Originally posted by: LizzieBennet
I tried this one:
Main kya janu kya jadoo hai
Film: Zindagi (1940)
Music: Pankaj Mullick
Lyrics: Kidar Sharma
Singer: Kundan Lal Saigal
I wasn't a big fan of Saigal initially (my dad was and owned his collection) but I grew up listening to him and the more I listened, the more I had to admit his command on sur is unbeatable. He seems to render songs with such consummate ease, it all seems effortless in his voice.
This song isn't easy by any stretch of the imagination, but I tried with and without music, the music was just the karaoke track playing on YT while I recorded on Vocaroo. 
Let me know which one you preferred
*Runs away*
Main kya janu without music https://voca.ro/1ix7t6IauodW
Main kya janu with music https://voca.ro/1mEXZOKoAwTW
What a pleasant surprise, Riya 
I don't have words to describe your singing, magical
My mother is a big fan of K L Saigal, and so am I. mere collection mein unke sare songs ki audio CDs bhi hai. I like Shanjahan Movie very much, superb acting & singing., unki singning ki baat hee nirali thi, kitna bhi mushkil song ho, bahut hee sahjata se gaate thay, pta hee nhi chalta ki kitna mushkil hai. Golden era ke almost sabhi singers including Kishore Kumar, Mohammad Rafi, Lata Mangeshkar, and Mukesh, unko idolize karte thay aur apna guru mante thay.
Tumne kamaal ka gaaya hai, matlab its not a recording, but a top-class performance by a trained singer
. your hold on breathing, voice modulation, and keeping feel of OG song is commandable.
I like w/o music version kyunki usme jo feel & clarity hoti hai, vo with music recording mein nhi hoti, w/o music me aap songs ko apna bana kar, music ke tempo/scale ko match karne ki tension ke bina, itminan se gaa sakte ho. If u have live music tab baat alag hai,
bolne ki jaroorat nhi ki song download karke playlist me add kar liya hai, already 4-5 baar sunn bhi liya, isiliye reply me deri huyi.
Thank you so much, aise hee songs record karte raho aur hume sunate raho.

202