Originally posted by: G259
Sumbul is majorly at fault in the matter but Shalin and Tina are not blameless. Her father was wrong in saying whatever he said about both of them. In the MC Stan vs Shalin fight the reaction was OTT but it was due to the violence which was happening that she reacted way too much. She has seen something like this in her life in front of her maybe. Because her reaction was abnormal. But Tina, Salman and the makers gave it a different turn by calling her obsessed which is not true. It became clear that she is like this with anyone she is very close when Fahmaan came. She was with him most of the time and was not bothered about others that much.
I agree with the part that she lies to escape situations.She has done it many times already. Getting a panic attack is not on her hands.
I disagree respectfully. I haven't seen Shalin or Tina encouraging Sumbul's feelings for Shalin. Sumbul wearing Shalin's jacket after she has 5 of her own and after her dad told her not to do it. A member pointed out that the beaded bracelet she wore on the convo khulsa day was Shalin gifted too. I don't see her wearing good friend Fahmaan gifted things (people who have seen RWSP are implying something more there too. I haven't seen the show, so no clue) or anything related to her family as I have seen HMs getting homesick and keeping those things near them. Her feelings for Shalin seem stronger than her feelings for Fahmaan as she has been dissuaded many times from being with Shalin. Even during the fish task after so much tamasha, her behaviour was deeply problematic.
When Shalin and Tina were talking after MC Stan fight, there was no violence. Her reaction there made no sense unless she has very strong feelings for Shalin. Obsessive, Infatuation, Crush or something deeper - Her father was spinning a story about it being something normal.
I have never seen anyone recover from a panic attack so fast and then pounce on another person (Archana) with so much energy. All the drama alone would have exhausted anyone along with the panic attack.
Edited by Snowfally - 2 years ago
Debate Mansion
Pati Patni Aur Panga
Indian Mythology
