Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 17 Jan 2025 Written Update and EDT - Page 17

Episode Discussion

Created

Last reply

Replies

238

Views

20.5k

Users

37

Likes

1k

Frequent Posters

Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: Debospeaks

I agree, he loves his mom and abhira sending her jail instead of outside settlement made him go mad at her and he finally gave her the divorce. But the point is why don't he make it clear to his mom that what she did was also a crime and it's not something that Abhira made a false story and framed her into conviction, hence all he could do was to give her divorce and he did that. Now this demand to publicly humiliate her and to do a tamasha is what he's incapable of doing as it's against his ethics and principles.

see I don’t think they’re saying Abhira framed her …their point is she could’ve negotiated an out of court settlement ….Vidya thinks Abhira has chosen this path just to humiliate her .. that is not true ..but to a family, it looks like that

However Armaan could have dealt with this better ..and him filing a fake complaint against Abhira is an ugly move and a real low blow no matter ..no defending that !

Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: mrigu

He is always going to be the ultimate family lover.


Nope that's not the story dear it's a journey of arman from being family lover to come out of there clutches. Baki k gen mei of you see then Ml family ka ladla tha and pura ghr uske aage puche tha. And ml didn't like them badmei voh family bhakt baan jata hei yaha ml pehele se hi hei toh he has to come out of it Varna ghr usko sautela karke treat karte hi kyu dekhayenge.

Edited by Ankitanair - 7 months ago
Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: Pinecone

Abhira is convinced that she can reconcile but MG is determined to convince her that they are over. I feel for Abhira. She loves him SO much. And kaveri ofc is there to blame Abhira for everything . Vidya committed the crime yet she is bechari is the narrative they are forcing. Ugh! Ghatiya elders. But I cant believe Ar actually filed false complaint just to permanently end hope of reconciliation with Ab. Thats got to be the stupidest thing ever. WTF is Armaan doing?! Surely breaking rishtaa is enough punishment for Ab. What has he achieved by getting her license revoked? Abhira never lied to get V punished. It was valid case. She did commit a crime whether intentional or not. But Ab did absolutely nothing wrong. Abhiras breakdown to Armaan today is so on point.

Armaan has made a huge mistake by picking Vidya over Abhira.


Kaveri ko apne naam k badle kich nhi pada nhi hei. She can throw anyone under bus for that.

mrigu thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: Ankitanair


Nope that's not the story dear it's a journey of arman from being family lover to come out of there clutches. Baki k gen mei of you see then Ml family ka ladla tha and pura ghr uske aage puche tha. And ml didn't like them badmei voh family bhakt baan jata hei yaha ml pehele se hi hei toh he has to come out of it Varna ghr usko sautela karke treat karte hi kyu dekhayenge.

Even I thought so and he did come out of it, stood up for her. But what happened then? After marriage or after his mother went to jail. Look I know they love each other like no one. But ultimately I'll get tired of this back and forth. Makers cannot keep going round and round.

inlieu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: CanKeepCalm

and VV will be suddenly out of her fake trauma? That would be bizarre.

Why do I get the feeling she's faking the trauma with her OTT hysteria? She seemed fine when she saw Arman leaving and then decided to emotionally blackmail him since that's the only way she can get revenge on Abhira. She knows he will not be able to do it himself so she needed to shove him in that direction by her fake trauma. I hope he finds out one day and then regrets what he did. The new character in the precap looks interesting. That actor did amazing in YHC so I hope they give him a meaty role. He might be this season's Abhinav.

Edited by inlieu - 7 months ago
Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: mrigu

Even I thought so and he did come out of it, stood up for her. But what happened then? After marriage or after his mother went to jail. Look I know they love each other like no one. But ultimately I'll get tired of this back and forth. Makers cannot keep going round and round.


Nhi re has not fully come out for it ma ka pending heu aur voh sabse jyada hold hei he will come out of it.

mrigu thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: Ankitanair


Nhi re has not fully come out for it ma ka pending heu aur voh sabse jyada hold hei he will come out of it.

Dekhte hai. Itna ruke hai, iske liye bhi ruk jaate hai. But I'll still not watch and only read updates. Mujhe apna mood nahi kharab karna.

CanKeepCalm thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail 9th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4

Team Critics

Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: inlieu

Why do I get the feeling she's faking the trauma with her OTT hysteria? She seemed fine when she saw Arman leaving and then decided to emotionally blackmail him since that's the only way she can get revenge on Abhira. She know he will not be able to do it himself so she needed to shove him in that direction by her fake trauma. I hope he finds out one day and then regrets what he did. The new character in the precap looks interesting. That actor did amazing in YHC so I hope they give him a meaty role. He might be this season's Abhinav.

it does seems like Vidya is faking but in dkp is not ekta to pull such stunt. So I blame it on execution and acting which is giving impression that she is faking. Even though its real doesn’t make sense which criminal get such level trauma in 5 days🙄

Regarding Ar he is gonna cry buckets and will not getting any sympathy 😡

inlieu thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 months ago

Originally posted by: CanKeepCalm

it does seems like Vidya is faking but in dkp is not ekta to pull such stunt. So I blame it on execution and acting which is giving impression that she is faking. Even though its real doesn’t make sense which criminal get such level trauma in 5 days🙄

Regarding Ar he is gonna cry buckets and will not getting any sympathy 😡

Yeah the trauma in 5 days is ridiculous. They are sidelining Abhir's issues and making him fodder for sister vs. sister in future. smiley44

This time round I don't know what excuse Armaan has. The only way is Abhira later decides to forgive him, but for her own self-respect I think she shouldn't go back to him. Unless he finds a cure for Abhir as a way of redeeming himself, then maybe she can think about it. I also don't see anyone of the Poddar elders being concerned about a young man like Abhir being disabled for the rest of his life. No conscience whatsoever. Vidya's drama is top prio for them, I get it, but not a single one of them went to ask about Abhir's condition or even pay a visit even before the case.

I think there's an underlying thread of Abhira for once putting someone in her family first because before this she was treated as a orphan dying for family, and was dependent on Armaan for giving her a family through marriage. She accepted them, but they never truly accepted her, except Charu and Armaan (and maybe the other kids). Right now, Charu is the only one thinking straight but no one listens to her. Armaan got used to Abhira doing everything for him and his family and was expecting her to prioritize his mother too this time. He couldn't accept the fact that she chose to stand with Abhir, her own real blood relation, even though she's totally right to do so. Vidya might have been scared initially and ran away from the accident site, but she stayed quiet for 2 days, which to me is the worst thing. She watched Abhir suffer in the hospital and said nothing. If the tables were turned, the Poddar's would have made the Goenkas' lives hell.

I agree with what Abhira told him, that he failed to see her perspective because somewhere deep down he hasn't really accepted her family as his own. If he had, he would have felt for Abhir too and acted accordingly. He still calls Manish 'sir' while Abhira call his parents what he calls them too. These things might seem trivial but they show a lot of other aspects of their relationship.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Manny_123

23 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 30 July 2025 EDT

Welcome to Episode Discussion Thread

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: WildestDreams

6 months ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai CC #9

Welcome to the chat corner of the Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai forum Hello all forum waasis, This Chat Corner is open now and anyone can talk on...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7

24 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai July 29, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread

🗣 Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread! 🗣 Make sure to...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".