Originally posted by: pratyay
Wanting somebody physically and doing the act are two different things. Even in courts, you are convicted for doing crime not thinking about it.
Arshi knows Ani's feelings for J.
Thats absolutely true, I am not trying to establish he is legally wrong; more moral depravity.
You know - I don't like Arshi; but through all of this, I've always felt Ani is being the cruelest to Arshi; not Jhanak.
Jhanak has the strength to move on, the drive and talent to be successful; people gravitate to her; and time heals everything.
Arshi has spent many years in a committed relationship with him; has had him lie to her constantly; he has given J an assignment intended for Arshi; manipulated her; given her repeated star performances; even with J telling him how he is disrespecting and cheating Arshi with his performances; he has not disclosed his feelinga for J to Arshi; he has constantly given her hope and put her in a scenario where because she loves him; she is unable to move away. He has never let her walk away from him and used her ruthlessly. He even has a monologue he could not bring himself to marry Arshi. For what? What gives him the right to control Arshi's life this way? Isnt she not entitled to make her decisions based on the truth - his truth? He is publicly showing jealousy and possessiveness for another woman. Pls dont tell me he is unaware of his feelings for J. Every one knows this. Thats why J's news had so much impact. Every one knows Ani is more than capable of this.
Is he some prince that he thinks Arshi cannot recover from him; and makes the decision he needs to keep her, like some sort of penance?? Thats why he runs behind her and pacifies her.
If Ani is not doing all this nonsense for some ulterior motive that involves good for J; then he has to be a very disgusting man....more from an Arshi perspective than J. At least if it is for J - he is being true to one person; even if he is being brutal to Arshi. Here he is destroying 2 lives.
J made mistakes because she does not have support and has gone through mental torture at BH and was vulnerable emotionally; but at least she never intentionally did wrong. But she spent much less time with Adi and is not obsessed with Ani is as Arshi. Encouraging a woman like Arshi is a despicable act in my book.
Ani has wrecked Arshi's life. More than lead couple it seems makers are trying to give solid reason for all the things Arshi is going to do to Ani and J.
The montage is very interesting. It does not show Arshi between Ani and J - rather seems like Arshi is controlling their relationship. Something is a bit off here, that we are maybe overlloking or I may be overthinking...somehow today did not make sense for me and I feel the story is somewhere not adding up.
Edited by PPak - 11 months ago
1.6k