There are specific reasons why there are expectations from Abhimanyu.
1) When it came to Akshara Abhimanyu relationship, she has always had the upper hand. Even before confessing her love. It was always him crawling back to her - despite her not telling him truths which he always deserved to know.
2) He has always always supported her - despite her taking blame for her vile criminal sister. All he requested was not to let her come to wedding - but Akshara couldn’t even give him that. And the second he found out she’s unhappy - he again backed down. Accepted what she wanted.
3) He has always forgiven her for not telling him things and not trusting him. So she has already assumed that he will patiently listen to her for not taking him into confidence about Kairav and making him a fugitive.
Due to all above reasons, she’s just totally flabbergasted that how he can not trust me? This is something that has never ever happened before. So she’s totally blindsided.
4