Meray Humsafar[ARY]|Thread #2|Farhan Saeed, Hania Aamir - Page 38

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

40.6k

Users

27

Likes

2.1k

Frequent Posters

Smudge thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: .Dilwale.


Oh really. I need to go through that thread then 😂 But on a serious note I am glad to know that other people have also noticed the same about Amina. With Something Haute, if it’s not Feroz Khan, Imran Ashraf and Hum TV shows in general, chances are Hassan and esp Amina will thrash it at some point lol. I guess she was praising an ARY show too much and HUM TV got offended. Amina is pretty close friends with Sultana Sidiqque 😂


But isn’t it strange that she put the entire blame on Hania and then some on Qasim, when she should have criticised the writer and channel the most. Qasim ka tu phir bhi samajh aata hai but how much influence can a 25 year old actress have on the show. And it’s only after SeM & MH that Hania is being applauded as a performer. Before this I bet she did not have the best script choices and had limited options. Why didn’t Amina once ask that why did Farhan Saeed chose to associate himself with such a project. Because she doesn’t have the guts and he gave them an interview recently so he is in their good books lol. I am still confused as to why she blamed Hania the most like really? Shouldn’t the makers (Channel/writer/producer) have to bear the brunt of it.

Yeah you should check out the recent pages of SeM thread to see how many are pissed with her biased reviews 🤣..

She was putting blames on Hania as if she is the maker and writer of the show..Yup she did take up the role,Hala is not an easy character to play,it is not a straight character,it has layers and challenges and if written in a better way the character would have been applauded and highlighted a lot,i feel it is more the makers and writer’s fault for failing to make the character stand out as Hania has given her best as to whatever she has been given to play with the character.And i remember her insta live a year ago,where a fan asked why she was not being seen in dramas after ishqiya,then she replied that she was being offered bechari types characters all the time which she does not like and resonate with and is not comfortable doing those characters.But when someone is constantly being offered the same bechari type roles then obviously she had to choose one of them,also there are so many veteran actors in MH from whom she can learn a lot about her craft.Why only Hania is being singled out,why not the senior actors like Saba Hameed,The actor playing Raees,Farhan or so forth🤔..

Smudge thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: .Dilwale.


Oh yes that’s another thing. She praises Hania no end for her craft like she also did in this video. But then also bashes her for getting surgeries. But then again goes on to completely ignore cosmetic procedures when it comes to Mehvish Hayat 😂 I mean is it even surprising why anyone would find Amina not credible as a critic. She turns whichever way the tide is turning. When twitter praises an actor, her review reflects that. When twitter is unhappy with a show/actor/character, she goes along with that. At least Amma from galaxy lollywood does her own thing. Good or bad. She isn’t trying to be some pseudo intellectual like Amina.

Now Amna is proclaiming herself to be Hania’s fan on twitter due to being questioned about her statement😆....I mean yeah right🤪!!She talked about her surgeries in detail and even Hassan joined in that bandwagon with her,like seriously...she insinuated that Hania’s face muscle doesnt move,her face gives cold vibe,her face does not have expression due to surgeries,this are the damn things she said on her channel openly.And now she has swallowed all those things and praising her non stop and more so claiming herself to be a fan of Hania🤪..Can she get any more obvious😆...Though i am really happy that Hania’s performance talked for herself and Amna has to swallow her pride and praise her for her acting😳..

haminasto thumbnail
Font-astic Voyage Thumbnail 14th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 3 years ago

The show is going through its issues, every show does once it starts reaching it's crux and climax. With MH there's also the issue of rewriting and reshoots. And I may be the only one, but I love hala and I don't see why Hania needs to be put down for choosing to play her. Why can't a bechaari be shown on screen getting better at being a stronger version of herself. Sab auraton ko superwoman hona zaroori hai? Can't there be vulnerable, naive and soft leading ladies, who rise to bravery through time? Hania has done her utmost playing hala and it's a pleasure seeing her. Yes it might have become a drag and she's been crying forever but if every other character can have their tropes, why can't hala have hers. She cries easily, accept it and move on.

Secondly, any lapse in the show's performance is the responsibility of the makers, an actor mostly does what they are asked to. Even at this point, Hania or any other actor isn't pulling their punches, they are still giving good performances. You can't randomly accuse them as to why they signed a show, when you were just a few months ago calling it your favourite.


And oh don't even get me started at SeM reviews from SH. I believed them and was shocked to see how mediocre Atif is and how delightful Hania turned out to be as gulmeena. They really be messing up their critique on these two especially. As mad as hilmand was supposed to be, Atif looked too polished too urban and way flat for a pashtoon character, while not only Hania aced her accent, she got the range done right.

haminasto thumbnail
Font-astic Voyage Thumbnail 14th Anniversary Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Smithhh

Now Amna is proclaiming herself to be Hania’s fan on twitter due to being questioned about her statement😆....I mean yeah right🤪!!She talked about her surgeries in detail and even Hassan joined in that bandwagon with her,like seriously...she insinuated that Hania’s face muscle doesnt move,her face gives cold vibe,her face does not have expression due to surgeries,this are the damn things she said on her channel openly.And now she has swallowed all those things and praising her non stop and more so claiming herself to be a fan of Hania🤪..Can she get any more obvious😆...Though i am really happy that Hania’s performance talked for herself and Amna has to swallow her pride and praise her for her acting😳..


I remember seeing that episode of SH and it was so poorly said, as a critic she got way personal there. You are up there judging a performance, call it good or bad, say what could be done better, but passing a remark on someone's appearance could be said in private confines. She sounded like she has some personal vendetta to settle with Hania.

The_Imane thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: 18shabbo

The show is going through its issues, every show does once it starts reaching it's crux and climax. With MH there's also the issue of rewriting and reshoots. And I may be the only one, but I love hala and I don't see why Hania needs to be put down for choosing to play her. Why can't a bechaari be shown on screen getting better at being a stronger version of herself. Sab auraton ko superwoman hona zaroori hai? Can't there be vulnerable, naive and soft leading ladies, who rise to bravery through time? Hania has done her utmost playing hala and it's a pleasure seeing her. Yes it might have become a drag and she's been crying forever but if every other character can have their tropes, why can't hala have hers. She cries easily, accept it and move on.

Secondly, any lapse in the show's performance is the responsibility of the makers, an actor mostly does what they are asked to. Even at this point, Hania or any other actor isn't pulling their punches, they are still giving good performances. You can't randomly accuse them as to why they signed a show, when you were just a few months ago calling it your favourite.


And oh don't even get me started at SeM reviews from SH. I believed them and was shocked to see how mediocre Atif is and how delightful Hania turned out to be as gulmeena. They really be messing up their critique on these two especially. As mad as hilmand was supposed to be, Atif looked too polished too urban and way flat for a pashtoon character, while not only Hania aced her accent, she got the range done right.

@Bold

This is isn't a SEM thread, but yes. Atif was so bland and all critics have praised him. Zavyar has done fabulous acting mostly in his scenes with Haji Marjaan & his mom, and also Gulmeena, he showed versality. Atif is a good singer, and is charismatic for sure, but he can't act. He was way too stiff, and the change of realisation should have brought a real pivotal change in his character, he underperformed it IMO.

I didn't knew Amna / SH criticised Hania as Gulmeena, did they ? 😕

Her accent was so good and her character was so well played, most of her scenes were with an actress as impressing as Sania Saeed, and Hania totally performed like she was her daughter and kept a balance on screen. The writing was short on Gulmeena's side, but Hania explored the few scenes she got an arc at, perfectly. Like the one where she's laying down and Zargona comes, she pretends to sleep then weep as Zargona massage her legs ? That was so good. The ones where she is mad at Hilmand for using her as bait for his plan, her scenes with Mastaan & Hikmat were good too.

Smudge thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

https://twitter.com/aamnaisani/status/1546771789010829315?s=21


A brand new Hania fan in town,the very biased Amna😆..

Sera-high123 thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago


I have never seen Mere Humsafar twitter tag so active 😆😆

Edited by Sera-high123 - 3 years ago
Smudge thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: The_Imane

@Bold

This is isn't a SEM thread, but yes. Atif was so bland and all critics have praised him. Zavyar has done fabulous acting mostly in his scenes with Haji Marjaan & his mom, and also Gulmeena, he showed versality. Atif is a good singer, and is charismatic for sure, but he can't act. He was way too stiff, and the change of realisation should have brought a real pivotal change in his character, he underperformed it IMO.

I didn't knew Amna / SH criticised Hania as Gulmeena, did they ? 😕

Her accent was so good and her character was so well played, most of her scenes were with an actress as impressing as Sania Saeed, and Hania totally performed like she was her daughter and kept a balance on screen. The writing was short on Gulmeena's side, but Hania explored the few scenes she got an arc at, perfectly. Like the one where she's laying down and Zargona comes, she pretends to sleep then weep as Zargona massage her legs ? That was so good. The ones where she is mad at Hilmand for using her as bait for his plan, her scenes with Mastaan & Hikmat were good too.

@Bold:Amna first started it when Shehrzaad and Gulmeena’s first scene came out where Sherzaad wanted to talk about ghag and Gulmeena was being pretty rude to her and brushed her off.There Amna found Hania to be cold whose face muscle doesnt move,she found Hania cold in MH as well wheras Hassan was praising Hania and didnt feel something like that.Then in the very next epi review,she along with Hassan jumped in and dissected her face surgeries in detail,and found Gulmeena’s confrontation with Hikmat after the ghag was not impactful due to her lack of face muscle movement and no expression due to surgeries..Though after that in the next epi review they changed their tunes and completely flipped and started praising her😆..


I loved Zaviyar’s acting,he is really promising as a newbie.Hania came as a surprise package to me with her spot on accent and acting as a pathan girl,how i wish they would have given her more screen time as Gulmeena😒🥱..Sania Saeed praised Hania to heaps and she is so fond of Hania ,i love their bonding...😳

Edited by Smithhh - 3 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".