Is Bhagyashree justified for feeling cheated by Rishabh

Is Bhagyashree justified for feeling cheated by Rishabh. I know it is her past but I think she overreacted

They were fake husband wife so he doesn’t owe her an explanation about being married to Nysa. Bhagya’s dad also is not willing to listen to anyone but this time he forgave Bhagya for lying to him about her husband

And till today’s episode Rishabh never said I love you to him so he never kept her in the dark about that

Both are justified in my opinion

Risabh did say to Bhagya when she confessed him her love -

He said it's khai for him to walk towards that. Bhagya said she will wait for him always to cross that khai

I think it's the initial intent of Risabh of revenge...he should have find out first bhagya is involved or not ...rather than jumping on revenge and giving hard time to her family.

I feel bad for risabh that bhagya didn't even realize that because of her statement his father was tortured in jail. He was innocent yet spent time in jail. She should realize this no matter she was manipulated or not. Otherwise I feel she is too much into her pain and not seeing others sufferings.

She is too naive to recognize people. She trusts wrong people blindly like her ex, nyasa, nikhil. And doubts good people like risabh.

She is not clever in days to day life ....only in her work she is good.

Originally posted by: priya185

Is Bhagyashree justified for feeling cheated by Rishabh. I know it is her past but I think she overreacted

They were fake husband wife so he doesn’t owe her an explanation about being married to Nysa. Bhagya’s dad also is not willing to listen to anyone but this time he forgave Bhagya for lying to him about her husband

And till today’s episode Rishabh never said I love you to him so he never kept her in the dark about that

Yes, she is justified from her end. Rishabh hid his identity, that too that he is a Kapoor. And her perspective of Kapoor Industries isn't good at all. She thinks his father is a criminal who opresses poor people. That too she got to know that they too her Appa's house.

All this aside, she was most hurt about him being Nayasa's husband. Even though Rish hadn't said he loved her, he had implied that dozen of times in last few days. They had gotten really close as well and he did lead her on knowing she had feelings for him, but in all this he just told he has a past but never told that he is still married. So yea, obviously she feels betrayed the way she got to know everything.

I don't blame Rish either, he was just trying to protect his family and ended up loving her. Really bad situation to be in.

Are you serious?!

She told him she loved him. Why didn't he tell her then that he's married?

They had so many private moments where he touched her, hugged her and so clearly implied that he feels for her too.

Not only that, he hid his identity and intentions for approaching her. She pawned her jewellery and gave him money. Why didn't he come clean about being rich and not needing money and acted like he's poor? Why did he act like he needed a job?

Fact is he led her on. Period.

I don't empathize with Rishabh because he judged her on the basis of 1 testimony and didn't even attempt to find out the truth. Also, even if she implicated his dad, does that mean you infiltrate her life and destroy her and her family?! Whatever that happened was professional, not personal. If he got into the company and tried to destroy her professionally, it would have made sense. Also my biggest question - why has he not tried to destroy Nysa instead, knowing damn well that she's involved in a lot of this and has clearly made his life hell?

Bottom line - they've made a mess out of this show with half-baked writing.

They don't think before writing. They just write as they think they think 😂😂...you know what I mean. Suddenly now he thinks it's not her but someone else. Bhaisahab...this woman who is your wife you know is a crackpot, she is the owner / responsible for managing this company where B is just an employee. That wife is capable of going berserk at slightest move against her. How could he not know it's her doing and not that bichari employee there. And when he returned there as an assistant how come no one knows him? He is the bloody owner of the company no? And how come B who is the national head not know who owns the company and who is her boss married to?

Audience is not dumb especially the newer gen. Bakwas likhwate hai purane writers se 😝

Originally posted by: BinKuchKahe.

Are you serious?!

She told him she loved him. Why didn't he tell her then that he's married?

They had so many private moments where he touched her, hugged her and so clearly implied that he feels for her too.

Not only that, he hid his identity and intentions for approaching her. She pawned her jewellery and gave him money. Why didn't he come clean about being rich and not needing money and acted like he's poor? Why did he act like he needed a job?

Fact is he led her on. Period.

I don't empathize with Rishabh because he judged her on the basis of 1 testimony and didn't even attempt to find out the truth. Also, even if she implicated his dad, does that mean you infiltrate her life and destroy her and her family?! Whatever that happened was professional, not personal. If he got into the company and tried to destroy her professionally, it would have made sense. Also my biggest question - why has he not tried to destroy Nysa instead, knowing damn well that she's involved in a lot of this and has clearly made his life hell?

Bottom line - they've made a mess out of this show with half-baked writing.

Yes, he shouldn’t have acquired her Dad’s house. He didn’t say I love you back when she confessed but he does love her now like he said in the hospital scene.

They haven’t shown that much information about Nysa and Rishabh after she put his dad in jail, maybe he has a plan to destroy her too.

Originally posted by: priya185

I have posted a topic for discussion. This forum barely has any topics apart from EDT and ATs.

Yes, he shouldn’t have acquired her Dad’s house. He didn’t say I love you back when she confessed but he does love her now like he said in the hospital scene.

They haven’t shown that much information about Nysa and Rishabh after she put his dad in jail, maybe he has a plan to destroy her too.

Bhagya is justified in feeling betrayed, and Rish also knows this. His plan was never to get this involved and he did because he got pulled by Bhagya's issues. At the time he just rationalized it as getting close to her (not romantically) and getting her to trust him. But things started going romantic and he did keep trying to fix that. He kept pushing her away, except when he couldn't. Finally when she confessed, he realized how far things had gotten. Since then he has been in split mind of loving her one moment and thinking about badla the next. Finally he finds out the whole truth and wants to tell her in calm way but Nyasa came up and destroyed everything.

As for the touches and him being married, the touches were mostly presented as involuntary except for the rain scene. And he clearly hates his so called wife, and probably was in the middle of divorce proceedings anyways. Separated couples can have relationships with other people. In any case, him revealing any of that would have risked Bhagya finding out the whole truth. Which is not what he wanted.

I agree that he could have simply said he has someone else or something like that, but I don't think Bhagya would have simply accepted that. Not after everything he has done for her.

Very interesting discussion points that I wanted to raise but has already been posted here

Am just watching this show for HC who I guess is being used like eye candy. I believe Bhagya has accepted Nikhil’s proposal. Even Rishabh asked her if he can also get forgiveness.

Basically, this is some random conflicted writing. Like Bhumika says , they just come and write on that day of shooting. That rationale is absent as of now. Am hoping they will show what happened to Naysa and Rishabh or else, his character looks bad if he is going to continue to obsessively follow Bhagya. I think some kind of closure is necessary to bring the leads together again.

viji

TBH, the story never made much sense to me. It feels lackluster. They write every other character praising the protagonist—calling her smart, empathetic, loyal, sincere, honest, fair, and courageous enough to stand against injustice—yet she fails to do the most basic due diligence before testifying against an innocent person in court? And on top of that, they don’t even show how she qualifies to testify. She wasn’t the defendant, she wasn’t an eyewitness, and she wasn’t an expert like a doctor, psychologist, or forensic specialist. She had no business being on the stand.

Honestly, the male lead’s over-the-top revenge is more believable than her testimony—because when someone is on a vengeance trip, they’re rarely thinking straight. They have a single motive and don’t care about collateral damage. I’m not justifying Rishabh’s misplaced revenge, but at least it makes sense. Bhagya, on the other hand, blaming an innocent person for a crime they didn’t commit—despite being portrayed as fair and honest—completely breaks her character logic.

And at least Rishabh didn’t stand her up completely and then ghost her like Nikhal, whom she and her father have so graciously forgiven and accepted as her fiancé. She was the one who hired Rishabh to play her husband. They both knew from the start that it wasn’t a real relationship, nor were they friends before entering into this contract. Neither owed the other any personal life information or secrets—it was essentially a job. Where Rishabh was wrong was in deceptively taking her parents’ house. But even that was shown as an exploitation of her brother’s failure to repay his debt. In a way, her brother also brought it on himself and their family. So, her and her family aren’t as clean and innocent as they like to believe.

So, to answer your question on whether she is justified in feeling cheated on by Rishabh—well, if she is willing to take accountability for her actions, then yes. If not, then she brought it on herself. Neither of them wronging the other absolves either one of responsibility.

Perhaps next time, they could have ChatGPT cross-check their screenplay. At least then it wouldn’t have this many loopholes and unrealistic scenes and characters.