Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No "105" - Page 82

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Shubho/Tanuja were more keen to go home and get update from Bips about how she executed her plan and baaki they wanted to focus on Bips-Laal milan

Kis angle se koi maanega yeh Ani ke parents hain

Today they were threatening to disown Mimi also and she was like whatever bhaad mein jaao....they only have that chashmish Rumi daughter left which they themselves barely talk to......warna beta aur beti dono haath se nikal gaye hain

Those parents scene the less we see is good

Originally posted by: ninaMAXWELL08

Yeah that bar owner told her ki bips and Ani made plan to get rid of her and sold her to them.....kyuki woh baar baar unke pass a jati thi . Jhanno as usual believed it .

How can she even trust bar owners?

No words left to me for her stupidity

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Only upbringing Urvashi gave her is to do Didi jaap for life....same as what Urvashi did till her dying day....end tak Srishti ko Didi maana and worship kiya uske saamne bechari banke....and then did suicide over Didi ke taunts .....toh aur kya hi seekh mili hogi Jhanak Rani ko life mein.....lol

Urvashi had equal rights on property like bharat and Shrishti... but she never claimed her rights...she thought J just to be submissive and do didi gulamgiri.

Originally posted by: Shalinim153

How can she even trust bar owners?

No words left to me for her stupidity

Am ranout of gaalis ..

Originally posted by: AreYaar

@bold: LOL what was the need? Are you still asking that after we have gone through so many iterations of senseless needless stuff shown by Leena?

What was the need to show Jhanak creating a tamasha in the mandap in the 400th epi when already Anishi shaadi was happening on her orders na? What was the point of doing tamasha over fake cancer reports at that point? But Leena ne dikhaya na? .....and Jhanak got to give grand speeches portraying herself as an eternally betrayed woman who gets dhoka each time blah blah......so yehi "need" hoti hai Leena ki har baar....how to find a way to portray Jhanak as supposedly being given "dhoka" by Ani and feeling oh so hurt over that before she runs off to some new location and new identity again .....it wasn't enough in 400th epi for Jhanak to feel dhoka over Didi ka pregnancy bomb....Leena had to forcibly add fake cancer reports drama in the ugliest and randomest way possible....lol and today no one even remembers those fake cancer reports 100 episodes later

So I view this senseless twist in the same vein....forced MU from Jhanak's side where she again thinks of Ani in a lowly manner and does some bitter monologues feeling betrayed by him but otherwise still keeps maintaining her "mann se pati" stance

Let me put it this way…I will try one last time to put my perspective of why this is beyond acceptance as a plot twist.

Maybe you had switched off from the Runak story much earlier but I hadn’t… I felt that J would get a reality check at that baby reveal stage given how she was perched up that morality pedestal!

I stopped watching around this time and didn’t connect to J post that phase cos her nonsense of wanting a fulfilling life for her Didi while berating Ani and then like Jekl Hyde of blow hot blow cold behaviour started to rankle and the relatability went down completely but still those characteristics didn’t look unreal to me.

While accepting that she was very upset at the baby announcement and even accepting she did some things out of spite I expected some reflection to happen at how she had given up her claim but none was forthcoming so I switched off and I had stopped even reading updates in the last few months except the odd clip we discussed here. I had tuned out of J’s character almost completely. Yet Jhanak’s core characteristics have always sent out a sense of duality so while berating her stance I could still see why she was being mule headed as that’s her core in a way or had become so

That Runak were in for separation was already known… She was going to fall for the Bips story and that wasn’t surprising at all given her past stupidity and

people in love can think a lot of stupid things of their partners.. that’s not a new thing… for instance… the fake illness isn’t the same as this new twist.. there it’s possible to conclude she thought Ani was conspiring to be with her…But my point is to think that the person you love and whom you have always said has been the reason for escaping a bad fate is today conspiring to get you to a dance bar? How lowly can one fall? What’s the sanctity of that love? My point is if Ani came to know that J thought this of him.. what’s he supposed to feel? For me this is lazy writing.. separation aur MU ke sau bahane the… agar Jhanak apne man se bar dancer ban jati accepting fate heavens wouldn’t have fallen? Why then to dehumanise the emotion J had towards Ani to this terrible level?

I know a lot of you troll this serial… I thought I did too until now… But making a lover however stupid to think that her lover is out to sell her - what is that even!!

Beyond this what’s the sanctity of a J who will come for Ani when he is in extreme pain?

Originally posted by: MMR2810

Am ranout of gaalis ..

Originally posted by: samarp2

so true Mayuri .. she just crossed all limits of her stupidity

Exactly ashu... how come any woman this much dumb..

Originally posted by: sanfan

people in love can think a lot of stupid things of their partners.. that’s not a new thing… for instance… the fake illness isn’t the same as this new twist.. there it’s possible to conclude she thought Ani was conspiring to be with her…But my point is to think that the person you love and whom you have always said has been the reason for escaping a bad fate is today conspiring to get you to a dance bar? How lowly can one fall? What’s the sanctity of that love? My point is if Ani came to know that J thought this of him.. what’s he supposed to feel? For me this is lazy writing.. separation aur MU ke sau bahane the… agar Jhanak apne man se bar dancer ban jati accepting fate heavens wouldn’t have fallen? Why then to dehumanise the emotion J had towards Ani to this terrible level?

I know a lot of you troll this serial… I thought I did too until now… But making a lover however stupid to think that her lover is out to sell her - what is that even!!

Beyond this what’s the sanctity of a J who will come for Ani when he is in extreme pain?

In the fake illness angle also Jhanak presumed that Ani tricked her into agreeing for the shaadi while carrying on with Arshi on the side. Here again she now seems to be presuming he wants to still stay with Arshi for real and get rid of Jhanak permanently by sending her to dance bar.....yes this twist is more senseless than the fake cancer reports tamasha but overall the senselessness is a common theme in my eyes......Jhanak's presumptions about how Ani is supposedly two-timing her no matter how clearly and vocally he makes it obvious that he only loves Jhanak.....you can pretty much feed her anything on that point at this point and she will quickly jump to believing that Ani is cheating her for whatever reason.

Re: dehumanizing....my take is that Jhanak in general dehumanizes Ani and his feelings a lot so it's not out of the ordinary that she is continuing to do that with this bar dancer MU also......she has never given much credence to his feelings so it is easy for her to believe all this about him always.

And makers will find a way to justify her coming to Ani when he's dying by hyping that as her mahaanta that she returns to nurse a "cheater" Ani who supposedly has always wronged her.....lol

Originally posted by: MMR2810

Urvashi had equal rights on property like bharat and Shrishti... but she never claimed her rights...she thought J just to be submissive and do didi gulamgiri.

She also engrained in her not to pursue dance as career. J ki bas itni si khahish thi ke graduate ho aur ek ofc mein naukri kare. Urvashi was another piece.

If you see most of the characters from this serial will not exist in real world.

- The Kashmir gang, they humiliated Urvashi and J continuously after snatching Urvashi property. At least for the sake of chaar log, people behave in public civilly. Lekin woh log toh kisi ka bhi care nahi tha. I am sure they knew J was Shrishti's daughter and Urvashi was doing her a favor.

- Urvashi, even tho she was a good dancer she took up the responsibility of J and gave up to become naukrani of her evil paternal fam. Couldn't she at least teach dance for income.

- Thammi, who forgets that she is suhagan, and she supports anyone who makes the loudest noise. Jiska galla uska Allah type of woman.

- Badoma whoever serves their relatives like servants and whine for years.

- Jethu and Choton continuously tolerate humiliation from their middle bother. Like he is circus master and others have to dance to his tunes.

- the bimbos in the house mimi and rumi (mimi lately only thing I can think of her is the actress wants to look good)

- Shubo and Tanuja's any family equation is unbelievable, be it with Laal-Bips, Ani, Arshi, Rumi, Mimi, Choton Jethu, Badoma. Only believable was with Appu. In real life a mentally challenged child faces that abuse from their own family.

- Laal-Bips how can they be rude to their own parents and lick boots of others. Why is J "kaanta" for bips, it just doesnt make sense.

- Brij bhushan, abandoned his daughter bcoz his wife left him. Toh beti ko kaun paale? sanyas lene se kya beti pal jaygi. bachca paida karke dono ma-baap palla jhaad liye.

- Arshi, how does she manage to get so much support from not only evil but also from good gang. it is just stupid. everyone pussy foots around her, why? why is so special. aisa toh uss mein kuch khaas nahi hai.

- Ani ka basic funda hai unless J accepts him he doesn't want to let go of Arshi. yeh kya hai. toh phir raho na Arshi ke sath hi. One time J accepted to marry was again on his terms, only after she said yes, walked in together and then Ani sent Arshi out.

Recently he has been saying Arshi ko divorce dega, toh dedona pahle. court mein hi hai. jao pahle woh kam niptao. phir apna pyar-muhabbat declare karna. IT industry walo ko itna toh logic aati hai na. Lekin ...

- J is raised with so so so low self-esteem, continuously badgered, tera baap kaun hai, as tho it is her fault. Anyway, the only parent that she knew killed herself knowing that she will be left to the wolves. she had to survive multiple kidnaps and attempts on her life.

Yes she loves sirji, we see that he loves her too, but she also sees that he continues to live with Arshi whatever be the reasoning. we know the ra*e. but for her he even had a child with her.

He says koi bhi tumhe dekha toh mujhe acha nahi lagta but he has again and again tried to get her married off to other prospective grooms (Rahul, AK, Vihaan and that uncle groom- well that was on J but he told Shrishti to get her married and J latched on it), So what does J have to make out of it.

So talented but so reluctant to make a living out of it. Appu is thinking of music school cant she think of dance school. Has the gyan to give bhashans but not use it in her own life. Only talent she used is "naukrani" banke seva karna. How is it a believable character?

Then finally Shrishti. who is so vile and stupid and arrogant to kill her own child soooo many times. I actually see that she enjoys trying to harm J or when anyone insults J (I dont know if it is the actress or character). They say daayin bhi apni bachche ke saath ghar dur pe apna panja marti hai. Yeh aurat ko koi kuch nahi kahta, uska pati bhi usko maaf kar diya. Yeh toh meri bilkul samajh ke bahar hai.

---

Dadu bhai, shuru mein theek the, lekin abb sothe rahte hai.

Vinayak bas nalayak hai

that leaves 4 characters. two good characters and two evil characters who are logical.

Appu and Minu

Kulbhushan and of course Tejas.

Originally posted by: MMR2810

Exactly ashu... how come any woman this much dumb..

Today he also cried & said J did his zindagi barbaad to Lallon .. I felt so bad for him the way he was crying till end of the epi

He will loose his mental state then all will blame her again ( & this time she deserves the blame for not even thinking about him at all )