I am not saying J is mahan. First thing is She should have been strong to not sleep with him . Then when she did she should have fought for her rights. But pushing Ani to Arshi, I have no comments. He is not a child and has brain of his own. If he doesnβt love Arshi he did not have to marry her even if J is not openly accepting. Second, people were blaming her openly of trapping him , when it was otherwise, he never openly supported her.there are lots of things on that front and I would refrain from going there at this point.
My only point is , J is not mahan but she is not here to ask for his love. She is asking for right of her child which is completely correct .
I think we view things differently.
I also donβt want to discuss my opinion about J, Ani is no saint and J is no saint either both pushed each other to different conclusions,
Ani kinda never wanted to cheat on Arshi, but ended up becoming a cheater. Even in Kashmir he says when lying sick in his bed that why I am not thinking about Arshi. I think he genuinely wanted to marry Arshi but the moment J was with him that night his true desires for real intimacy and acceptance by an opposite gender came up and I donβt know what it was lust, love, infatuation. Arshi stopped understanding him after her suicide drama. He couldnβt share anything with her. In the past they shared things as it was shown by makers, that they were very close. Thatβs why he maybe still runs after her.
J after that Kashmiri night stopped understanding Ani completely. She called herself dusri aurat. And then he understood that he should stick with Arshi. Yes, he maybe wrong in choosing a partner but J is no good partner for him either. No one understands him anyway. Even he has lost himself as he canβt believe in what has happened. He has been putting an act for too long and now it hit him so hard that he is out of touch with reality. Maybe they show him falling ill and this doesnβt mean I want to redeem him. But if you think about such people in real life I think they may have split personality disorder or being narcissistic due to childhood trauma
1.6k