Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No 94. - Page 83

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

I wonder, how did darpok chomu marry real Avni going against baa and staying there for two years without any contacts with family & friends, and not sharing any pics of his wife and bacha ? Really strange 🤔

True!! Itna darpook babda itna daring kaam laise kar diya aur phir fake Avni ko ghar bhi le aaya. Konse gaon mein internet or SM ka access nahi hai, jo Avni ki pix access nahi karte. Woh banda jo fake Avni ka tabela aur gai ka doodh nikalne ka video bana raha that uske paas toh resources hai!

Aur hamara Chomu kah raha tha hamare gao wale SM par nahi hai. Yes strange

Originally posted by: szsiddiqa

Nazar matt lagaiye. Yeh Leenaji ki writing hai. yeh bass hamari Arshi didi ki tarah achchai ka dhong hai. Aage kya hoga uska idea bhi nahi hai humko... Sorry I am not watching any of Leena's writing anymore.

I have watched ghum1, (Leenaji's adaptation) Sairat were married early on and then their beautiful courtship na na karte huwe, (lot of illogical stuff in that story too) then forcibly PL snatched the IVF procedure from under their nose and impregnated herself ( audience called it rape too but the channel and production refused to accept it as such and called it a medical procedure). It was set up as Sairat separation. We waited holding our breath that PL and evil gang will be punished. But PL married ML adopted a kid, tried (not succeeded) to have conjugal relationship. ML kept on living and supporting PL in her kaands (taking ML's gun and threatening to shoot). FL remarried a random guy, and we waited and waited for Sairat to find path back to each other. Aur phir last Ghum1 episode mein dono ko bomb se udha diya after a few lollipops of imaginary wedding rituals.

I did not watch Imlie except for a few episodes after Fahman's entry. I felt ick watching a barely 18+ yr old girl doing so intimate scenes, so stayed away from it and I am v happy after reading the trauma you all went thru.

From what I hear all of Leena's writings end with a feeling kuch baqi hai. From her can't expect Iss pyar ko kya naam do story! (Or we should thank Barun for his timing to quit before ruining the story)

Ghum 1 ruined to satisfy Mr and Mrs blue ....

Originally posted by: Shalinim153

Chalo is show mai kuch toh constant hai..MU hi sahi 😂

Runak fandom honestly is the unluckiest fandom hai....Rab Rakha bhi Leenaji ka show hai but dekho kitni Dhoom dhaam se leads marriage horhi hai...today done with Sikh riti riwaj... tomorrow will be done by Bengali traditions

Runak fandom ke lye hi sare dukh likhdiye hai Leenaji ne aisa lgta h....pta ni konsi dushmani nikal rhin h😂

Tab Rakha has been adapted from a pure lovestory...no third angle is given importance in the leads' equation...the ML actually always saved FL and himself from PL's changul...

Originally posted by: szsiddiqa

Nazar matt lagaiye. Yeh Leenaji ki writing hai. yeh bass hamari Arshi didi ki tarah achchai ka dhong hai. Aage kya hoga uska idea bhi nahi hai humko... Sorry I am not watching any of Leena's writing anymore.

I have watched ghum1, (Leenaji's adaptation) Sairat were married early on and then their beautiful courtship na na karte huwe, (lot of illogical stuff in that story too) then forcibly PL snatched the IVF procedure from under their nose and impregnated herself ( audience called it rape too but the channel and production refused to accept it as such and called it a medical procedure). It was set up as Sairat separation. We waited holding our breath that PL and evil gang will be punished. But PL married ML adopted a kid, tried (not succeeded) to have conjugal relationship. ML kept on living and supporting PL in her kaands (taking ML's gun and threatening to shoot). FL remarried a random guy, and we waited and waited for Sairat to find path back to each other. Aur phir last Ghum1 episode mein dono ko bomb se udha diya after a few lollipops of imaginary wedding rituals.

I did not watch Imlie except for a few episodes after Fahman's entry. I felt ick watching a barely 18+ yr old girl doing so intimate scenes, so stayed away from it and I am v happy after reading the trauma you all went thru.

From what I hear all of Leena's writings end with a feeling kuch baqi hai. From her can't expect Iss pyar ko kya naam do story! (Or we should thank Barun for his timing to quit before ruining the story)

Ghum 1 was actually till some extent adapted from Leena OG show...the PL never became so nasty in the OG...moreover, PL and ML were never married...after some MU, leads separated and after some years they united...and PL married someone else..the story was much cleaner compared to Ghum 1...and after a point of time PL actually stopped pursuing ML romantically in OG show..

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Ghum 1 was actually till some extent adapted from Leena OG show...the PL never became so nasty in the OG...moreover, PL and ML were never married...after some MU, leads separated and after some years they united...and PL married someone else..the story was much cleaner compared to Ghum 1...and after a point of time PL actually stopped pursuing ML romantically in OG show..

Dibya they changed story just to accommodate Pl in hindi version...in OG version Pl used to get her quota of bashings...but in Hindi version those parts were removed because Pl doesn't like her character bashed by her boyfriend later husband. Definitely OG Bengali version is better....later it is remade in different languages. The best version is Tamil version .

Originally posted by: sanfan

Bold - At some point in the tale I used to think that this tale where one has implicit faith and a strong sense of ownership to issues… like Ani does… a break in faith could alone resolve but that break by itself doesn’t help the love story coz Jhanak was always shown wary of the home breaker tag…so it was my hope ( long ago) that Jhanak would have to be the one to realise that Ani is being manipulated but at that stage I didn’t envisage this baby trap.Yet here we are and at the stage we are NO LOLLIPOPS OF RUNAK can work anymore as after the marriage and baby complications and Ani’s performance as dutiful husband will irk fans of the story even if they accept his situation or not. So, Leena would have to bring the conflict to head ONE WAY OR THE OTHER.

I agree, Rekha ji....and I do think she will indeed bring this conflict of "Sirji ne mujhe zindagi ka sabse bada dhoka diya" to head in some form same way she took so long to slap Ani in the face with the truth that Jhanak claiming to be pregnant with his kid was not a lie....otherwise until that point, he was also considering Jhanak trying to trap him with a baby as the lowest point of their relationship.....but suddenly the tumor news gave him blinding clarity and everything clicked in place in his mind.

Now I don't know if Jhanak will ever be shown getting that kind of clarity cuz the story in many ways runs on her inherent dumbness and inability to face her own hypocrisy and double standards regarding her feelings and expectations from Ani.....but for this particular issue, the way Leena is constantly showing Jhanak mocking Ani's claims of loving her and repeating over and over that he gave her biggest dhoka.....I do feel this will come to a head at some point for clarification but in true Leena fashion, by then she will already have found a way to divert things into another adjacent MU yet again. Cuz the story will always keep spinning around the same point of Jhanak feeling like Ani gives preference to Arshi over her.....conveniently forgetting all the times he's fought so hard for their love and she's the one who's never supported him. And reason for her lack of support has never been ki I don't believe that you love me....reason for her lack of support has always been ki I don't want to be called reason of your break up with Arshi......lol

Why’re people wishing MC for Arshi? Is it the hate for the character coz it’s beyond obvious that if Arshi miscarries blame ka tokra jhanak ke sar phutega even if she’s isn’t in Kolkata, Leena will show J is responsible.. Bechari ne abhi abhi toh sapna dekha hai shanti se zindagi bitane ka, bekar mein naya mu kyu chahiye.. Also technically speaking MC doesn’t mean Arshi will never get pregnant again.. Ise toh ani aur zyaada sympathy mein doob jayega and will willingly move on so it doesn’t make sense.. And for me more than Arshi and Ani, I want Guj track to be beneficial for J. 400 eps hogaye ek din ki khushi nahi mili.. at least ab toh woh khush rahe

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

For that Arshi has to be turned vile and plot her own harm to trap J...Aisa huwa to firbhi chance hai ki didi ki kartoot kabhi samne ayegi...agr they take the aag track route where Srishti actually caused damage to Arshi...to ye Ani ka violation angle kabhi bhi bahar nahi ayegi...and given the way they wwed Arshi and made Ani utter pregnancy as drunken mistake,I doubt makers will ever open the violation topic for discussion..

No, I don't think that is needed to get clarification on this topic. Like I said, that clarification can be a token one also - not some big khulasa but some level of revelation so that Jhanak knows that Ani didn't lie to her when he said ki didn't have that kind of rishta with Arshi.

Main reason I'm wondering about this is cuz Jhanak is being shown unable to move on from this grudge....even when she's been given a plum chance to move on with readymade fake pati, baccha and a whole big sasural, she is hung up on how she got sabse bada dhoka from Ani so marriage has no meaning for her blah blah......every single moment that Arshi ki pregnancy is mentioned or Arshi is referred to as Ani's wife, Jhanak is visibly burning up in jealousy. So iska koi toh resolution nikaalna padega......she anyways considers Ani biggest dhokebaaz so usmein koi new big level of hate reach karne ko is waqt bacha nahin hai....seperated bhi already hain.....only thing left is for Jhanak to somehow find out a piece of info that restores Ani in her eyes.....same way the tumor revelation restored Jhanak's integrity in Ani's eyes.

Main difference in the MU this time is that Ani is not lying to Jhanak to let her think he really loves Arshi....he is still reiterating his truth whenever Jhanak accuses him of dhoka. Same way Jhanak used to assert her truth each time Ani used to accuse her of giving him dhoka in J's pregnancy track.

Originally posted by: Firefly_shines

Why’re people wishing MC for Arshi? Is it the hate for the character coz it’s beyond obvious that if Arshi miscarries blame ka tokra jhanak ke sar phutega even if she’s isn’t in Kolkata, Leena will show J is responsible.. Bechari ne abhi abhi toh sapna dekha hai shanti se zindagi bitane ka, bekar mein naya mu kyu chahiye.. Also technically speaking MC doesn’t mean Arshi will never get pregnant again.. Ise toh ani aur zyaada sympathy mein doob jayega and will willingly move on so it doesn’t make sense.. And for me more than Arshi and Ani, I want Guj track to be beneficial for J. 400 eps hogaye ek din ki khushi nahi mili.. at least ab toh woh khush rahe

I'll tell you why from my POV. After so much of selfish behavior and hatred for J, publicly humiliating her, character assasinating her, allowing her mom to victimize her, hanging on to a man who you knew loved his lawful wife, take advantage of him when he is inebriated, inspite of all signs, even when you mentioned many times you did not love him, just to ensure she did not win over you...this kind of person needs some punishment as she herself said in last weeks episode. Its not fair to the baby as well. A child who has the stigma of being conceived on account of his/her dad imagining his/her aunt while sleeping with his/her dad. Isnt is gross for the child.

This is apt punishment for he. But Leena never punishes anyone but J and Ani in this show. Thats why their characters are also compromised and called out. If Arshi was actually given the consequences of her actions as and when she did them, she would be in no state to be respected as a person.

Take baby conceived by imagining J out of the equation. After that if Ani sleeps with Arshi fully in his senses, then bring baby. J has no bearing in this. She already has taken Ani's response to situation as dhoka and moved on in her life. Even if bachha is not viable anymore, she will not come in between Ani Arshi equation. Leena has ensured this. this is why we got all the clarification of J POV in the episode yesterday.

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Is show mein everything happens in service of setting up MUs only toh ab aur kya hi guess karein hum

Ani ko is waqt dikha rahe hain trying to be selfless and not creating problems in Jhanak ki new life and shaadi....he is praising her in front of her new saas ki isse achhi ladki aapko mil nahin sakti, yehi aapke ghar ki laxmi hai.....lol toh aage probably hoga yeh phir se flip at some point into thinking badly of Jhanak. Jhanak anyways thinks badly of him abhi se only toh aage dono ka aur hisaab barabar ho jaayega in hurling insults at each other

Achha nahin kiya ye Ani babu ne...he also forgot Jhannu ki history...Jhannu ki guarantee le ra hai .iska to impression kharab ho jayega ..sab fan bane hai..Lakshmi ji ab roz kalesh macha dengi ghar pe ..kabhi tata thaiya karke and kabhi padai ka bhasan deke ..