Mannat other version discussion thread - Page 25

Originally posted by: Moor278

One night stand

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Look at their smiles

https://x.com/KhadkaDeepali/status/1935765927959969983?t=hN1dAPSy0En4Y0gshQFFqA&s=19

I simply loved their scene. Their smiles were heartwarming. Gagan must’ve laughed wholeheartedly after such a long time. Loving their bond and I agree they shouldn’t flip his character when truth comes out🤞

Originally posted by: Moor278

Putting it here....

In OG, bio dad is blackmailing ARS to stop the wedding. She tries... but cant stop it. This is even after the kaand since bio dad knows Mannat and Vikrant love each other. He doesnt like Vikrant as a choice (also because the kaand truth is not out yet) but agrees for Mannat.

Malla is too obsessed and refuses to do this. Hindi Malla ka dresses and jewelry ka excitement is same as Turkish Malla.

Mannat has left the job and is working as a waitress in some hotel which Malla gets to know.

She deliberately plans the engagement there so that Mannat can see.

On the engagement evening, Neetu exposes her (courtesy Vikrants friend who has doubts on Malla)

They play a video recording where she accepts everything.

ARS is missing from this party because she is meeting bio dad who has asked her to have ONS in exchange for him going away permanently. When she reaches there he gives up and tells her I will make you fall in love with me again... but not this. ARS doesnt like it at all and refuses to indulge but gets a reality check when Malla says the same thing about Vikrant.

My interpretation on this is...

Vik will get drunk and Malla will follow OG situation. ARS will be missing as she would be with Mannat on the seashore.. or even at the hospital donating her liver. (I believe Mannat will barter that she will hide the maternity secret in exchange of liver ka tukda).

In the morning, either Vik will tell Mannat that some kaand has happened or someone else tells her and she might have to do detective giri to prove Vik innocent.

There have been too many instances where ManVik were together and he has not crossed a line... Mannat will indirectly demonstrate him ki bharose ko saboot ki jarurat nahi hoti……

I still have 2 questions... Sirf Malla ya Neetu ka sach bhi bahar aayega??? will they merge the two??? would love if this happens. Vik should atleast tell Ronnie about his memory loss.

Will Gagan also know that ARS is mom ya sirf Mannat???? Agar Gagan ko pata chala to phir aage kya?

Firstly - you’ve summarised the OG engagement track really well. I’d genuinely forgotten bio dad blackmailing ARS try to stop it and her accepting his proposition.

Your parallel to the Hindi and how the ONS plays out is very good.

It may be Shalini or I wouldn’t put it past Malla to tell Mannat the next morning, Vikku is going to be too confused & ashamed to face her. But yes I like how you’ve highlighed Mannat knows he has never crossed the line with her, given the ample instances, and she will know nothing happened.
bold - yes and now it will really sink in.

a) This track has unexpected exposed ARS so will likely only expose Malla’s ONS kaand and save Aman/Neetu’s for a little while yet to compete with BB or whatever is next. OR that big blockbuster will be the bio dad appearing?

b) Mannat has tried to shield Gagan’s from ARS, so I feel somehow she’ll try to keep Sonia truth from him for now? They’ve shown Gagan’s vulnerabilities over ARS this week and his strong bond with Mannat today but can’t see the benefit in him knowing, esp as the on-going ONS & Malla situation.

c) Malla won’t get to know Mannat is her sister yet either I feel.

My guess is Vikrant will get drunk after failing to find Mannat and wake up to ONS on his supposed wedding day. Lets say ARS agree to donate liver..wouldnt she ask Mannat to stay away? Would Mannat be in the headspace to think about Vikrant or anything else after everything that happened?

In the promo, Mannat and ARS are back to where it all started, the seashore, for Shruti liver. Vikrant is the only one missing, how he will be connected in this I am still not sure.

Frankly I had forgotten the blackmail parallel too.

All I remembered was ARS was missing when Mallas expose happened. So I went back and checked.

Thats when I realised the parallel that Mannat blackmailing ARS is ideologically similar to OG.

Now it depends on who will expose Malla.

By OG it should be Ronnie (since they swapped Neeti Ronnie here) and the friend could be Sammy or Shalini but I would love if its Punnu.

While I do feel Mannat might trust him... for once I dont want her to do anything to prove him innocent.

Although he needs to tell her its all fake. That much he has to do.

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

My guess is Vikrant will get drunk after failing to find Mannat and wake up to ONS on his supposed wedding day. Lets say ARS agree to donate liver..wouldnt she ask Mannat to stay away? Would Mannat be in the headspace to think about Vikrant or anything else after everything that happened?

In the promo, Mannat and ARS are back to where it all started, the seashore, for Shruti liver. Vikrant is the only one missing, how he will be connected in this I am still not sure.

Bold... even if Mannat agrees to go away... thats fine... we all know she will come back by some way 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Blue... I had the same thought... he needs to be on the seashore if this is parallel to the first promo... maybe he is... drinking and all... but cant see them... who knows 🤷🏻‍♀️

Vikrant and Mannat were at the seashore when she found out about her birth mother. ARS was not there.

He may not have to be physically there, but something will change for sure.

A risky scenario..will the connection they built end with Mannat finding out Sonia truth?

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

Vikrant and Mannat were at the seashore when she found out about her birth mother. ARS was not there.

He may not have to be physically there, but something will change for sure.

A risky scenario..will the connection they built end with Mannat finding out Sonia truth?

I had that thought until I saw the kaand article.

In fact I was wondering if Vik will go into sulking mode if he thinks Mannat was in SM for something else and not him... and that she probably never loved him or something...

But then this Malla kaand points to something else. Lets see

Disclaimer: I am not an overtly religious person, nor superstitious... but as a Hindu married woman I understand the emotions and significance of these rituals...

This is based on what the makers have shown us in the episode telecast...

Here's the theory I have been cooking since panmasala wedding was confirmed last week.

There are few observations everybody has about the show so far

1. Fate plays a big role in Mannat and Vikrants life.

2. Vikrant doesnt trust Mannat easily... he always supports his family... has blind faith on them and goes against Mannat.

3.Vikrant's all the love and care and declarations for Mannat have mostly happened when they are alone or he is alone. he is different person around Mannat.. and as episodes progress we see he is very different from RS family as well.

4. Nobody in the house cares about his feelings... all they want is to fulfill their own motives through him.

That said... the theory I have been working on... why did the makers show elaborate rituals for ManVik in the garb of ViMal wedding.... only to have ManVik wedding not happening in real sense but ViMal getting through inspite of Malla spoiling all her rasms.

Even the latest one of grah pravesh has happened for Mannat and not Malla. There might be a pehli rasoi next week.

So the theory is... like the Pandit said... it was an auspicious moment for the couple to bond and whosoever does it, gets married. Some folks have dismissed it but Mannat and Vikrant had a blood sindoor ritual at exactly that moment... so in a way, they are married secretly... just like all their rituals have happened privately.

This could be because... point no 1... fate plays a big role... it was in their destiny to get married at that point... but there's a catch... the person, the physical body and the emotions are Aman and not Vikrant.... Vikrant Saluja is dead since 23-24 years.... what exists is Aman... a living breathing human who has intense emotions for Mannat.

He has an identity given to him by Neetu and Ronnie... to suffice for their own loss.... Vikrant Saluja is not real.... he is a mirage... something that RoTu have kept alive all these years due to their trauma...

This is same entity/mirage/illusion that ARS wants for Malla... the same illusion Malla wants to claim from Mannat because she feels she cant be outsmarted by a plain girl like Mannat. As per point no 4... none care for his feelings... neither RoTu nor ARS Malla... they want to claim him for their own benefit. His emotions which are of a living being are ignored and manipulated.

So when the rituals completed and the blood sindoor happened it was between Mannat and Aman.... but on the surface it was for Vikrant and Malla... an identity she badly wants to be associated with... hence the jaap of MVS.

Vikrant Saluja the way he is ... is bound by intense devotion and blind trust to his family, because he is told he is Saluja and belongs to them and should not accept anyone who breaks his family. ARS and Neetu know this and exploit this... that's why neither are ever shown worried ki what would happen if Vik starts investigating on his own... they know he wont.... they manipulate that... blame and blackmail him and question his motives for Mannat which ends with him shouting at her and mistrust of her ... point no 2.

For Vikrant to truly see his family and the way they play around he needs to come out of his shell... which is the identity of Vikrant Saluja... Aman has to resurface and reborn... for him to take control over the situation and his emotions... for that Vik has to die... metaphorically... Vikrant the boy has died already... but the identity that Aman has got... has to go.... his truth needs to come out for him to see how he has been played around.

his world is going to come crashing down and everything that he has known or every relationship he has cherished will turn out fake.

Now, all the rituals of the wedding happened in private because like the rituals, Aman is also hidden... but it was in his fate that he get married at this stage in his life, at that moment... hence point no 3.

When Mannat met him for the first time, they met at a gurudwara, just like when Aman was going for his ardas... they didnt even exchange names, they need not ... Mannat didnt meet Vikrant Saluja... she met her BKB... BKB goes into action when Mannat is unsafe and vice versa... maybe a threat to any of them now will trigger Aman's memories.

He behaves differently around her... and he himself has said it and observed by others... and the audience.

Now when Aman/Vik is completely broken and desolate... it would take some help from Mannat and probably some fate for Aman to start coming out... Once he knows the truth, Vik/Aman can then rethink over why his family hid the truth and kept him away from Mannat... and why should he even bother to listen to them (point no 2 and 4)

Vikrant Saluja may never see sense in Mannat (no 2) but Aman will... and Aman will be the one to bring her back with full rights... or maybe start living away from RS family...

Now to those who think this is incest/EMA/jija saali and what not...

Understand point no 1 through this....

Vikrant Saluja doesnt exist... what exists is Aman... the tangible body..

Malla is married to a guy who is dead...

So this is technically none of the names called...

Had fate played a role differently and boy Vikrant was alive... Malla would have still married him and Mannat would have married Aman (who was linked to her on her birth)... there would have been 2 different persons physically...

That's what I mean when I say this ViMal wedding doesnt bother me anymore .... its linked to an identity and not a real person...

and seeing how they have built the story for Aish and Mallas motives... it is obvious they are bothered only about Vikrants money...as Aish dismissively said... gali ke kutte se bhi pyar ho jaata hai...

Once they get to know Vikrant Saluja is penniless, they will discard him too...

Mannat is linked to Aman by her fate... due to Aishs actions, who was Sonia Khanna then and not RaiSingh... Shruti kept Mannat safe when Aman wasnt around and Aman/BKB kept her safe when Shruti wasnt around...

Now that both of them are back... Mannat is fiercer and stronger... a matter of time before Aman is back!!!

Linking it to Muktas caption... Mannat will show a broken Aman how to love again, ru-b-ru karayegi ... when he would have all but lost everything.

I feel they could have still gotten away without the wedding... but then they didnt even focus on it much... thats an insignificant part of the story right now...

another reason why this could have happened though is they have changed the timelines from OG... like in the Mannat 2.0 track... all the talk is about money... Malla's kaand would have made no sense after Amans truth is out.... but the change to bring it parallel to ARS=Sonia might have necessitated some changes... and of course TRP pressure.

Tagging all of you since I have added some elements.....

Feel free to disagree please.... this is keeping me sane for my viewing experience... i hope it does to the few of you.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Disclaimer: I am not an overtly religious person, nor superstitious... but as a Hindu married woman I understand the emotions and significance of these rituals...

This is based on what the makers have shown us in the episode telecast...

Here's the theory I have been cooking since panmasala wedding was confirmed last week.

There are few observations everybody has about the show so far

1. Fate plays a big role in Mannat and Vikrants life.

2. Vikrant doesnt trust Mannat easily... he always supports his family... has blind faith on them and goes against Mannat.

3.Vikrant's all the love and care and declarations for Mannat have mostly happened when they are alone or he is alone. he is different person around Mannat.. and as episodes progress we see he is very different from RS family as well.

4. Nobody in the house cares about his feelings... all they want is to fulfill their own motives through him.

That said... the theory I have been working on... why did the makers show elaborate rituals for ManVik in the garb of ViMal wedding.... only to have ManVik wedding not happening in real sense but ViMal getting through inspite of Malla spoiling all her rasms.

Even the latest one of grah pravesh has happened for Mannat and not Malla. There might be a pehli rasoi next week.

So the theory is... like the Pandit said... it was an auspicious moment for the couple to bond and whosoever does it, gets married. Some folks have dismissed it but Mannat and Vikrant had a blood sindoor ritual at exactly that moment... so in a way, they are married secretly... just like all their rituals have happened privately.

This could be because... point no 1... fate plays a big role... it was in their destiny to get married at that point... but there's a catch... the person, the physical body and the emotions are Aman and not Vikrant.... Vikrant Saluja is dead since 23-24 years.... what exists is Aman... a living breathing human who has intense emotions for Mannat.

He has an identity given to him by Neetu and Ronnie... to suffice for their own loss.... Vikrant Saluja is not real.... he is a mirage... something that RoTu have kept alive all these years due to their trauma...

This is same entity/mirage/illusion that ARS wants for Malla... the same illusion Malla wants to claim from Mannat because she feels she cant be outsmarted by a plain girl like Mannat. As per point no 4... none care for his feelings... neither RoTu nor ARS Malla... they want to claim him for their own benefit. His emotions which are of a living being are ignored and manipulated.

So when the rituals completed and the blood sindoor happened it was between Mannat and Aman.... but on the surface it was for Vikrant and Malla... an identity she badly wants to be associated with... hence the jaap of MVS.

Vikrant Saluja the way he is ... is bound by intense devotion and blind trust to his family, because he is told he is Saluja and belongs to them and should not accept anyone who breaks his family. ARS and Neetu know this and exploit this... that's why neither are ever shown worried ki what would happen if Vik starts investigating on his own... they know he wont.... they manipulate that... blame and blackmail him and question his motives for Mannat which ends with him shouting at her and mistrust of her ... point no 2.

For Vikrant to truly see his family and the way they play around he needs to come out of his shell... which is the identity of Vikrant Saluja... Aman has to resurface and reborn... for him to take control over the situation and his emotions... for that Vik has to die... metaphorically... Vikrant the boy has died already... but the identity that Aman has got... has to go.... his truth needs to come out for him to see how he has been played around.

his world is going to come crashing down and everything that he has known or every relationship he has cherished will turn out fake.

Now, all the rituals of the wedding happened in private because like the rituals, Aman is also hidden... but it was in his fate that he get married at this stage in his life, at that moment... hence point no 3.

When Mannat met him for the first time, they met at a gurudwara, just like when Aman was going for his ardas... they didnt even exchange names, they need not ... Mannat didnt meet Vikrant Saluja... she met her BKB... BKB goes into action when Mannat is unsafe and vice versa... maybe a threat to any of them now will trigger Aman's memories.

He behaves differently around her... and he himself has said it and observed by others... and the audience.

Now when Aman/Vik is completely broken and desolate... it would take some

help from Mannat and probably some fate for Aman to start coming out... Once he knows the truth, Vik/Aman can then rethink over why his family hid the truth and kept him away from Mannat... and why should he even bother to listen to them (point no 2 and 4)

Vikrant Saluja may never see sense in Mannat (no 2) but Aman will... and Aman will be the one to bring her back with full rights... or maybe start living away from RS family...

Now to those who think this is incest/EMA/jija saali and what not...

Understand point no 1 through this....

Vikrant Saluja doesnt exist... what exists is Aman... the tangible body..

Malla is married to a guy who is dead...

So this is technically none of the names called...

Had fate played a role differently and boy Vikrant was alive... Malla would have still married him and Mannat would have married Aman (who was linked to her on her birth)... there would have been 2 different persons physically...

That's what I mean when I say this ViMal wedding doesnt bother me anymore .... its linked to an identity and not a real person...

and seeing how they have built the story for Aish and Mallas motives... it is obvious they are bothered only about Vikrants money...as Aish dismissively said... gali ke kutte se bhi pyar ho jaata hai...

Once they get to know Vikrant Saluja is penniless, they will discard him too...

Mannat is linked to Aman by her fate... due to Aishs actions, who was Sonia Khanna then and not RaiSingh... Shruti kept Mannat safe when Aman wasnt around and Aman/BKB kept her safe when Shruti wasnt around...

Now that both of them are back... Mannat is fiercer and stronger... a matter of time before Aman is back!!!

Linking it to Muktas caption... Mannat will show a broken Aman how to love again, ru-b-ru karayegi ... when he would have all but lost everything.

I feel they could have still gotten away without the wedding... but then they didnt even focus on it much... thats an insignificant part of the story right now...

another reason why this could have happened though is they have changed the timelines from OG... like in the Mannat 2.0 track... all the talk is about money... Malla's kaand would have made no sense after Amans truth is out.... but the change to bring it parallel to ARS=Sonia might have necessitated some changes... and of course TRP pressure.

Tagging all of you since I have added some elements.....

Feel free to disagree please.... this is keeping me sane for my viewing experience... i hope it does to the few of you.

Moor 🫂❤❤❤...I'm so happy after reading this ..I know it can be our delusions ..but to some extent its the truth...the one who malla and ARS wants is VIKRANT SALUJA ..and they got him..but the soulmate of mannat is not vikku ..its only AMAN ..from the day she born ..Aman ne usse protect kiya tha not Vikrant ...

Mallika Vikrant Saluja is an illustration...because legally a person named Vikrant Saluja doesn't exist...that little boy died years ago.. Neetu and Ronnie doesn't legally adopted Aman they just replaced him with their son and fled to London...so when the truth will come out there will be only Aman ..and Aman belongs to Mannat ❤

And I'm also happy that makers doesn't even focused on this wedding..they didn't give much importance to it ..aage bhi aisa hi rahee