Originally posted by: kavya1994
@Brown: No, he can't remain silent specially with Monami after gunshot and quitting academy incident.
Reason: Faizi's words; that cadets connects with him, they can't understands his moods specially Monami, he should talk to her.
âď¸Faizi's words affects Karan a lot because Karan knows that his friend knows and understands him better than others, otherwise he never goes to Monami's room on Faizi's say.
âď¸In the picnic too,
đ¸Karan explains his words "kisi ke liye bhi" to Monu only because Faizi was highlighting it again and again.
đ¸He comes to the picnic only because Faizi asks him to treat Monami in a better way than what he was doing with her, which Karan confesses too before Faizi in the picnic, heard by Monami too.
@Pink: If he was about to close the door from outside that means he has already decided to go outside and celebrate diwali with all, which wasn't the case.
Reason: He is not shown as thinking something after reading the second note, but it happens from 5:16 to 5:29 min.
@Sea Green
đĽFirst: He came for his 'cadets' only including Monami too as cadet only.
Reasons:
đ¸He starts thinking something after reading second note + Faizi's words about cadets in past (mentioned above)
đ¸2nd point in his pehli baat which he tells to Monami that Khadoos Shergill ki wajah se sabhi diwali kharaab ho jaaye, that's not right.
đ¸Karan is always shown as a leader/trainer who is always there for his junior and cadets.
His scene with Sanju when he says to her that she is not Sanju but SA.Sanjana Dubey and makes her feel better after the disastrous date incident. He also comes to Koel to know the reason why Rawat calls her name as main witness.
Now, after knowing what all Monami has done for him, for baby, for others, also after understanding that he misunderstood her as other privileged rich kids, Karan uski diwali unhappy nahi hone de sakta. He is compensating in installments for all above.
đĽSecond: Him wishing her with smile.
Karan knows very well how to hide his pain and smiles for others. Baby ki liye aajtak woh yahi karta aaya hain. He comes out of the room plastering a smile on his face, it's not just for Monami, Ustadji se bhi woh halki si smile ke saat hi baat kar raha tha.
đĽThird: Him wishing Monami
When Karan is not in Khadoos mode, and he has to say his 2 baatein then he doei starts his 2things directly, kuch na kuch pehle bolna zaroori hain usko, mudde ki baat par baad mein aata hain, as when he comes to Monami saying Sorry after her return back to academy.
Other time when his Khadoos mode is on he says his 2 baatein directly, when he comes to Monami's room after locking up Sid in jail.
@Orange: He came for her.
If that's the actual and only reason, he goes directly to her after coming outside and is not looking here and there(11:33 to 11:37 min), she's just before eyes. The place is not even crowded(11:23min) Also after looking at her he can make some excuse to Ustadji and can go to Monami but he doesn't. He continues his talk with UstadJi.
@Violet: Him opening upto her
If he doesn't want to open with her or let her know that he is somewhat opening to her, he never tells her that he is not a social person to Monami that day when he comes to say Sorry. He can end it just by saying Sorry for his behaviour in jeep. On shopping too, he never says to her that "kash woh aisa kar pata" when she talks about sharing pain.