Rajamouli felt Aamir was overacting in Laal Singh Chaddha - Page 2

I wont recommend PK personally just my opinion n LSC was slow n most seen the English movie which was a masterpiece.

Originally posted by: wat_up

I wont recommend PK personally just my opinion n LSC was slow n most seen the English movie which was a masterpiece.

PK is a must watch. Aamir overdoes it with his googly eyes, but the movie is really funny with a good message on blind faith / organised religion

poori dunia ko yeh pata tha sirf Aamir ko chor kar

PK is a good watch.. his googly eyes worked In that movie… but not at all in LSC…. The older chada role was better portrayed … but aamirs Punjabi was not at all convincing…

kkk did so well in her role… she looked beautiful…. The vfx/de aging on her was subtle … but looked very off on aamir

Originally posted by: Daebak

What about PK? I didn't watch the film coz I was worried his eyes would pop out and fall on me

Genuinely though, how was PK as a film? I haven't watched it.

I liked PK except for the climax and Anushka's love story which didn't make any sense to me

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

LSC was stupid but why wouldn’t you recommend PK ?

Originally posted by: Daebak

What about PK? I didn't watch the film coz I was worried his eyes would pop out and fall on me

Genuinely though, how was PK as a film? I haven't watched it.

It's good.. recommended

I think that PK could have been a better movie with another expression in Aamir's face...strangely I had problems to look at his eyes so I couldn't finish the movie.

Same with LSC...I couldn't give the film a chance because of Aamir's expression.

Both the times I had the disturbing feeling of something artificial, not naturally belonging to the character...

Never before I had experienced something similar...

I genuinely wonder how people would have felt about Aamir’s acting in LSC if PK wasn’t there? Everyone’s immediate reaction after the trailer came out was to say he was doing PK again. By the same token how would everyone have felt if LSC was an original story and not a Foresr Gump remake and you couldn’t compare him to Tom Hanks?

Forest or Laal were mentally challenged individuals with low IQs. They weren’t meant to be able to speak and communicate clearly and be able to pick up on social cues. Should Aamir have been more subtle in his acting? Absolutely!! I don’t know why he took the route that he did with how he portrayed the character. However LSC as a story and as a production was very well made. I don’t agree that it was a garbage movie. Not by a long shot. Aamir may have faltered as an actor here but not as a producer.