Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 25 - Page 113

Originally posted by: Shemer

https://x.com/lakshu24/status/1960947632827982113?t=WX8TvDfpZIj3eOr2vAI8kQ&s=19

Its after mannat saving bio dad from ars

Originally posted by: Moor278

I was not comparing ARS and Neetu...

I was hinting at Anirudh and ARS, for Mannat .... right now Mannat is questioning both their versions. Mannat clearly told Anirudh that she doesnt trust him... but she patiently sat down and listened to his version, thought about it, came and questioned him...

She knows Aish better than she knows Ani and the flashbacks she had today were on her villinish acts... so Mannat is definitely wondering who is lying... Aish or Ani...

When Ani questions her who she will support... Mannat without missing a bit says the one who lied will get punished...

This is the statement expected out of Vikrant... when Neetu asked him who he will support among her and Mannat... both are equally dear to him!!!

@bold

but first he says "Mannat knows what she is doing" which implies she wont do a baseless rumour!!! Fair enough and good I would say.... but has he ever questioned Neetu's accusations towards Mannat??? Has he ever asked proof from Neetu when she vomits against Mannat???? or even Malla when she accuses Mannat????

If Mannat has to think before making baseless accusations... why cant the same courtesy be extended by Neetu or Malla or Keerat?

Why is only Mannat has to show proof and no one else and why does the responsibility of getting proofs only from Mannat???

Vikrant can investigate on his own like Mannat is going to do!!!!

The difference in writing which I repeatedly point out to you is this....

Vikrant could have simply told Neetu that I will support whoever is right!!!! but he said nothing....

and that doesnt come without proof being 'shown to him'.... not him 'finding it out on his own'!!!! does it mean that he can never trust Mannat against Neetu if Mannat doesnt have a proof... ???? wont that be wrong for the love of his life?????

What you find as perfection ... I find as flaw and biased writing!!!!

Absolutely agree with Moor..

Vikrant should not be biased between Neetu and Mannat..He should ask proofs from both,if at all ..

Otherwise without proof he should believe like in poisoning case ..but when it comes to his mom,even though he trusts Mannat ,he gives support to his mom, after all a mother is a mother who can't do anything wrong to her child ( being sarcastic)who can't be questioned by her son😳,who starts emotional crying 😢 to manipulate him...

Mannat should learn all these techniques from her mil, useful for future encounters...

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Absolutely agree with Moor..

Vikrant should not be biased between Neetu and Mannat..He should ask proofs from both,if at all ..

Otherwise without proof he should believe like in poisoning case ..but when it comes to her mom,even though he trusts Mannat ,he gives support to his mom, after all a mother is a mother who can't do anything wrong to her child ( being sarcastic)who can't be questioned by her son😳,who starts emotional crying 😢 to manipulate him...

Mannat should learn all these techniques from her mil, useful for future encounters...

I think openly supporting Mannat against his mum is a recipe for disaster. I would rather the conversation he had with Malla about Mannat he had a similar one with Mannat so she understands that it's not about him mistrusting her but it's his mum. Mannat needs to be more careful when bringing up an argument against Neetu. I understand previously she was tricked into disclosing since Keerat did her drama in front of everyone.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I think openly supporting Mannat against his mum is a recipe for disaster. I would rather the conversation he had with Malla about Mannat he had a similar one with Mannat so she understands that it's not about him mistrusting her but it's his mum. Mannat needs to be more careful when bringing up an argument against Neetu. I understand previously she was tricked into disclosing since Keerat did her drama in front of everyone.

The convo should happen with both honestly.

But problem with Neetu is she has so much inherent hate for Mannat that she won't listen to Vikrant even once.

Vikrant tried so many times to make her logically understand but each time she starts with her emotional manipulation.

Even if Malla wasn't part of the game, Neetu would have still spewed venom. The reason being Mannat’s social status and also having her own individuality, doesn't bow down to any non sense. Majority indian subcontinent MILs would never prefer such bahus for their sons. They would prefer someone who stays under their thumb. Malla has very well understood this part & hence tries to align herself & tricks Neetu.

Another big reason is her birth. Neetu keeps on blabbering Ganda khoon etc.

Now, If the entire game changes & it is established that not Mannat but Malla is the illegitimate daughter coupled with ONS secret being out, Neetu would be the first to flip & side with Mannat.

She is also opportunist like the other SM waasis.

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Absolutely agree with Moor..

Vikrant should not be biased between Neetu and Mannat..He should ask proofs from both,if at all ..

Otherwise without proof he should believe like in poisoning case ..but when it comes to his mom,even though he trusts Mannat ,he gives support to his mom, after all a mother is a mother who can't do anything wrong to her child ( being sarcastic)who can't be questioned by her son😳,who starts emotional crying 😢 to manipulate him...

Mannat should learn all these techniques from her mil, useful for future encounters...

He needs to first make his Mom understand.

Keerat incident was a deliberate one. Keerat deliberately dragged her & told about Neetu drugging Vikrant. Otherwise both Mannat & Neetu were having their conversations in SM kitchen. Mannat never had the intention to bring out in front of others.

She lost it when Neetu lied & put the blame on her for separating mom & son.

And in majority cases Mannat had never started direct confrontation with Neetu. Its Neetu who starts it that too name calling her mom. And Mannat simply retaliated which is fair enough. Vikrant initially wasn’t understanding this aspect but am glad he is now & giving back to Neetu as well.

But he really needs to put a full stop to this & only he can do that. Even if Mannat tries 100 tactics Neetu will still hate her

Originally posted by: ronahiji

Its after mannat saving bio dad from ars

That clip has me worried. ARS had a head start. No doubt she already has a plan in action. Mannat breaking down in front of the vultures is worrying.

Agree with all of you....

the problem is Neetu continues with her venom and when it fails she blackmails Vik and then the onus falls on Mannat to make amends... why should she when she is not at fault?

Like Mona said... majority of subcontinent MILs are like that...

Instead of having the conversation with Mannat... he should have that convo with Neetu... try to make her understand his POV without getting upset and also ask what exactly she doesnt like in Mannat... Pretty sure Mannat being Mannat will change for Vik's peace of mind...

But that initiative to build a bridge between his mother and wife should be from the husband/son.... no one else is going to make the effort!!!

Vik had given her Mannats letter when Neetu was unconscious after the wrist cutting... that letter has not reached Neetu it seems and Vik's fake proposal had complicated matters... Neetu has got it in her mind that Mannat is after Vikrant whereas it was other way around...

Originally posted by: Moor278

Agree with all of you....

the problem is Neetu continues with her venom and when it fails she blackmails Vik and then the onus falls on Mannat to make amends... why should she when she is not at fault?

Like Mona said... majority of subcontinent MILs are like that...

Instead of having the conversation with Mannat... he should have that convo with Neetu... try to make her understand his POV without getting upset and also ask what exactly she doesnt like in Mannat... Pretty sure Mannat being Mannat will change for Vik's peace of mind...

But that initiative to build a bridge between his mother and wife should be from the husband/son.... no one else is going to make the effort!!!

Vik had given her Mannats letter when Neetu was unconscious after the wrist cutting... that letter has not reached Neetu it seems and Vik's fake proposal had complicated matters... Neetu has got it in her mind that MANNAT is after Vikrant whereas it was other way around...

Bold But she knew about fake proposal when she heard malla and Vik talk about it to make Mannat to realise her feelings towards him..It was clear by that conversation that Vik wanted Mannat in his life, not the other way ..

Neetu needs to be more humane to understand her son's happiness if she really cares for it..instead of giving importance to social status..

Being coming from a chawl herself, she was looked down by Ars in initial episodes..She forgot her roots..

VIK has been telling her to be polite and not to insult Mannat . even then she is repeating ,no heed to his words, ignores and pays no attention

She disregards his requests, showing lack of consideration..Vik has to be more stern ..Ronnie has to put some sense in her zero brain ..Otherwise she is uncontrollable in insulting Mannu..

oh yes... I had forgotten that completely...

She knew before the wedding that this was fake proposal

😁😁🤣

https://youtube.com/shorts/n6PagNYOlPk?si=VNwVwLGqdiuvcYHH