Siddharth Malhotra or Kartik Aryan?

My vote goes to Sid

I just like watching him more onscreen...acting-wise, he's very restrained, at times a bit too restrained, but he was so good in Shershah

Best of Sid (Shershah)>>Best of Kartik (Dhamaka)

Kartik is a bit too OTT for my liking

Ek underactor ek overactor. Can’t pick. Don’t want to.

Originally posted by: PyaasaMacchhar

Ek underactor ek overactor. Can’t pick. Don’t want to.

Exactly

That's why it's a trick question!

Sid is bland but good looking so does good in movies like Shershah & Karthik is over actor so did well in BB2.

I liked Shershah more & Sid creates good chemistry with most of his co actors but can’t really call any of these two a good actor.

I prefer Kartik. I like him since PKP1 days.