Shrimad Ramayan Chat club #3 - Page 93

Chat clubs

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

31.8k

Users

13

Likes

2k

Frequent Posters

RamAayenge thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Celinacrescent

That's the beauty of the epic.There was no mention of Ram taking Bhramacharya during vanvaas or Kaikeyi asking him.Sita assures him that she will maintain celibacy so that he can take her with him.Its not mentioned anywhere else but logically the couple being quite intelligent and wise knew that giving birth to a child and raising him or her in forest when one doesn't neven have a solid roof over your head is no joke.So the reasons for abstinence is more logical and practical.For others it was more emotional

1.Lakshman accompanied his brother ,was physically separated from wife ,not having a child before the eldest one.He wanted to be close to his brother and hence was happy with him.

2.Bharat lives in Nandigram as an ascetic ,away from everyone and did all the administrative work.So he was literally alone with no mental support unlike Ram who had great moral support from Sita and lakshman.Vanvaas was toughest for Bharat.He was away from his consort ,not having a child before the eldest one.

3.Though Shatrugan was not mentioned in detail in the epic,we can safely assume that being the youngest he probably had much easier unlike the other three.We can assume that perhaps the responsibilities were not dumped on him.But during the vanvaas ,he stepped up and did all the leg work for Bharata.After all Bharta never stepped foot inside Ayoddhya .A kingdom without king is vulnerable so Shatrugan must have physically manned the borders and looked over the subjects,looked after the 350 wives of Dashratha ,stayed with his wife yet CHOSE not have a child before the eldest one .Because whoever has the first child will technically become the next king as all the 4 were of same age.

As soon as the trio returns,the 4 princesses conceive shortly afterwards.

I also feel that,,,for brothers it wld have been even more difficult,,bcz Ram and Sita were together,, mentally and emotionally happy & invested into each other,,,Lakshman and Bharat serving their respective duties happily but literally had no mental & emotional support to share with anyone,,,as they were also separated frm their wives,,that guilt of Lakshman for choosing Ram's service but in this process, compromised on husband's duty must hv been there,though not considered enough,,but again a continuous turmoil going on deep inside,,,same for Bharat,, with added on guilt for what Kaikeyi had done,,,I feel sabse mushkil in dono ke liye hoga,,as lakshman wld be keeping himself engaged in manual work in vanvas giving space to couple,,Bharat must be fighting the remorse plus shouldering all responsibilities but didn't accepting facilities of rajya,,,shatrughna and Ram atleast had their wives to share the agony with,,Bharat & Lakshman can't share their agony with anyone,,,Bharat can't share much with Shatrughna who was already younger and had to handle many things,,, lakshman Never became weak in front of Ram,,, otherwise he may send him back as he tried also once,,,,

Both of them never expressed though but that emptiness wld hv been difficult to handle sometimes for both of them...

Lakshman had that mental satisfaction that atleast he was doing the thing he wanted to do( tho last year was way more Challenging and again adding guilt and pressure on his side as for what happened to Sita and the breakdown of Ram which he himself never witnessed earlier so handling him with that guilt of not able to save Sita and that harsh talk between Sita & Lakshman b4 abduction),,Bharat had great challenge there too(misunderstood for what he has not done & still carrying out responsibilities till return of Ram),,,,

challenging situations erupting and how to manage is something these characters teaches us....all brothers and sisters...

Really the self control shown by all 4 couples was really great...

Edited by RamAayenge - 1 years ago
MJ_1009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: cuteamanboy

i love pakistani dramas especially their title tracks are awesome

nice, even im watching pakistani dramas too. which one is your favorite?
cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

mannnat murad

i love that show and

tere bin

i love that as well

cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

according to valmiki ramayan

kaikeyi was a bit proud lady

dasharath said that due to kaikeyi nature he couldn't due respect to kaushalya and sumitra

something like this

cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

according to valmiki ramayan

it seems

the queens of ayodhya didn't share very much cordial relations as shown in tv shows

dasharath says he fears how he will face sumitra after the exile decision

cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

what are your views regarding uttar kand as many claim it's interpolated some say even the same about bal kand

cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

in my opinion

bal kand and uttar kand are not interpolated

though uttar kand may have some differences in stories

it can be because of kalp bhed

Edited by cuteamanboy - 1 years ago
RamAayenge thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: cuteamanboy

in my opinion

bal kand and uttar kand are not interpolated

though uttar kand may have some differences in stories

it can be because of kalp bhed

UK happened or not ??? This topic...

Ananya didi had put this topic and long discussion on it happened b4 on forums i think,, sabne views diye the,,happened b4 extension of series,,i think in July 3rd or last week,,didi ko tag kar rahi hu,,,she may give thread of that discussion...

Edited by RamAayenge - 1 years ago
CID-fan-394 thumbnail

Panchavati Peacekeepers

Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: cuteamanboy

what are your views regarding uttar kand as many claim it's interpolated some say even the same about bal kand

Uttar ramayan is definitely interpolated

cuteamanboy thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

it would be better if there would be few verses dedicated to the sisters of sita like their conversation before exile during exile after exile

like mothers discussing about the pain of the sisters in the original epic

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".