Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 24 - Page 116

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Lovely review Trupti…….
think we all agree that there are glaring holes in the logic and actions of Mannat, spending more time with Vikrant is rubbing off 😂🫠 Joking aside, we have pages upon pages of posts complaining why writers dumbed down his character…… that’s what writers are doing to Mannat atm so they can boost and dramatise Anirudh’s story….. and drag it out to maybe link exposing along with Vik’s ONS or at least create the parallels.

I really like your comparison between Mannat and Vikrant’s trust on their respective parent….it really is illogical but writers probably plan dramatic emotional/confrontation scenes for Mannat like Vik/Adnan’s sensational week that boosted trps.

At least we are seeing more of ManVik with Malla sulking in the background…and Mona’s double face is fabulous, yesterday I felt ARS was genuinely admiring her daughter Mannat during the bhajan and rituals with Vik….. ARS’s look of surprise when Malla took the stage was spot on as she knows how hopeless Malla is, and initially Gagan was just the proud father…. til the song changed😂🤣

On ARS…that scene when Neetu fetches her from her room for the puja and questioned her about Malla/Vik in light of Mannat being her daughter too….. that was odd - was Neetu testing where ARS’s loyalty was now or whether the ARS’s black mail still stood? Neetu is dumb so unlikely, it was probably her hatred for Mannat that she’d still rather keep her son married to criminal Malla. But wasn’t Neetu adamant after the poisoning to take Vik’s side until ARS bm’s her again……

Looking for to the glorious ManVik episodes we have in store ❤️

Yes, right now Mannat is more emotional than sharp-minded. Just like when she was jailed. Smart Mannat would have doubted ARS or got someone to investigate and called a lawyer. But she was getting scared and helpless because of Malla and ARS dhamki.

I can understand why Mannat trusts ARS and does not bring up her past crimes. ARS confessed she punished innocent Mannat for Anirudh's crime, admits she did many wrong and apologised. The same ARS who brought Mannat into SM to keep her identity as Sonia hidden. Its like her assault made her cold-hearted and assault attempt on Mannat bought herself back. Makes sense or not, thats how it looks to me.

ARS didnt drop her act infront of anyone. Like you mentioned, her reaction to Malla and Mannat bhajan looked genuine. So it still looked believable for me that no one is doubting her. Right now, ARS is the victim Mannat needs to save from Anirudh. Even Shalini is MIA.

Mona maam is fabulous and am glad we are getting less of Malla,

Waiting for Mannat 'spider sense' to tingle and work on finding out the truth.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNX21s1SQZc/?igsh=MTRpanJuMTVsMGJoYg==

Originally posted by: Moor278

Chasmish gang understands kya hua

Adnan/Vikku getting too vigorous in pulling his pyaari into his arms 🫠 when glasses can be a hinderance 😂

I had been wondering how Ayesha was managing with her glasses and those very dangly earring in the energetic dance moves and Vikku’s over exuberance 🤣

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

https://youtu.be/Umw9NnK7KWE?si=ux43j7no1rsjS2AK

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/167220151

@PG bts and above convo I had with @Jyots…… I think there is another clearer bts where Mannat brings up Vik’s shaadi/shuudi and Malla being her sister ……. Shruti talks about the fake ONS entrapment and about Vik and her true pyaar….. looking forward to seeing this maa-beti episode soon.

In the clip, Shruti didnt mention about telling Vikrant the ONS truth or divorce, which should be the priority. Will wait for this scene in episode.

Thanks for sharing this Shazia😊

I am looking at it from OG angle...

There are certain things which need to happen for Amans reveal... one of which is Neetu realizing Malla doesnt love Vik and start supporting Mannat .. secondly Mannat needs to know Amans truth before Vik does... RoTu asking Mannat to lie for Viks sake...

Mannat also needs to lean towards Anirudh...

But they have added this ONS wali shaadi in the mix... And they are clearly delaying Mallas expose for whatever reasons...

So by that logic...

I feel this Dahi handi is replacement of BBQ. I guess hand tied Vikku black hole main gaya

If Mukta wants to play around by keeping Vik unawares like they usually do... they can still expose ONS truth for everyone else but Vik (he could be unconscious) ... when Mannat saves him... but then she could be manipulated by Neetu to leave for his birth truth.

That might be the push for Mannat to start believing in Anirudh as she would also understand Aishs role in the blackmail.

All I am wondering on these lines is because of the reasons everyone has listed... Shruti asking Mannat to accept Vik, Vik being crazy in love without bothering about divorce himself, Mannat openly flirting with him... Malla not getting exposed etc etc... none of it makes sense... not from the positive characters perspective that is...

There has to be something different ahead

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

Yes, right now Mannat is more emotional than sharp-minded. Just like when she was jailed. Smart Mannat would have doubted ARS or got someone to investigate and called a lawyer. But she was getting scared and helpless because of Malla and ARS dhamki.

I can understand why Mannat trusts ARS and does not bring up her past crimes. ARS confessed she punished innocent Mannat for Anirudh's crime, admits she did many wrong and apologised. The same ARS who brought Mannat into SM to keep her identity as Sonia hidden. Its like her assault made her cold-hearted and assault attempt on Mannat bought herself back. Makes sense or not, thats how it looks to me.

ARS didnt drop her act infront of anyone. Like you mentioned, her reaction to Malla and Mannat bhajan looked genuine. So it still looked believable for me that no one is doubting her. Right now, ARS is the victim Mannat needs to save from Anirudh. Even Shalini is MIA.

Mona maam is fabulous and am glad we are getting less of Malla,

Waiting for Mannat 'spider sense' to tingle and work on finding out the truth.

You’ve explained Mannat’s state of mind really well! Does make sense from that perspective.

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

In the clip, Shruti didnt mention about telling Vikrant the ONS truth or divorce, which should be the priority. Will wait for this scene in episode.

Thanks for sharing this Shazia😊

I think there is another longer bts with Mannat half hiding the necklace behind her back…. and Shurti’s knowledge about the ONS was a few episodes back I think……but as you say, let’s wait for the epi and editors cuts!

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Yes listened to Shairains iv, very illuminating that for Malla it’s beyond jealous now (doesn’t love him) and if Vik doesn’t want her, Mannat can’t have him either! Mentioned it to PG earlier that they’ve been leading to Malla’s volcano about to burst!

Absolutely it’s equivalent to Mellisa’s fire …. but Vic in white and hands tied doesn’t match up but may have been a red herring/promo.

In terms of mini-separation, I can see that on the cards as all this over load in Vik’s love finally being reciprocated and his promises in the OH of nothing coming between them is too much goodness to give us. But not sure the reason as I said to RD earlier

Perhaps, as you say because Mannat feels she is putting his life in danger, but that doesn’t tie up….. she knows there are other dangers around the corner for him from Neetu’s drugs so would she break up. Plus they’ve bonded well and he is supporting her this ARS/AS situation so to separate while that’s going on? We’ve pointed out in the past, they don’t hold grudges with each other so hopefully if it does happen it blows over v quickly……. but Mukta inflicted us with the sham wedding after hinting otherwise, so perhaps they do have an emotional break in mind. Hoping it’s not the rumoured pregnancy (but wasn’t in OG so may be spared that drag out).

And your ARS - AS role reversal is unravelling 👏🏼 and even in characters Vik and Ani have more and more in common, both passionate in their one and only love, both very hot headed where their woman is concerned, both decent principled men who value their family above anything (Ani=his daughter, Vik=his mother), both too bhola and trusting and tricked easily……

Very well expressed. Food for thought definitely.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

They look 🔥 Is this on or off screen?

Patha nahi...but they are looking 🔥🧿

Originally posted by: Moor278

I am looking at it from OG angle...

There are certain things which need to happen for Amans reveal... one of which is Neetu realizing Malla doesnt love Vik and start supporting Mannat .. secondly Mannat needs to know Amans truth before Vik does... RoTu asking Mannat to lie for Viks sake...

Mannat also needs to lean towards Anirudh...

But they have added this ONS wali shaadi in the mix... And they are clearly delaying Mallas expose for whatever reasons...

So by that logic...

I feel this Dahi handi is replacement of BBQ. I guess hand tied Vikku black hole main gaya

If Mukta wants to play around by keeping Vik unawares like they usually do... they can still expose ONS truth for everyone else but Vik (he could be unconscious) ... when Mannat saves him... but then she could be manipulated by Neetu to leave for his birth truth.

That might be the push for Mannat to start believing in Anirudh as she would also understand Aishs role in the blackmail.

All I am wondering on these lines is because of the reasons everyone has listed... Shruti asking Mannat to accept Vik, Vik being crazy in love without bothering about divorce himself, Mannat openly flirting with him... Malla not getting exposed etc etc... none of it makes sense... not from the positive characters perspective that is...

There has to be something different ahead

Moor you are scaring me

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Yes listened to Shairains iv, very illuminating that for Malla it’s beyond jealous now (doesn’t love him) and if Vik doesn’t want her, Mannat can’t have him either! Mentioned it to PG earlier that they’ve been leading to Malla’s volcano about to burst!

Absolutely it’s equivalent to Mellisa’s fire …. but Vic in white and hands tied doesn’t match up but may have been a red herring/promo.

In terms of mini-separation, I can see that on the cards as all this over load in Vik’s love finally being reciprocated and his promises in the OH of nothing coming between them is too much goodness to give us. But not sure the reason as I said to RD earlier

Perhaps, as you say because Mannat feels she is putting his life in danger, but that doesn’t tie up….. she knows there are other dangers around the corner for him from Neetu’s drugs so would she break up. Plus they’ve bonded well and he is supporting her this ARS/AS situation so to separate while that’s going on? We’ve pointed out in the past, they don’t hold grudges with each other so hopefully if it does happen it blows over v quickly……. but Mukta inflicted us with the sham wedding after hinting otherwise, so perhaps they do have an emotional break in mind. Hoping it’s not the rumoured pregnancy (but wasn’t in OG so may be spared that drag out).

And your ARS - AS role reversal is unravelling 👏🏼 and even in characters Vik and Ani have more and more in common, both passionate in their one and only love, both very hot headed where their woman is concerned, both decent principled men who value their family above anything (Ani=his daughter, Vik=his mother), both too bhola and trusting and tricked easily……

Listening to Sharain’s interviews gives me flashbacks of lost ki PL.