**Dhruv Tara - Samay Sadi Se Pare Episode Discussion Thread #10 ** - Page 70

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

34.4k

Users

20

Likes

3.4k

Frequent Posters

aekiel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Neutral2

Dhruv is wrong in Judgement. Dhruv knows already about how Ravi Baba is imprisoned, but never raises question at that time. He accepted that things like this happen in 17th century and continues his marriage. But when he knows Ravi is his father, suddenly all the outburst comes out.

When tara comes to 21st century, Dhruv sent her to mental asylum. When Dhruvs passport was missing, Tara was blamed because she was outside. Even they are ready to sent her jail. How 21st century differ from 17th century. Even today if some foreigner comes to India without passport, he will be jailed and might be tortured thinking he would be spy.

Another thing why Maharani is only nazarband while Ravi is tortured in jail. Well, everybody knows Maharani, and Ravi is foreigner for them. Punishment will be different.


Bold- can't really blame him for this part though? Obviously his outburst will be more for a near and dear one than any stranger?

Edited by aekiel - 2 years ago
vibha28 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Neutral2

Dhruv is wrong in Judgement. Dhruv knows already about how Ravi Baba is imprisoned, but never raises question at that time. He accepted that things like this happen in 17th century and continues his marriage. But when he knows Ravi is his father, suddenly all the outburst comes out.

When tara comes to 21st century, Dhruv sent her to mental asylum. When Dhruvs passport was missing, Tara was blamed because she was outside. Even they are ready to sent her jail. How 21st century differ from 17th century. Even today if some foreigner comes to India without passport, he will be jailed and might be tortured thinking he would be spy.

Another thing why Maharani is only nazarband while Ravi is tortured in jail. Well, everybody knows Maharani, and Ravi is foreigner for them. Punishment will be different.

You are 100% right and I said the same thing in my post on Page 85, we have to take into consideration the time and how things were in 17th century. Queen herself took Dhruv to meet Ravi. The day her exile was over she brought up topic of Ravi. Before that no one would have listened to her or believed her and seen as a ploy to get out of exile.

I also think that if they wanted to hide Ravi why even bother showing him to Dhruv? He knows Queen had no idea until later and at that time Tara did best that she could. They did not have any agenda to beat Ravi or put him in prison it was the situation that caused all this.


Look at the US Embassy Seige in Iran when exiled king was allowed to enter USA for cancer treatment. Iranian public captured Americans and it took them over a year to get them out. The movie Argo describes it perfectly. It even cost Jimmy Carter his Presidency. Exile is not something where anyone can do anything. She was deprived love of her children.


What is most confusing is why the heck Ravi didn’t tell his wife what he was doing? If he thought queen was his sister then why not tell wife that? He runs off without telling anyone and Dhruv is offered as a consolation prize. That’s when he was deprived of his dad - mind you his own family is lying to him and have for the last 25years.

Chinmayi18 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Just because Tara 17th century se belong karti hai uske actions ko hum justify nahi kar sakte 👎🏼

Saman nyay ki bat karke apne papa ki mistakes ko justify karti hai ye ladki ye to 21st century behavior hua na jaha log itne selfish hote hai ki apne aur apni family ke aage unhe aur kuch bhi nahi dikhta 😕

Saxena family ke lies jab Dhruv ko pata chalenge I'm sure woh unki bhi class lega jaise usne jail ke bahar shushi ki li thi Kyunki Dr Dhruv me courage hai wrong ko wrong bolne ka phir samne koi apna ho ya stranger 👍🏼

Aur yahi quality princess me nahi hai jab shushi bakwas karti thi Tara khud ke liye stand leti thi but king ki wrong doings dekhkar isne 1 word bhi nahi bola

Kya bol raha tha Dhruv Ravi baba ki condition worse hai abhi me shadi ke bare me soch bhi nahi sakta to wrong kya hai isme?? Tumhare papa bimar hote to tum karti shadi Tara?

Mahaveer ko society ki padi hai Anusiya ke would be hubby ne suddenly kisi dasi se shadi kar li tab uski jag hasai nahi hui but princess ki shadi kuch dino ke liye postpone ho jayegi to jag hasai hogi inki 🙄

Dhruv ne gusse me 4 bate kya suna di royal family ko Tara usse gussa ho gayi jo hua so ho gaya ab tum chup ho jao shanti ke lessons de rahi thi

But jab Dhruv ne question puchha agar mai bhi tumhare pitashree ke sath wahi karu jo mere pita ke sath hua hai to??? (Ye sirf question tha statement nahi kiya tha D ne ki mai bhi tumhare papa ke sath same karunga jo mere papa ke sath hua!!!! ) to Tara ko kitna gussa aaya ise apne papa pyare hai to D ko bhi honge na simple Tara thodi maturity dikha sakti thi us scene me

In short D ne gusse me bhi kuch wrong nahi bola woh sirf Tara ko bol raha tha shanti ke lessons teach karna easy hai ek bar khud ko meri jagah rakh kar socho

I remember D ki engagement wale din Tara gayab ho gayi thi tab unknown city me Tara bechari kaha jayegi ye sochkar uski help ke liye D shushi ki care kiye bina Tara ke pichhe gaya tha

Aur kal jab D ne bola mai ja raha hu 21st century wapas Ravi baba ke sath tab Tara ne easily bol diya jao hum bhi nahi rokenge tumhe!!

Mai ye nahi bol rahi ki tara ko D se rukne ke liye bolna chahiye tha but Tara ne ek bar bhi nahi socha D ki koi identity nahi 21st century me plus Ravi baba ko aisi halat me kaise lekar jayega woh akele kaise survive karega bechara

Kal sirf D ke ek sentence se Tara extremely gussa ho gayi to king ke marne ke bad uska hate towards D kitna horrible hoga socho

vibha28 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: aekiel


Bold- can't really blame him for this part though? Obviously his outburst will be more for a near and dear one than any stranger?

I think outburst is justified - but his anger is not letting him think other things along with it. Do you think he will be just as angry when he finds out who his real dad is?

Chinmayi18 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Minhasmansi92

Arre behen kuch kapde hote hai jo dusro ke hi pasand ate hai yeh unme se ek hai.🤣🤣 phir chahe apne pass hazaron kyu na ho 🤣 pasand vohi ayege Jo apne pass hai nhi 🤣

OK mere pas koi sis nahi hai na jiske kapde muze achhe lage aur mai chura lu is liye muze experience nahi hai is bat ka🤣

Neutral2 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: aekiel


Bold- can't really blame him for this part though? Obviously his outburst will be more for a near and dear one than any stranger?

I will blame him for hypocrisy. He blamed Tara's family for selfishness. What Dhruv did? He comes to 17th century not to save Mahaveer, but he is in love with Tara. He asked King to follow equality, but did he follow equality.

We can understand if it happen one time, out of anger he said many thing. But again and again he is blaming Tara's family, not even listening to what they are saying, I will say he is wrong in judgement.

aekiel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: vibha28

I think outburst is justified - but his anger is not letting him think other things along with it. Do you think he will be just as angry when he finds out who his real dad is?


Tough question- Yes and no IMO.


Yes because he would've probably liked to be in Jai's place (subconsciously). Everyone likes stability/normalcy of a "regular" family.


No because it does appear that Sushi really, really doted on him- so that "extra" love for someone who isn't quite your own blood will balance the giving away of a kid, ITV style. Plus his real parents were always around him, so it's not like he didn't grow up around them or not knowing them as people.

Edited by aekiel - 2 years ago
Chinmayi18 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: vibha28

I think outburst is justified - but his anger is not letting him think other things along with it. Do you think he will be just as angry when he finds out who his real dad is?

Ha muze trust hai tab bhi D ka reaction same hi hoga kyunki woh meri family Tara ki family me farak nahi karta

Last time jail ke bahar shushi se isi tone me bat ki thi D ne jis tone me king se bat ki usne tab bhi Tara ko use calm down karna pada tha

Jis tarah se Ravi baba ke sath hue injustice ke liye stand liya usi tarah se Agni pariksha ke time queen ke liye bhi stand liya tha jab ki koi jarurat bhi nahi thi kyunki tab queen ke khud ke bachhe sirf rone me time waste kar rahe the

Minhasmansi92 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Chinmayi18

OK mere pas koi sis nahi hai na jiske kapde muze achhe lage aur mai chura lu is liye muze experience nahi hai is bat ka🤣

Mere pass 2 hai but mai unke kapde nhi chura sakti vo dono rehti hi aboard hai. 🤣

Chinmayi18 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Tia-life

Hai na , royals jaaye bhaad mein , hum aaram se jiju par , saxena family ,aur baba and Navrangvan ji ki incomplete love story par baat karenge 🤣

Done aisa hi karenge 👍🏼

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".