Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 16 - Page 114

Originally posted by: Moor278

@Sai

I agree on point no 3 somewhat...

Mannat has never tried to find out why Neetu is giving the medicine... she herself is aware how much Neetu loves Vik... so why would she harm her own son? Ek baar bhi nahi socha???

She did say earlier and even today that I don't know why Neetu is doing this...

To behen jab tere haath medicine lagi thi to test karvati???? Kisi Doctor se poochti ki ye kya hai???

Dustbin main kyun daal diya... ya Vikku ko hi de deti ki dekho tumhari Maa ke purse main mila... ab ise check karao

This is simply an exercise in increasing episode number 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Originally posted by: Moor278

@bold is exactly what I feel he is doing... and thats why I can give him some leeway...

@red... I am surprised 😆😆😆

@blue... perfectly put 👏

I am surprised myself yaar… I was like what’s happening with me … kahin meine bhi Vikrant ki tarah apna bheja fry kardiya hai!!

Seriously though I am hoping and praying writers actually have a full plan… otherwise it will be like Vikrants ring (black one) that Mannat is still hiding in her chef uniform… like tge tracks where Gagan was going to help out revealing ARS truth

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

I don’t agree that episode are dragging …. They are finally bringing Mallas character out…

Like I said Vikrant cannot just expect Mannat to confess when he has not been able to trust her or convince his mom that Mannat is who he loves. He is truly living in lalaland … in his defense he’s in love and he’s not able to think anything other then Mannat!!! It’s hard to explain I feel bad for Vikrant and at same time I feel kya gadha hai. How many times people in love have always thought ek baar woh haan karde mein apni mom/parents koh mana lunga

regarding this ARS and Mannats spy attitude… it’s only to be seen on what Mannat really wants!!

I thought I won’t enjoy episodes but to the contrary I am liking how they are addressing some basic foundational issues on two people falling in love…. Just because destiny brought them together doesn’t mean they get it all easily!

trust and don’t ever let third person intervene … those are what I feel is the motto now!!

@red have to give where it's due.... Mannath team are really doing well to keep audience glue in boring tracks too compared to other shows

I agree with all the points. Am playing the devil's advocate here.

I do agree, that they are laying a strong foundation for trust between Manvik. I love it. In fact this used to be the grouse in Lost, why does the FL, always need to give proof to prove her point. but there's also...how come everyone else get that trust and not the FL?? This an age old Desi TV trope.

- Trusting neetu - my logic has always been the same from the start. Trust your mom because that's how it should be. But the fact is his health has been off, and he needs to investigate at least his own health. if even to prove that Mannat is wrong about his mother..that is all Mannat is asking. Something is wrong with his health, at least trust that one fact Mannat is saying. That itself might bring out the fact, that he is being poisoned. And then he can investigate that poison.

- And asking Mannat to apologise unconditionally, that is not done.

- Trust Malla because he knows her from childhood, they have played hide & seek together. Plus, she is Mannat's best friend. But don't agree to hurt the person you love, blindly. Think of the person you love too. Again, it's not about reciprocation, it is just about your love, and how you can't see her getting hurt.

And definitely , he needs to put his foot down strongly at insulting Mannat. That doesn't need any justification...love or no love, trust or no trust.

He pulled up Malla for insulting Sammy initially. That is Vikrant!

I am going to get chappals because I am really annoyed with Vikrant today. So let me just go full throttle.

What is with threatening to kick her out of her job every second sentence?? Dialogue writers are also on leave looks like.

And Mannat is being idiot number 1. Her plan is totally a flop plan.

Ok..bye. Am running now...

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

I am surprised myself yaar… I was like what’s happening with me … kahin meine bhi Vikrant ki tarah apna bheja fry kardiya hai!!

Seriously though I am hoping and praying writers actually have a full plan… otherwise it will be like Vikrants ring (black one) that Mannat is still hiding in her chef uniform… like tge tracks where Gagan was going to help out revealing ARS truth

Gagan ka blood stained hanky to gaya Mannat land ke black hole main

The job threatening bit is getting on my nerves too... bahot jyada ho gaya hai...

The only solution to this is make her Maalkin of that job

Originally posted by: scarlett22

I agree with all the points. Am playing the devil's advocate here.

I do agree, that they are laying a strong foundation for trust between Manvik. I love it. In fact this used to be the grouse in Lost, why does the FL, always need to give proof to prove her point. but there's also...how come everyone else get that trust and not the FL?? This an age old Desi TV trope.

- Trusting neetu - my logic has always been the same from the start. Trust your mom because that's how it should be. But the fact is his health has been off, and he needs to investigate at least his own health. if even to prove that Mannat is wrong about his mother..that is all Mannat is asking. Something is wrong with his health, at least trust that one fact Mannat is saying. That itself might bring out the fact, that he is being poisoned. And then he can investigate that poison.

- And asking Mannat to apologise unconditionally, that is not done.

- Trust Malla because he knows her from childhood, they have played hide & seek together. Plus, she is Mannat's best friend. But don't agree to hurt the person you love, blindly. Think of the person you love too. Again, it's not about reciprocation, it is just about your love, and how you can't see her getting hurt.

And definitely , he needs to put his foot down strongly at insulting Mannat. That doesn't need any justification...love or no love, trust or no trust.

He pulled up Malla for insulting Sammy initially. That is Vikrant!

I am going to get chappals because I am really annoyed with Vikrant today. So let me just go full throttle.

What is with threatening to kick her out of her job every second sentence?? Dialogue writers are also on leave looks like.

And Mannat is being idiot number 1. Her plan is totally a flop plan.

Ok..bye. Am running now...

Mannat basically expected Vikrant to atleast investigate or take care if his health.

Her intention was never to go full fledged against Neetu & hence she first confronted her in the kitchen otherwise she would have started shouting & saying bad stuff against her in the Drawing room itself. Thanks to Keerat that day that Neetu vs Mannat. Had already mentioned how Keerat had a wicked smile on her face as she & ARS both wanted her to be thrown of SM by hook or crook.

Also Mannat had a smile when Vikrant told Neetu that humare beech mei koi nai aayega. So her intention was never to do anything bad to Neetu.

Mannat did try her best to confront Neetu patiently & tried to know the reason but its obvious she won't accept.

I am not even blaming Vikrant for reacting that way on Mannat in front of everyone. His reaction was justified from his POV but atleast banda try to karein khud se sochne ka. Here writing is the issue, not blaming the actors. Each is acing his/her role. We are just continously getting love related thought process of Vikrant & nothing else.

Juice glass kyu break ho rha hai, Malla aise kyu behave kar rai hai, ek bhi question Vikrant's ke dimaag mei nai aa rha. Abhi toh Khair he is so engrossed in love but we have seen this happening before. Only when situation goes completed out of hand he does something. This is bad writing honestly...

Also, If he is expecting trust, then he needs to trust her too. Abhi itna toh woh close hai ki for few things he can trust her. They have now spent considerable amount of time together & are not just boss employee anymore. If not 100 percent trust atleast try to find out something from your end too.

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Frustrating episode. Mainly because, everyone seems to be jumping in the same place. I can't make out head nor tail of which conspiracy is going to be unearthed..each one is making very half hearted, pointless, and may I add, brainless efforts.

- Vikrant has thought of this wonderful, experiential method of proving how trustworthy he is, by asking Mannat to jump into his arms, from a height!! Mannu gives it to him, teaches him by another example of what trust means. She also asks him if he loves Malla, now he wants to know why she wants to know if he loves Malla, why does she doubt it. Convo goes nowhere.

- Neetu is determinedly trying to give her tablet to Vikku. And walks menacingly towards the store room. Mannu acts like her normal clumsy, vague self and knocks it over.

- Malla is being her villainous self, plans the chunri kaand, and laughs like one of Ekta's old villains. Kya yaar?? Where is the modern touch to this show? And just her saying 'Aww, aww' at every sentence someone speaks doesn't show her contemporary, London returned persona.

- Neetu and Ronnie have an argument. Ronnies warns her that she's going to destroy Vikku's life by getting him married to Malla.

- Mannat finds Neetu's little bag, and throws out the medicine.

- Engagement evening...Vikku smiles happily, but obviously to make up for it, the director makes him look for Mannat, Ronnie notices.

- Malla sees Mannat walking out and wants to stop her because her plan needs to work...'Awww'.

I can give you guys tomorrow's update.

Malla will call Mannat on some pretext. Chunri will be discovered, Mannat will be blamed. Neetu will bad mouth her, Ronnie will look upset, Gagan will look upset and acc to the BTS, he at least vocally supports Mannat. ARS will add her bit. Vikku will stand, looking stunned, and in his mind he will say " Bol do, Ms Mannat, ki tumhe mujhpe bharosa hai, phir dekhna, main tumhe duniya ki saari khushiyaan de doonga".

And only when Neetu tries to throw her out the door, he will wake up out of his stupor and stop.

There will be a Manvik scene and conversation that increasingly I feel is manipulating us to watch the episodes. No Manvik conversation had led to Vikrant using his grey cells , in this track.

Sorry for the rant...now the repeated tropes are irritating. Are the writers on leave?? Why are all the scenes written in such a listless manner. Like they have been copied and pasted, with a few cosmetic changes.

I love this team, if they are stalking us, but they are truly taking fans too much for granted.

I blame the writing team completely, the actors are all doing their jobs very well. They have so many open tracks, and they are not moving forward even on one track. Nor are they giving us an indication of any new track.

Other top shows move so quickly into different tracks...I hate to compare. but I also know that this team is excellent and even if they do move into different tracks, they will excel, and be much better than others.

But why this bored kind of writing???

Tomorrow’s episode will go exactly the way you described.

Vikrant needs to get his grey cells out of his pants and back into his head. What is this nonsense about getting Mannat to confess?? When it has been abundantly clear that she will not come in the way like a third wheel.

I think even this new director sucks. Writing ke baare mein matt pucho!

Episodes are becoming repetitive, abusive and boring.

They better start closing the various open tracks and give this show some direction. The 3 witches are beyond tiresome. The very sight of the 3 of them is tiresome.

I think TRP will be 0.9-1.0

So a question folks....

In the BTS I shared yesterday ... where Vik calls her kabab main haddi...

He is talking to Malla and Mannat calls to cross check if he is indeed... he gets the notification and then comes over says the haddi bit.

It didnt make it to the episode... I am glad in a way... calling her haddi was stupid.

Question is what does it make Mannat look like???

A. If she calls and cross checks... thats her doubt creeping in and she wants to know if ViMal are indeed a pair???

B. Or she is getting jealous as per the plan 🤦‍♀️

C. Since it didnt make it to the episode... does it mean Mannat is taking everything at face value and not using her brains??? Not pondering over Viks obvious flirting and throwing hints at her??? If it is, then why did she questioned him today if he loves Malla? There was a doubt there certainly.

D. Continuing with point C... does it mean she believes Malla completely as well??? And therefore can be easily manipulated. And will continue to believe Malla if Vikku comes clean?

I am confused ki Mannat ke perspective se ye kya hai 🤔

Originally posted by: Moor278

@Sai

I agree on point no 3 somewhat...

Mannat has never tried to find out why Neetu is giving the medicine... she herself is aware how much Neetu loves Vik... so why would she harm her own son? Ek baar bhi nahi socha???

She did say earlier and even today that I don't know why Neetu is doing this...

To behen jab tere haath medicine lagi thi to test karvati???? Kisi Doctor se poochti ki ye kya hai???

Dustbin main kyun daal diya... ya Vikku ko hi de deti ki dekho tumhari Maa ke purse main mila... ab ise check karao

This is simply an exercise in increasing episode number 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

RIP ITV logic 🙏