly the poor girl had no one.Neil had asked him to take care of his child.Your point is true that everyone traumatised ruhi and not only ak.Kairav and muskaan could have offered to adopt ruhi and take care of her.Muskan wasn't that bad.But in end past is past.Gen 3 has finished and we cannot just fight over it.Writers have done their work and we have to accept the truth.Let's not have hard feelings.

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

Their pathetic writing in both gen-3 and gen-4 has created all the mess.

Abhi chalo abhira and armaan ki trolling karte hai.

Originally posted by: sammmmmyyyyyy

I agree on Aarohi getting her karma

I disagree with solely Aarohi's fault... It was even Achaara's fault included Along with Ruhi shouldn't have start car, it's more Achaara's fault of manipulating situation like that instead of explaining families

It's Achaara who couldn't control the car properly.... It's team fault which she could have explained to families rather than misguiding ABHI & Misleading families with self inflicted mistery on Every other person

Originally posted by: A_Star39

I wonder how manjari abandoned ruhi at that point too.She could have kept ruhi with her.

Manyu obv went behind ak for abhir and he could have prioritised ruhi as honestly the poor girl had no one.Neil had asked him to take care of his child.Your point is true that everyone traumatised ruhi and not only ak.Kairav and muskaan could have offered to adopt ruhi and take care of her.Muskan wasn't that bad.But in end past is past.Gen 3 has finished and we cannot just fight over it.Writers have done their work and we have to accept the truth.Let's not have hard feelings.

Originally posted by: A_Star39

True. Manyu and ak dono leads ka character butcher hogaya and same for gen 4.

Abhi chalo abhira and armaan ki trolling karte hai.

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

@Bold- Agreed 100% but many in the forum still can't get over Akshara, Abhimanyu and Abhinav whom all have died two years back.

I am 100 percent sure kuch bada kaand hoga.They need some old trauma to continue in gen 5