Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 12 - Page 43

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

67.6k

Users

29

Likes

7.7k

Frequent Posters

Lipstickqueen thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 months ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Detailed review for 6th May episode.

I loved the symbolism they used throughout the episode. The writers dipped into their own content quite wisely.

If there's one thing about this show is nothing is random... everything everywhere is connected. smiley27


Mukta knows very well how to tap into the audience... so the quack doctor turned out to be an Ayurvedic Doctor probably to pacify TRP aunties who believe in alternative medicine and power of prayers. smiley27

There was Mannat traumatized due to the thunder... but her BKBs words gave her strength to sail through this toofan... literally and figuratively... Mannat fought with her inner demons throughout the night and willed herself to save Vikrant. The magic of prayers be it Gurbani or Ronnies call for Vikrant's safety or Gurav Baba's prayer ... Vikrant got better in a matter of few hours.

ManVik are now becoming each others BKB.... With their bond, it looks like Mannat will be the one to help him fight his own demons when he is made aware of his truth smiley27.


His half awake state where he sees an anxious Mannat gently caring for him and him reaching to cup her cheek was a beautiful parallel to the freezer situation where Vikrant did the same for her. Even in his half dazed state he could make out the comforting touch and latched on to her in panic ... small detail but so powerful.smiley27


Ronnies car delay meant Mannat could care for Vikrant alone and he got to see his janam peacefully sleeping on his chest smiley2. His first instinct to check his surroundings and her shows his alertness and protective spirit... that sweet smile on seeing Mannat nuzzling closer to him was too good (putting a pause on all the 18+ khayals here smiley36)

Neetu comes in and pulls Mannat away and then the infamous slap situation happens at Saluja mansion ...

BTW Gagan too has people on his beck and call... pehle kyun nahi kiya bhai?smiley6

Although per OG, mujhe Gagan ke liye dar lag raha hai ... Makers... please use mat marna smiley19... he needs to be kept alive... usko memory loss de do chaho to ya phir coma... but please keep him alive smiley6


I wrote earlier that I felt bad for Neetu...

The writers and creatives are totally focusing on Nature vs Nurture angle on this show....

There's Neetu who is not biological mother to Vikrant yet her maternal instincts are so on point, she senses the danger for him but doesnt realise it is herself ... unfortunately these might also be the key to Ronnie turning against Mannat smiley19

and then there's ARS who literally wishes to kill her biological daughter... simply so that she continue with her lavish lifestyle. smiley7

Another reason is... Neetu is clearly suffering from some mental illness.... and its unfortunately not diagnosed. Keerat Raveena and ARS... all of them know about her weakness and they are manipulating her on that ... for their own personal gain. Neetu's possessiveness has now turned into a paranoia. smiley18

In previous episodes... ARS blamed Neetu for breaking the engagement... Keerat blamed her for not choosing Malla and preferring Mannat... Keerat also played on her fears that Vikrant is making memories with Mannat and not her .... Raveenas threats are well known and now Malla has smartened up on this game too and behaves like a good girl in front of Neetu.

All of them are actually cruelly playing with Neetus fragile state of mind and twisting her thoughts... putting her into a rabbit hole. smiley18... Neetu was always introduced as a bit crazy, all the ladies are now openly targeting that weakness of hers.

I absolutely do not agree on her drugging Vikrant... but she has gone beyond rational thoughts... Neetu did not break the engagement... it was Vikrant who refused to go ahead and it was not because of Mannat... there were no such feelings in him then for Mannat. He simply did not want someone like Malla as his wife....

now all the ladies are trying to make Neetu look guilty and Mannat as the cause of it which serves both their purposes ... which the disturbed Neetu is unfortunately projecting on Mannat... she blames her for causing trouble for Vikrant when she forgets it was he who wanted to go to Ratnagiri, not Mannat.

Only thing I didn't get... and since this was different in OG is... Mannat is not the one who is bringing back his memories... there's no connection like that...they could have changed it... but as I said... Neetus fears are legitimate... unfortunately Ronnie will agree with her too ... When Mannat explained Vikrants morning breakdown he looked shocked and probably thought that Neetu is after all right.

thankfully he still finds time to thank Mannat and ensure her safety.


I am no doctor or psychologist but the Shalini track resolution gives me hope.... I hope Mukta addresses this that mental illness is not to be taken lightly... any kind of odd behavior needs to be taken into serious consideration.

Neetu is not that different from Shruti who went to lengths to hide the truth from Mannat, both the adopted mothers have this fear and immense love for their children.. but that fear is making them do wrongs, questioning their own nurtures ... Neetu is quickly losing a grip on reality and I hope the makers have some plan for this... a situation like this where she is harming her own son who she loves so passionately is not a thing to be ignored.

They need to make some kind of statement on this somewhere in future!!!!

We can only hope!


P.S. for once Adnan broke character while the camera was on... he scrunched his face when the raindrops were hitting him. smiley17... and this could be the scene where Ayesha got to know about his ticklish situation smiley36.. there was a faint smile on her face when she was rubbing his hands.

Your reasoning and logic is on point and if I hadn’t seen Neetu in action then I might have agreed with you. She clearly has a mental illness but drugging your child so he doesn’t learn the truth about what happened that night? Sorry no. I know she loves Vikrant but a mother’s love does not give you license to cause irreparable harm to your son. She knows she has a problem. Why not talk to your husband? A doctor?

And any woman who raises her hand against another - when she has no right to do so - especially someone else’s daughter? Not done. Especially when that daughter has her own mother in a hospital bed and saved your son’s life!

Mannat is being shown as the scapegoat for all the crappy choices these women have made. And make no mistake they were choices. And with those come consequences.

Edited by Lipstickqueen - 6 months ago
purplegirl7 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team Mannat

Posted: 6 months ago

Both Shruti and Neetu are driven by fear and did wrong but for different reason. Neetu fears losing Vikrant and is harming him knowingly. Shruti fears for Mannat's life and was trying to protect her from ARS. Maybe she underestimated ARS or was confident about herself, but ARS found out the truth and is after Mannat's life.

I dont get the 'questioning their own nurtures' part

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 6 months ago

Exactly what I wrote on why I feel bad for Neetu smiley27

We are resonating again smiley31

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 6 months ago

I completely agree... she should not drug him at all... and telling the truth to Vikrant is out of question for both of them... even Ronnie who is sensible is not thinking on these lines...

@lipstick... I dont think she understands she has a problem... she thinks its her maa ki mamta... dont think Ronnie has realized it either... maybe he will if he gets to know Neetu is drugging Vik.


All I am saying is... Neetus illness needs to be addressed by the makers ... I hope they dont brush it under the carpet.. and with so much focus.. I hope they really do take it up...


In OG, her mental illness is known and Ronnie repeatedly warns her to control her behaviour... he tells her I wont put you in the mental hospital for propriety sake... only if you agree to manage your behavior... Neetu agrees.... this is after few of her kaands...

So expect more crazy behaviour from hindi Neetu as well...


Mannat is a ITV FL... scapegoat to vahi banegi... usme koi choice nahi hai

Edited by Moor278 - 6 months ago
Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 6 months ago

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

I dont get the 'questioning their own nurtures' part

they should trust their own upbringing na... why are Neetu and Shruti worried that their kids would leave them? Neetu doesnt trust Vikrants intelligence kya? or Shruti believes Mannat is turning into Sonia?

Both the mothers are panicking...

purplegirl7 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team Mannat

Posted: 6 months ago

Shruti was worried Mannat would leave her and turn into Sonia? When?

Neetu doesnt trust Vikrants intelligence about what?

Moor, you are confusing me more😅

Moor278 thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 6 months ago

Originally posted by: purplegirl7

Shruti was worried Mannat would leave her and turn into Sonia? When?

Neetu doesnt trust Vikrants intelligence about what?

Moor, you are confusing me more😅

Shruti was worried Mannat would leave her and turn into Sonia?... not leave her... but Mannat at one point was impressed by ARS that Shruti remarked to herself that she is behaving like Sonia... even in the intro episode when Mannat speaks about earning lots of money... Shruti recalls the same statement from Sonia.

After the mooh kala... Mannat has lost all admiration for ARS... but Shruti doesnt know that

Neetu doesnt trust Vikrants intelligence meaning... why cant she tell him the truth? Is he so dumb that he wont be able to handle it or is he so thankless that he cant see how much Neetu Ronnie love him? his mothers death from what we saw was accidental... Neetu did not kill her... why is she not trusting his good nature and intelligence?

Edited by Moor278 - 6 months ago
truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 6 months ago

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

Thank you for the tag Trupti , I always look forward to your update/review which I like to read before I watch the episode so I know what to watch out for 😉

Also love your star scores at the end! As a biased fellow Adnan fan, it brings an extra smile when he gets your vote 🥰 you should keep a running tally 😂

Off to watch the episode now……

Awww! That’s so sweet of you to say this You look forward to my review before watching episode 🤗

About star score IDK that I started when I was on Saraswatichandra forum. I think from that time I do that. Yes I am Adnan fan but I do appreciate others also when I like their performances.

I should take your advice of running tally😜.

Hope you enjoyed the episode ❤️

truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 6 months ago

Originally posted by: Resham

Finally caught up with the episode ....I loved Manvik scenes....special shoutout to Ayesha who performed really well in her panic mode....the way she fights back to the shivers thanks to her BKB words was so well done by the girl ...the entire rain sequence and the Gaurav Kaka scene was nicely weaved here....I loved the soothing Manvik here....both are each other's support ....Adnan gave the right expressions of his tremor regarding Aman....

Gaggu is on his way to find out the truth of ARS but I doubt she will be exposed this soon....but Mona was brilliant in bringing that fear across....I ignored Neetu and didn't care about her fears...I want Aman truth to unfold and see Neetu cry ..sadist me here....

Felt really sad for Mannat...poor girl is left all alone but this is what the trend has been on ITV....until the FL is all alone the makers don't feel the steam.....anyways ..now wait for the episode until night again ...

Thanks Trupti for the tag....could view the episode through your update ..waiting for Moors analysis.....

I wish they would have retained HDDCS track..that song is itself soothing and apt for Manvik ...

Bold- completely agree on this. IDT that she Will exposed so soon that’s what I said. Looks like Gagan will come across Vikrant’s past if he tests that blood on ARS’s car. Yes Aman’s truth should come out and let Neetu suffer for what she is doing to that poor kid in the name of love😡

HDDCS track same sentiments yaar! Wish they could’ve kept that song. Like you said it’s apt for ManVik. Without any expectations or obligations they are always there for each other no matter what❤️

Selfless love that’s what makes ManVik more adorable. I hope they both realise it soon what they mean to each other🤞

@ Moor

Don’t worry. I am with you regarding Neetu. TBH I did feel bad for in car. She was so worried for her kid. Had nagging feeling that something must’ve bad happened to her kid. Being a mother it was so relatable.

In that moment I felt sympathetic towards her But next moment all my sympathy vanished when she gave that medicine to Vikrant 🤬.

On top of that she slapped poor Mannat.

If any other mother would’ve been at her place she would’ve thanked Mannat for taking care of her kid but no she blamed her 😡

purplegirl7 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5

Team Mannat

Posted: 6 months ago

Originally posted by: Moor278

Shruti was worried Mannat would leave her and turn into Sonia?... not leave her... but Mannat at one point was impressed by ARS that Shruti remarked to herself that she is behaving like Sonia... even in the intro episode when Mannat speaks about earning lots of money... Shruti recalls the same statement from Sonia.

After the mooh kala... Mannat has lost all admiration for ARS... but Shruti doesnt know that

Neetu doesnt trust Vikrants intelligence meaning... why cant she tell him the truth? Is he so dumb that he wont be able to handle it or is he so thankless that he cant see how much Neetu Ronnie love him? his mothers death from what we saw was accidental... Neetu did not kill her... why is she not trusting his good nature and intelligence?

Mannat lost her admiration for ARS after the spiked coffee incident, Shruti knows it. About earning lots of money and big dream part, Mannat's perspective has changed. She repeated Shruti's word to ARS, but Shruti doesnt know this. Mannat has Sonia's trait but she uses it for right cause, thanks to Shruti's nurturesmiley27

About Aman's mother death, from what we saw was accidental..but I am not sure about the whole story. Punnu admits Bobby is wrong but he is still his father, but Vikrant stood with justice. When the whole truth comes out, we will know what really happened and how Vikrant would react.

Neetu was trying to commit suicide when Aman mother died, her mental state is not the best to begin with. If we go by OG, Neetu has lost her own son, she does not want to live through that again, and the fear is driving her to drug her own son.

Edited by purplegirl7 - 6 months ago

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 29 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission by Leprecheun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 10 months ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 28 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission by Leprecheun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 · 10 months ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 3 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".