these creatives have Zero clarity or notion of being educated - which shiva is , up to 10thThe way they use unpadh gawaar bailbuddhi is too crass to agrees a school dropout in Highschool. It really was offensive what Shilpa Choubey was explaining it in her interview, no wonder where she gets this ‘English is the only way to measure a person’s smartness & Highschool dropouts are bailbuddhi’ ideas. She sure needs good education in decency.
I studied in Gujarati medium school k-12.English is introduced from grade 3.
no idea who writes this scene, where they get this urge to push uneducated part unhinged & wonder if they ever went to school!!!
Character picked up from Suman & bhabhima. My way or highway type attitude.
Slang they got is total bambaiiya, tapori. Infact even Suman’s character doesn’t reflect how a Pandya gujarati small town family will be. Suman is given dressing of Rabari community - sure they got it from Raamleela - but Rabaris won’t be Pandyas.
Similarly Shiva & all brothers & infact all characters could have been shown showing some slang if Saurashtra.
Saurashtra rajkot Gujarati does have a different kathiyawadi slang.
utna toh these creatives are not even capable to research & manage! Lazy cutpaste & whatever is all they can do.
Not only English language but formal education itself can't be used as an measure of people's overall intelligence, knowledge and/or even mannerisms. Many people learn well from life experiences and/or are self taught while others don't retain much of what they were taught despite having fancy degrees. Politeness and good manners most certainly aren't exclusive to scholarly people. Nature as well as nurture both play a much bigger role there.
They just use Shiva being less educated compared to the others as an excuse to include these so-called comedic scenes. They do a similar thing with Raavi where everyone keeps calling her stupid even when she isn't saying or doing anything wrong. It all looks very out of place and bizarre.
I'm not sure why they bothered to set the show in Gujarat if they didn't want to include any cultural nuances at all. It's quite a strange choice to make. Showcasing the various festivals and traditions would have instead helped them prolong some of the tracks without having to resort to excessive reaction shots or adding senseless subplots in the middle.