Originally posted by: Kiwicy
I don't know why I feel bad for NM here. Matlab why are we happy that she is not getting the credit she deserves.
Atleast she wrote the characters. If she didn't write such characters how could we see them on screen. This story, these characters are her baby. That's her creation..and no one can take that away. So why aren't we giving her due credit.
I know we have qualms about something's, I know something's are copy pasted, but overall that is hers.
And coming to all the others. Everyone. I repeat everyone has a share in this mess. No one is dhood ka dhula. When she was writing or send the script of last episodes they could've said no. Anyone could've.
Kaddu uncle and asad khureshi how did they okay it. They knew everything but still did. And don't tell me they weren't seeing. They were..coz TB was their golden egg and every page would've been scrutinized. Still they okayed it.
And siraj. What was the director doing. He can remove any scenes which tells about girls but not such problematic things. Why are we giving him free pass. Doesn't the final say lies in directors hands. If anything we have to blame this stupid man.. He should be the one with vision. We don't call directors visionaries not for name sake, right?
They have the vision..they know how a scene should be. He can put symbolisms if we go by those fans who skeletoned every scene of the show and told us how the things and pieces used represented the theme..He can think about all that but not about story. Please spare me this logic.
In any field..the ultimate decision lies with director, creative heads who are there in the shooting spot, going through every shot. Monitoring everything. So even Marie baaji is responsible.
How could she not see the glaring mistakes in the script. She could've improvised it. No one will tell her off if she does this. The screen play, every damn person on the set.
Shouldn't they knew how that scene looked on screen after filming it..and then editors what the hell were they doing when editing..half of the blunders in TB are due to editors. 🤦
So why only nooran. Did she write such regressive story. No..I don't agree. She gave iconic characters. Maa begum , haya, meerab. They are written as powerful characters. But the screen couldn't show them to that level. I agree there should've been some dialogues here and there. But who's to say she wrote it and other dumb idiots removed those.
So I don't agree blaming everything on nooran. Even if I hate what she did with the story and the characters in the last phase. But everyone supported her. If they wanted they could've stopped it but they didn't.
So who is to be blamed more. Writer who just writes on paper. Or the ones who are shooting it not finding faults in it.
742