Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No "122” - Page 124

Originally posted by: Maleigh

Perfect! I want it to be a hidden little gem so much, i ain't gonna bail on krush with this one. It's kinda my second show with him PLUS I'm already high on jhanak's tolerance i ain't tripping man 😂😂😂😂

All the the way with Bindi 🧗‍♀️🏊‍♂️( but c'mon what kind of name is this???😂)

Maleighji, it seems you haven't learnt the biggest lesson from Jhanak experience...that never to watch a show for your favs if there's no good script...else emotional trauma is on the way...🤣🤣🤣

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Maleighji, it seems you haven't learnt the biggest lesson from Jhanak experience...that never to watch a show for your favs if there's no good script...else emotional trauma is on the way...🤣🤣🤣

Hahah can't argue with that one but I'm trying to convince myself that jhanak was just a big conspiracy 😂😂😂 it never actually happened the way it did😀

Originally posted by: Maleigh

Perfect! I want it to be a hidden little gem so much, i ain't gonna bail on krush with this one. It's kinda my second show with him PLUS I'm already high on jhanak's tolerance i ain't tripping man 😂😂😂😂

All the the way with Bindi 🧗‍♀️🏊‍♂️( but c'mon what kind of name is this???😂)

I don’t have the tolerance to sit through another round of character assassination like Ani’s - for no good reason. But if we’re talking about character arcs and if Krushal is indeed playing Bindi’s father (cringe)... then the trajectory seems fairly standard. He starts off as a negative character, has a change of heart around epi 70 after discovering he has a daughter, and then becomes the mom/child's protector through to epi 300. After that, where the father ends up in jail, the mother dies and the villain wins!

Post-leap, he’s released from prison and begins seeking retribution. On paper, it’s a broader arc... negative to redemptive, an emotional journey eventually yearning for family... but it still feels driven more by plot twists than genuine emotional depth in the regional version. This would really have to be adapted to do justice to Krushal’s acting chops... there’s potential, but only if the writing steps up. Throughout the show, the father is mostly shown interacting with the child and has relatively few scenes with the mother (just as well... look at the oozing chemistry in the pic below... pretty sure his BFF gave that one a big thumbs-up!).

I’m sure Krushal had his reasons for taking on the role, but personally, I would have liked to see him in a more youthful, grounded character... something with real emotional texture rather than another plot-driven arc inevitably leading to a generational leap. Oh well!

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMz7U3TPsEJ/

Originally posted by: Alter_Eg0

I don’t have the tolerance to sit through another round of character assassination like Ani’s - for no good reason. But if we’re talking about character arcs and if Krushal is indeed playing Bindi’s father (cringe)... then the trajectory seems fairly standard. He starts off as a negative character, has a change of heart around epi 70 after discovering he has a daughter, and then becomes the mom/child's protector through to epi 300. After that, where the father ends up in jail, the mother dies and the villain wins!

Post-leap, he’s released from prison and begins seeking retribution. On paper, it’s a broader arc... negative to redemptive, an emotional journey eventually yearning for family... but it still feels driven more by plot twists than genuine emotional depth in the regional version. This would really have to be adapted to do justice to Krushal’s acting chops... there’s potential, but only if the writing steps up. Throughout the show, the father is mostly shown interacting with the child and has relatively few scenes with the mother (just as well... look at the oozing chemistry in the pic below... pretty sure his BFF gave that one a big thumbs-up!).

I’m sure Krushal had his reasons for taking on the role, but personally, I would have liked to see him in a more youthful, grounded character... something with real emotional texture rather than another plot-driven arc inevitably leading to a generational leap. Oh well!

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMz7U3TPsEJ/

I would have been happier if Krush got to play even a complete negative character who is not having this family baggage..if it would have been a parallel character, still I would be feeling more confident that yes, he will pull it off with finesse...in this case, imv, he is too young to play a father both as an individual and as an actor...he should have explored more mainstream things before taking up this type of fatherly characters..and after Jhanak experience, even after knowing that the show is a remake, he should have put some more thought before signing it...again I am clarifying, its my personal opinion...

Originally posted by: Alter_Eg0

I don’t have the tolerance to sit through another round of character assassination like Ani’s - for no good reason. But if we’re talking about character arcs and if Krushal is indeed playing Bindi’s father (cringe)... then the trajectory seems fairly standard. He starts off as a negative character, has a change of heart around epi 70 after discovering he has a daughter, and then becomes the mom/child's protector through to epi 300. After that, where the father ends up in jail, the mother dies and the villain wins!

Post-leap, he’s released from prison and begins seeking retribution. On paper, it’s a broader arc... negative to redemptive, an emotional journey eventually yearning for family... but it still feels driven more by plot twists than genuine emotional depth in the regional version. This would really have to be adapted to do justice to Krushal’s acting chops... there’s potential, but only if the writing steps up. Throughout the show, the father is mostly shown interacting with the child and has relatively few scenes with the mother (just as well... look at the oozing chemistry in the pic below... pretty sure his BFF gave that one a big thumbs-up!).

I’m sure Krushal had his reasons for taking on the role, but personally, I would have liked to see him in a more youthful, grounded character... something with real emotional texture rather than another plot-driven arc inevitably leading to a generational leap. Oh well!

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMz7U3TPsEJ/

Originally posted by: Alter_Eg0

I don’t have the tolerance to sit through another round of character assassination like Ani’s - for no good reason. But if we’re talking about character arcs and if Krushal is indeed playing Bindi’s father (cringe)... then the trajectory seems fairly standard. He starts off as a negative character, has a change of heart around epi 70 after discovering he has a daughter, and then becomes the mom/child's protector through to epi 300. After that, where the father ends up in jail, the mother dies and the villain wins!

Post-leap, he’s released from prison and begins seeking retribution. On paper, it’s a broader arc... negative to redemptive, an emotional journey eventually yearning for family... but it still feels driven more by plot twists than genuine emotional depth in the regional version. This would really have to be adapted to do justice to Krushal’s acting chops... there’s potential, but only if the writing steps up. Throughout the show, the father is mostly shown interacting with the child and has relatively few scenes with the mother (just as well... look at the oozing chemistry in the pic below... pretty sure his BFF gave that one a big thumbs-up!).

I’m sure Krushal had his reasons for taking on the role, but personally, I would have liked to see him in a more youthful, grounded character... something with real emotional texture rather than another plot-driven arc inevitably leading to a generational leap. Oh well!

https://www.instagram.com/p/DMz7U3TPsEJ/

LOL this whole story just sounds like a rotation of everyone going to jail.....so story starts with the FL being born in jail? Then she comes out of jail after 5-6 years and is an outcast everywhere for being born in jail? lol then once the father re-enters the picture, he will protect her for a bit before himself landing up in jail in time for gen leap?

And Krushal's track record playing father to Moon bitiya in Jhanak was really not convincing much so to imagine that he's signed up for a show where 300 epis ke liye 7 year old girl ka dad banke rahega is just sounding quite bizarre......

No one is saying Krushal needs to sign up for a love story each time but it's really confounding that at this stage of his Hindi TV career, he would jump to playing a father role like this.....most actors don't do these roles until much later in their careers when ML roles have dried up for them.

Baaki toh Krushal bhaiyya hi jaanein kya soch rahe hain in taking up this story

Originally posted by: AreYaar

LOL this whole story just sounds like a rotation of everyone going to jail.....so story starts with the FL being born in jail? Then she comes out of jail after 5-6 years and is an outcast everywhere for being born in jail? lol then once the father re-enters the picture, he will protect her for a bit before himself landing up in jail in time for gen leap?

And Krushal's track record playing father to Moon bitiya in Jhanak was really not convincing much so to imagine that he's signed up for a show where 300 epis ke liye 7 year old girl ka dad banke rahega is just sounding quite bizarre......

No one is saying Krushal needs to sign up for a love story each time but it's really confounding that at this stage of his Hindi TV career, he would jump to playing a father role like this.....most actors don't do these roles until much later in their careers when ML roles have dried up for them.

Baaki toh Krushal bhaiyya hi jaanein kya soch rahe hain in taking up this story

Makers may try to develop an extended romantic angle between the parents to pull crowd...but still the fact remains that its the story of the kid...the kid is the actual lead..high chance that it will end up like Jhanak where end was predetermined with Anishit raising Moon as a married couple while Jhanak remained alone if gen 1 ended in feb (like Jol Nupur and Roshnai ending) or in the village raising an illegitimate child with a gunda as it ended recently...and makers just fooled us with Runak live in and lovey dovey scenes...to keep us engaged for extended time...aisa kuchh hone k chance rahe jaati hai in this case as well where leads romance and love story is not the ultimate goal but a mere tool to engage audience..

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

I would have been happier if Krush got to play even a complete negative character who is not having this family baggage..if it would have been a parallel character, still I would be feeling more confident that yes, he will pull it off with finesse...in this case, imv, he is too young to play a father both as an individual and as an actor...he should have explored more mainstream things before taking up this type of fatherly characters..and after Jhanak experience, even after knowing that the show is a remake, he should have put some more thought before signing it...again I am clarifying, its my personal opinion...

Yep... I think both Hiba and Krushal can play negative roles very well!

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Makers may try to develop an extended romantic angle between the parents to pull crowd...but still the fact remains that its the story of the kid...the kid is the actual lead..high chance that it will end up like Jhanak where end was predetermined with Anishit raising Moon as a married couple while Jhanak remained alone if gen 1 ended in feb (like Jol Nupur and Roshnai ending) or in the village raising an illegitimate child with a gunda as it ended recently...and makers just fooled us with Runak live in and lovey dovey scenes...to keep us engaged for extended time...aisa kuchh hone k chance rahe jaati hai in this case as well where leads romance and love story is not the ultimate goal but a mere tool to engage audience..

Dibya ji, ab aapko bhi bola padega ki itna deep nahin jaana hai .....itni bhi overthinking mat karo, bhai

This PH is not Leena and no one can be as ganda as Leena. Fact.

Everything is not about the same "predetermined outcome"....many factors were at play in Jhanak and it's not fair to keep applying the same to every show.

This show doesn't seem to have any scope for any romantic angle until the gen leap story jahaan pe they are showing college love story of grown FL.....so if Krushal has to play romantic hero, he will have to play the post gen leap wala hero of the FL only.....warna PAPPA banke hi ghoomega if he's signed on for the initial storyline which all revolves around the child from the get go....they won't show any exended parental love story angle then if main focus is on the child's struggles/stigma. So then he would only have signed on for a grey shaded role if that's the case.

Originally posted by: Alter_Eg0

Yep... I think both Hiba and Krushal can play negative roles very well!

Actually for a long time I wanted Krush to take up a complete negative character for his next project...but after realising KrusHi going through stress and trauma for their reel characters in Jhanak, I thought ok, a light hearted love story may be a good choice as next project..but chalo...I do think maintaining a continuous source of income is important to survive in this industry...at least when someone is new...eventually, with experience monetary situation improves and actors also reach a position in their career fo 'choose' scripts more freely...