Originally posted by: diasingh2
I liked the OG version better. Kartik's character had much better authentic, Delhi-guy vibes to it and it was a rage back in 2011.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qy0m-4meolQ
I am not making PKP scene a classic. Rather you're trying to sell following scene from Ala Vaikunthapurramuloo as some piece of art, when it's NOT.
I'm sure there are better scenes in Allu's filmography to showcase his talent.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxVeDG4iL4U
The sole attraction in above scene is Allu himself. Take him out and replace him with Sallu and Tiger and they will be bashed mercilessly for doing the exact same thing in above scene.
So, we can also say.... "Pllllleeeaase. Aisa kya hai is scene mein"๐
My point is that not every actor have to learn to do the 0.5 walk + 1.5x dance scenes to prove that they have SWAG. Kartik can very much come up with his own version of it and still be good at it.
It's like saying Robert Di Nero is bad actor because he can't dance on Bollywood songs..
And it also reminds me of Kangana who compared herself with Meryl Streep and claimed to be"better" than her because Meryl can't pull off her roles.
Although I agree, Kartik is miscast in this role. And its a remake of AA's film so the comparisons will be inevitable and Kartik is going to be trashed badly.
@Bold: Thank you for repeating what I was trying to say there. Isnโt that the whole point? While I simply said that the scene you mentioned of Karthik can be done by any actor worth his salt.*my opinion?*
And therefore I rest my case! ๐
comment:
p_commentcount