Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

5.3k

Users

20

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

Salutethearmy thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 3 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: Intoxicator

Fair enough - I’m not all that interested. It was just conversation and I’m not familiar with SSR’s work enough to comment anyway.

Whenever you have time.

Pls watch Kai Po Che and 2016 the end (it is on Y tube)

You will come to know the difference.

That is all from my side.

Salutethearmy thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 3 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: austen-eliot

Abhimanyu's character is so crappily written that I can understand how HC's fans only continue to watch the show for him. But they cannot make up the entire viewership that is bringing in such high trps right? What exactly in the show is making it work do y'all think?

The dialogues are so uneven that it looks more like too many cooks spoiling the broth than a strong writing team delivering the goods. I think bhavna ji answered a question recently where she said she's not writing for yrkkh. Her focus is only anupama and another new show isss mode se jaate hain. Zama Habib's name has always been in the credits throughout the 13 years but I don't know that he has been connected in any way to the show for many years. I think his name appears only bcz the original concept at NAKSH time was his.

If HC is doing this role just for the commercial aspect then so be it. But to support and praise Abhimanyu bcz of HC is silly. The characters of both the leads is bullshit.The supporting characters, all except Neil are highly irritating, the story doesn't hold water. I don't know how the show runs only on so-called #abhira chemistry.

It is myth and a very wrong notion to believe that Harshad's fans are watching the show

Infact my neighbour left watching as from the past 12 years all that she wanted to see is those songs and dance numbers.

Who is watching the show. Well Yrkkh has a dedicated TV audience base who by default tune in at 8 or 8.30 and continue till 10.30

The writing tuned bad in 2020 when a look like called Sirat entered the show. It defied logic, reasoning and everything related to Yrkkh. Therefore in comparison the current plots are some what sane. Aarohi is not Akshara's duplicate. The writers brought 2 separate actors.

I don't much about previous 2 seasons but Abhimanyu isn't consistent because the writers have copied basic traits of Anurag from IN. He too fell in love immediately and believed Adrija instead of investigating Meghla's background. Here Abhimanyu is doing everything for his parents or mother and hurting himself in the process. Abhira are two sides of the same coin.The coinswitch to Aarohi is bothering many.

Neil is an anmol ratan, He will outshine everyone subject the writer giving him screen space.

Abhira are going to be inconsistent throught their journey.

Well most of the online fans are Abhira fans.

HC was always hunting for a story. It is about time that he looks at a show from a commercial point of view, earns his money and gives the viewers what is expected from him.

HahaHeheHuhu9 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: Waidehi

Sushant is not comparison to Harshad anyway I beleive Harshad is an average actor if comparison is to Sushant Sushant is classapart who made tv to bolywood becoming bigger actor in short span of time no one can even come close to him ever since he is not here we must respect him and not compare with own favourites Sushant is never to comparison now let's him leave in peace for God sake


Acha Acha theek hai, he's the best and no one on earth can come close to him, okay? 😆


Chill dude, it's just different opinions on something that's as subjective as acting. And saying that someone is an average actor doesn't amount to disrespecting them.

Edited by HahaHeheHuhu9 - 3 years ago
HahaHeheHuhu9 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Yes let him rest in peace. Cannot even imagine what really happened with his life. He died young and had his own share of predators in the film industry.

Waidehi,

Intoxicator put forth this question to me and I answered. Yeah for me SSR proved to be the rising star and he was considered a threat by many..

Everyone is entitled to their opinions

Let members agree to disagree.


Of course, all due respect to the departed soul. May he Rest in Peace.


And I think Intoxicator put forth this question as a reply to one of my comments. And I quoted Salutethearmy's comment that replied to Intoxicator's question.


It's all cool, no hard feelings. Just that different people will have different opinions on things which are subjective. 🤗

HahaHeheHuhu9 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Whenever you have time.

Pls watch Kai Po Che and 2016 the end (it is on Y tube)

You will come to know the difference.

That is all from my side.


Hmm, 2016 the end was a small budget film, without accomplished technicians or crew. And they couldn't actually release the film due to demonetisation.


And Kai Po Che's director and producer, plus the story writer, were all celebrated people in the industry in their own right. And the book it was based on was a bestseller.


We can't actually compare their films like that to compare acting. If we want to have a subjective opinion on acting, we could compare the acting that has similar parameters, not two things which are unrelated.

Edited by HahaHeheHuhu9 - 3 years ago
HahaHeheHuhu9 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#66

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

It is myth and a very wrong notion to believe that Harshad's fans are watching the show

Infact my neighbour left watching as from the past 12 years all that she wanted to see is those songs and dance numbers.

Who is watching the show. Well Yrkkh has a dedicated TV audience base who by default tune in at 8 or 8.30 and continue till 10.30

The writing tuned bad in 2020 when a look like called Sirat entered the show. It defied logic, reasoning and everything related to Yrkkh. Therefore in comparison the current plots are some what sane. Aarohi is not Akshara's duplicate. The writers brought 2 separate actors.

I don't much about previous 2 seasons but Abhimanyu isn't consistent because the writers have copied basic traits of Anurag from IN. He too fell in love immediately and believed Adrija instead of investigating Meghla's background. Here Abhimanyu is doing everything for his parents or mother and hurting himself in the process. Abhira are two sides of the same coin.The coinswitch to Aarohi is bothering many.

Neil is an anmol ratan, He will outshine everyone subject the writer giving him screen space.

Abhira are going to be inconsistent throught their journey.

Well most of the online fans are Abhira fans.

HC was always hunting for a story. It is about time that he looks at a show from a commercial point of view, earns his money and gives the viewers what is expected from him.


Hmm, Harshad fans may be watching the show. But they may not be on IF or twitter or we may not know them!


Of course, yrkkh has a set of audience but they too drifted away even before the original Akshara left. The show was under a scanner due to trps and then the new generation story attracted the audience in 2016. Similarly, they ran out of stories and showed something random during the Sirat track again causing trp decline. The show went out of top 10. But the new generation now has again made the audience interested and the show is back in top 5.


There was a time between 2013 till around 2019-20, that Star Plus shows weren't working at all in the 8 to 9 slots. So it's not entirely due to the default TV watching habit of the set of people.


Again only my POV.

Waidehi thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: HahaHeheHuhu9


Acha Acha theek hai, he's the best and no one on earth can come close to him, okay? 😆


Chill dude, it's just different opinions on something that's as subjective as acting. And saying that someone is an average actor doesn't amount to disrespecting them.

In my opinion Harshad i incomparison in front of sushant my opinion ok DNT fight engaging legend yes no can come close to him ever he was the best
Edited by Waidehi - 3 years ago
Waidehi thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: HahaHeheHuhu9


Hmm, 2016 the end was a small budget film, without accomplished technicians or crew. And they couldn't actually release the film due to demonetisation.


And Kai Po Che's director and producer, plus the story writer, were all celebrated people in the industry in their own right. And the book it was based on was a bestseller.


We can't actually compare their films like that to compare acting. If we want to have a subjective opinion on acting, we could compare the acting that has similar parameters, not two things which are unrelated.

u will even say Harshad is better than srk Aamir to price Harshad nice u will used legend who is no more wow hats off 👏
HahaHeheHuhu9 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: Waidehi

In my opinion Harshad is nothing in front of sushant my opinion ok DNT fight engaging legend yes no can come close to him ever he was the best


This is the problem.


It's difficult having a civil conversation with fangirls where we can't put subjective opinions on acting across.


There's no need to demean one person to lift up the other. And commenting on someone's acting, which is MY opinion by the way, is not the same as commenting on the person's worth which is what you've done unfortunately.


And yours or my opinion on anyone's acting or their worth is not going to make any difference in the larger scheme of things. So yeah, cheers and have a good day!

HahaHeheHuhu9 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: Waidehi

u will even say Harshad is better than srk Aamir to price Harshad nice u will used legend who is no more wow hats off 👏


I never brought all these names forward. And I never said anyone is a legend.


And two people can agree to disagree on something as simple as a subjective opinion on acting.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".