Sunn Mere Dil (GEO) #11 - Wahaj Ali, Maya Ali, Hira Mani - Page 111

Originally posted by: kuhelidebbarma

I am hopeful because I understand KRQ's style of writing...when he is almost at the finishing point of the story,one will understand what message he is trying to give..his way of writing is not 1+1=2 ,its complex.

Also in OST,so many scenes are there for bilal-sadaf.

Also I dont have much hope I m just trying to calm down myself

Not sure if we are getting all the scenes that were in the OST in the actual show. I’m not so hopeful. They probably have another 7-8 episodes to wrap up the show. Will they be able to show all that in such a short while ?

Originally posted by: missFiesty_69

Not sure if we are getting all the scenes that were in the OST in the actual show. I’m not so hopeful. They probably have another 7-8 episodes to wrap up the show. Will they be able to show all that in such a short while ?

Well I m not talking only about ost scenes but I am talking about scenes from teasers too ....many of bilsad scenes are left to be aired and also there are BTS of bilal in Singapore and sadaf in Singapore..

Expectations are very less but I think they still have many scenes together.

Geo dramas normally cross 40 + episodes so this show will not finish before 40-45 episodes.

Originally posted by: missFiesty_69

Not sure religiously, but isn’t having a romantic affliction with someone without a divorce morally wrong ? It’s literally cheating because regardless of the fact you partake in physical intimacy or not, you are consciously cheating your husband - how’s that justified ?
and no, Farzana might be justified if this was 1970s - now times have changed. If she knows Sadaf has been domestically abused by Ammar and still wants her to give him a chance, she’s the shittiest mother in the face of the earth. No mother should and would support that.

I do understand that Divorce is *still* considered a stigma in many parts of the society, is frowned upon even religiously, but come on she’s not getting a divorce because she doesn’t like Ammar or she’s harboring feelings for someone else. There’s an inherent lack of trust, respect in this relationship. So why should she continue to suffer ? Bacchi thodi hai ki yeh pasand nahi aaye toh let’s move on to the next toy bolegi Sadaf.
She’s an adult who’s well aware of the consequences of her actions. So Farzana should treat her as one instead of asking her to give an abuser like Ammar another chance.

If they show Sadaf and Bilal together before an official divorce, I do think there will be people who take issue with it. I don’t know how they will go about it.

Just saw KDH review...I found Atiqa Odho's POV very sensible..

She said like this kind of script was never meant to be in the form of drama..and on the top of it the producers have made everything OTT and over sensationalized it. It should have been a mystical type of art movie or something.

Originally posted by: kuhelidebbarma

Just saw KDH review...I found Atiqa Odho's POV very sensible..

She said like this kind of script was never meant to be in the form of drama..and on the top of it the producers have made everything OTT and over sensationalized it. It should have been a mystical type of art movie or something.

I agree with her. We have said same here that this is wrirten as a commentary on different philosophies of love that we experience through its impact on Sadaf's life, and not a love story or romance or melodrama. There is not a lot of action or external stimuli in the story. Its a lot of internal pov, emotions, opinions, psychological issues/ dysfunctions. I have said this myself here that this type of story that the script was telling needed a fresh contemporary creative treatment, contemplative tone, restrained performances and authenticity of emotions, and not this ott seationalistic contrived approach haseeb took. Atiqa thought Humsha could have been the central cktr. While I do not agree with that, I do think Humsha could have been executed as a Lady Macbeth or Loki type of cktr, or as an omniscient narrator. I liked that Atiqa made me think of the different creative ways in which this script could have been executed.

Overall, I agree with Atiqa that the team did not understand the story they had on paper or were not simply interested in telling that story. Forcing a script that is meant to be something else into a love story and high drama with many filler scenes was a very insincere and wrongheaded way of storytelling.

Originally posted by: hypnotoad

I agree with her. We have said same here that this is wrirten as a commentary on different philosophies of love that we experience through its impact on Sadaf's life, and not a love story or romance or melodrama. There is not a lot of action or external stimuli in the story. Its a lot of internal pov, emotions, opinions, psychological issues/ dysfunctions. I have said this myself here that this type of story that the script was telling needed a fresh contemporary creative treatment, contemplative tone, restrained performances and authenticity of emotions, and not this ott seationalistic contrived approach haseeb took. Atiqa thought Humsha could have been the central cktr. While I do not agree with that, I do think Humsha could have been executed as a Lady Macbeth or Loki type of cktr, or as an omniscient narrator. I liked that Atiqa made me think of the different creative ways in which this script could have been executed.

Overall, I agree with Atiqa that the team did not understand the story they had on paper or were not simply interested in telling that story. Forcing a script that is meant to be something else into a love story and high drama with many filler scenes was a very insincere and wrongheaded way of storytelling.

Yes hypno I remember having the same discussion where we were saying how KRQ had a different vision while writing the story and Haseeb had a different vision while shooting it..also Haseeb had so much pressure from the channel to make it more appealing to the masses..hence he chose to make it more OTT(which totally came out weird resulting into inconsistencies of acting of the actors)

Also as a director I find Haseeb not that good..I mean he has always worked with best writers hence his work always got praised..but I never came across any project of him where the script wasn't ’t that good but he saved it with his fantastic direction...even a below average story can be saved by director and can be made more appealing to masses(for eg-Tere Bin) but Haseeb doesn't have this quality..he is more like a author-backed director

Its really sad to see how everything went wrong just because of miscommunication between director and writer...now they have nothing to do except blame game..!!

Is anyone watching the episode live?

Originally posted by: kuhelidebbarma

Is anyone watching the episode live?

i just saw twitter. sadaf said " i want to date bilal abdullah". and it's making me laugh

i was right about sadaf 😬

https://x.com/7thskybiz/status/1882096020152365134?t=PI9aeOllbSUMZQP1cJJosQ&s=19

sadaf has already started making ammar jealous 😆