Kumkum Bhagya New Season | Episode Discussions Thread 3 - Page 10

Originally posted by: TintedBlossom

Sonalika was speaking facts today. Nowhere I see her fault. If I were in her place, I would’ve reacted even worse and probably said far more hurtful things to Prart. Knowing the entire history, instead of walking away with dignity, she chose to stand there and give lectures about marriage and kumkum.. My foot!

In which century are these writers living? Inke hisaab se, marriage alone is enough to validate a relationship, even if there’s no love. But if there’s genuine love without marriage, it somehow becomes meaningless and inferior? .

I wonder if she had gotten married to Bhavesh, would she still consider it her Bhagya, Kumkum Bhagya?

@bold : Most probably, yes. I don't think she would have fallen in love with him, but I think she would have accepted her fate and fulfilled her duties as a wife / daughter-in-law.

Is it just me that’s annoyed that the writers have ignored essentially everything that occurred during the whole hospital terrorist attack, like prarthana risking her life to save shivansh and everything she said to him that he clearly heard and then him catching the sword to save her? Like their first interaction was so underwhelming after all of it and why show these scenes if it had no effect on their relationship. I think the writers are lazy and rather than establish are true connection and relationship between these two characters with their interactions they’re instead falling back on the concept of ‘kumkum bhagya’ and marriage but that doesn’t work as not only is it a marriage but on deceit, there’s no true relationship, just a small bond formed that the writers constantly break and reform at will.

Originally posted by: TintedBlossom

It didn’t seem like she was lying, her words were v convincing.
For me, Shiv is the one I blame the most in all of this. If revenge was all he ever cared about, then why did he even enter into a relationship in the first place? u wanted relationship and then u wanted revenge? Then what about the girl you used and betrayed in the process? Doesn’t he hold any moral responsibility towards her?
I’m not judging them for being consenting adults.. that’s not the issue here. What bothers me is realizing that all this time, Shiv wasn’t some helpless abla mard.. He was fully involved, fully willing nd no one was forcing him into any of this. It's just sad.

I don’t believe Sonalika cause that is her job to be convincing. Alright let’s assume what she says is true why is she telling this to Prarthana, to do what exactly, the girl owes her nothing. I never assumed Shiv was forced in the relationship but from their introduction I got no inkling that Shiv doesn’t loves Sona. I just thought they were two friends coming together cause it made sense since father is in business with Shiv or BM arranged it. We have no background information to say Shiv was forced knowing shiv do you really think he could be forced into anything he doesn’t want.

I don’t know but I’ll reserve judgment for now but I just can’t draw conclusions, based from a woman who is scorned and bitter. I know he’s anti-hero but that Shiv who spoke with pandit that he didn’t just respect it but wanted all reeti-riwaz and the gentle care he took for gath-bandhan, stood in front of strangers announcing how he’s a good man did all Sonalika is describing. Nah I can’t buy it

Ekta doesn’t screw up the core essence characters especially leads. ML may easily be manipulated by family and FL will be quiet and maybe after leap Jhansi ki Rani but still the sweetness and decency is there.

Originally posted by: HHRR

Is it just me that’s annoyed that the writers have ignored essentially everything that occurred during the whole hospital terrorist attack, like prarthana risking her life to save shivansh and everything she said to him that he clearly heard and then him catching the sword to save her? Like their first interaction was so underwhelming after all of it and why show these scenes if it had no effect on their relationship. I think the writers are lazy and rather than establish are true connection and relationship between these two characters with their interactions they’re instead falling back on the concept of ‘kumkum bhagya’ and marriage but that doesn’t work as not only is it a marriage but on deceit, there’s no true relationship, just a small bond formed that the writers constantly break and reform at will.do

The leads are sidelined by the the pack of villain and one of the lead showcasing stupid bravery by fighting alone for a relationship which is not her responsibility in the first place whereas the other lead who is responsible for all the mess is avoiding any confrontation and responsibility like a coward.

Originally posted by: Mrinmoyi_me

I never thought that I would be so disappointed with PraShiv scene after Shiv had woken up. Since Sona came they are just destroying all the bonding and growth PraShiv had and irritate us with damn kumkum bhagya. We know the show name they don't need to remind us that everyday.

The leads are sidelined by the the pack of villain and one of the lead showcasing stupid bravery by fighting alone for a relationship which is not her responsibility in the first place whereas the other lead who is responsible for all the mess is avoiding any confrontation and responsibility like a coward.

This is exactly how I feel! They fill the episodes with so much negativity and of the villains, who constantly succeed in their plans and give little of the leads. Not only that they’ve mostly ruined both lead characters and so their bonding and growth is ruined too. I’m struggling to watch it now because whilst I like the Pranali and Namik pairing, the writers have completely lost the plot

Originally posted by: HHRR

Is it just me that’s annoyed that the writers have ignored essentially everything that occurred during the whole hospital terrorist attack, like prarthana risking her life to save shivansh and everything she said to him that he clearly heard and then him catching the sword to save her? Like their first interaction was so underwhelming after all of it and why show these scenes if it had no effect on their relationship. I think the writers are lazy and rather than establish are true connection and relationship between these two characters with their interactions they’re instead falling back on the concept of ‘kumkum bhagya’ and marriage but that doesn’t work as not only is it a marriage but on deceit, there’s no true relationship, just a small bond formed that the writers constantly break and reform at will.

No no no. It did have an impact on Shivansh. Throughout today’s episode, he calculated the dynamics, and answered accordingly. His ‘I’ll sort it out’ has a different meaning. He’s just catering to BM and Tanya’s feelings. He’s smart, so he’ll work alone and figure stuff out. But this will lead to a misunderstanding. Prarthana is already tanking so much, Shivansh’s so called indifference will break her to the point she’ll leave or according to the bts, a clairvoyant’s words will force her to leave. All in all, her leaving will have the desired impact on Shivansh. He’ll realise his feelings, either confess or they start working together like a team instead of him being the lone warrior.

Originally posted by: TintedBlossom

Sonalika was speaking facts today. Nowhere I see her fault. If I were in her place, I would’ve reacted even worse and probably said far more hurtful things to Prart. Knowing the entire history, instead of walking away with dignity, she chose to stand there and give lectures about marriage and kumkum.. My foot!

In which century are these writers living? Inke hisaab se, marriage alone is enough to validate a relationship, even if there’s no love. But if there’s genuine love without marriage, it somehow becomes meaningless and inferior? .

I wonder if she had gotten married to Bhavesh, would she still consider it her Bhagya, Kumkum Bhagya?

We know Shiv wrong Sona and I even commented yesterday how embarrassed I was for her. Now with that being said why should Prarthana leave Shivansh, cause Sonalika wants her to do it. Who F is Sona to Prarthana, are they friends or some long lost behen. Has Sonalika tried to understand how Prarthana got caught up and accepted what fate has dealt her. Has Sona ever spoken to Prarthana with any form of respect, forget respect any form of decency as a human being. So again why the hell should Prarthana leave her pati, all Prarthana had gotten from her is bezzati, taunts and ego. I want Prarthana to leave even if she listens to BM, I rather she do it herself if Shiv not, but for Sona absolutely not

If Prarthana had married Bhavesh yes she would’ve talked about KKB caused she said it when Gayatri & Raunak was telling her not to married him or even meet to him alone. Prarthana is a pandit daughter you have doubts on her commitments

Let Sona go make demands to Shivansh, he wronged her and deceive her and if she can’t then heifer get out of Prarthana face and go pound sand. I hate entitled people

Namik isiliye toh underground nhi ho gya naa that he doesn't like this track? 😭 Socho guys socho,he was even though less,but was little bit active before chunalika's entry but now especially after this accident and hospital track, he's so underground and inactive era back again😭😭

Originally posted by: Mrinmoyi_me

I want a PraShiv

Dance scene

Rain scene

Shower Scene

Also I would like to see them getting married again

But I wanted to see jealous Shiv but I got doormat Prarthana.

I am actually Surprised Ekta Didnt use Namik's bare chest scenes to get eyeballs yet.

Common it’s Ekta’s show, she’ll be serving all of that in a golden platter. Now that she’s got hot leads, she’ll definitely bank upon them. My only fear is her knack for separating the couple. Bechare Abhigya, Pranbir, Rajvi sab bichde hue hai. Whatever happens, I only want PraShiv to be together in the end.

PS: Everybody is saying ki Prats is poor, low class and all, but man, her greatgramps is a rock star, Gramps is a business tycoon, even her dad is a business tycoon. Technically she’s from old money, probably higher in status by blood over all these minions. There should be a scene revealing all this so that she gets the damned respect she deserves and BM will be swerving lanes so fast.

Originally posted by: Afrinaparvin

Namik isiliye toh underground nhi ho gya naa that he doesn't like this track? 😭 Socho guys socho,he was even though less,but was little bit active before chunalika's entry but now especially after this accident and hospital track, he's so underground and inactive era back again😭😭

I think not having anything to do is also part of it. He was pretty active until he posted accident pics, he posted plenty of stories for hospital track to assure us that he's shooting and he posted that he finally has dialogs.