Why it needed to be YRKKH 3? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

as 3 shows are running on same concepts for example

1. Ghum - Pakki didi's one sided love and mission Virat

2. Imlie - Malini didi and Imlie fighting for the same man

3 YRKKH - Aarohi wants to win over Abhimanyu (( icchee Noddee))

upcoming shows

if Kartikye Priyam is going to replace ZMGA then it's again about a doctor marrying the dark skinned sister and the fair one troubling them

The only show which is going to be very diff is kabhi kabhi itefaq ( it's a comedy one).

The writers and producers of YRKKH should not buckle to pressure. They can show more of Kairav trying to reason out with the sisters and yes they better bring grandparents in the Birla Household. Dadi or bua, anyone to break the ice.

I understand they wanted to remake some hit regional serial.. and wanted to revamp the show... and also do not want to loose the current fan base..

But they could have selected a show which resonated with the earlier YRKKH vibes.. right? Why choose the love triangle with toxicity. Especially when there are 2 already with the same concept. (toxic family+ love triangle)

And as I understand, these shows are majorly taken from bengali shows.. are you saying there is no successful show which do not have extreme toxicity in west bengal?

Why only this serial?

Originally posted by: umawanderer

I understand they wanted to remake some hit regional serial.. and wanted to revamp the show... and also do not want to loose the current fan base..

But they could have selected a show which resonated with the earlier YRKKH vibes.. right? Why choose the love triangle with toxicity. Especially when there are 2 already with the same concept. (toxic family+ love triangle)

And as I understand, these shows are majorly taken from bengali shows.. are you saying there is no successful show which do not have extreme toxicity in west bengal?

Why only this serial?

Sincerely no clue. Harshad is particular about a story and character growth. I hope he has asked for changes in the script.

toxic family + love triangle is a big hit. That is why channel is latching to it. However it is just not Bengali but even certain telugu ones are also adapted. The channel is trying by getting some of kind of variety in the early evening slots but numbers are not upto the mark.

They are only showing what sells. At the same time RS is a big time producer and he can put his feet down. Just retain the original essence and mellow down the Birlas, show conflict of interests not negativity.

if they manage then yes everything will fall into place.

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

if Kartikye Priyam is going to replace ZMGA then it's again about a doctor marrying the dark skinned sister and the fair one troubling them

When I read this.. I felt as though I already saw it...

It just clicked... Didn't they already do it, "Kartik Purnima" The premise was same I guess... I never saw it.. but I think it was dropped really fast.

Originally posted by: umawanderer

When I read this.. I felt as though I already saw it...

It just clicked... Didn't they already do it, "Kartik Purnima" The premise was same I guess... I never saw it.. but I think it was dropped really fast.

same one.

SP is in one big mess.

Good question! I have thought the same.. I don't see much connection with the first two seasons 😆

You are right, I have been a YRKKH fan from the very beginning, I have watched almost all the episodes from starting till now and I can feel that this current new generation track is just not the original yrkkh type, because ye rishta had always been a family show with lots of positive character and almost nil negative ones. This is what makes ye rishta the best show till now. And this positivity and "only good characters" have made it possible for the show to continue for so many years and that too by always being at the top in trp list. But in this birla family there is no yrkkh vibe, they are all negative people. The makers should try to make their family a bit positive and lively. Also on goenka's side many characters are missing. They should bring in the singhania's too because in yrkkh, the family members, all the relatives, cousins have played a major role in bringing the leads together, be it KAIRA or Akshara, Naitik. This time also they should continue with similar family scenes, festivals, functions, picnics.... Just like true yrkkh type.. Hope we could see more of the original yrkkh type tracks in future😊

To be honest, even I would have loved a new season or a new show even but that's only because that way, the actors would have the chance to gain their fame, work hard towards it ( they are already doing but we could see the impact too bcoz now a lot of YRKKH viewers are old fans too except HC Fans *huge in no's*) , would not get faaltu ka hate too...

Originally posted by: umawanderer

My relationship with YRKKH is a bit weird..

I know everything what happened in 1 gen story arc only through my sister.. never saw a scene properly.

never knew what happened in 2 gen story(really clueless..)

now only started to see 3 gen because I suddenly was curious..

From what I have heard from my sis, I thought it was a family type serial. But the new promo looked as though it was going to lean towards romantic genre. I was just curious how they will execute the change.. that's all

Now...

I am more curious why they needed to continue in YRKKH.

They could have started a new show with the same cast members(the main 3 at least) and went ahead. This generation is not much related to the previous 2 generations. There is not much mention.

I know that they just wanted to make use of the already existing fan base, but even then the old fan base is connected to old cast.. they could have some scenes with the 3rd and 2nd gen before just rushing into the story.

And anyways, HC fan base is actually quite large.. I think.. wouldn't the new show get benefited by that?

I feel this was a bad move from producers. They are making one daughter a saint and another a vamp. But both a Karthik's daughters (A character whom I thought many people liked(?)) That would be doing bad for the original fan base.. I think..

What do you guys think?

Well Apparently I think Rajan Shahi wants to set up a record of longest running tv show and thus season 3,i agree with you that this could easily be different show with same leads, as yrkkh always have very positive vibes and now it's drained. Yrkkh never had vamp or grey characters now we have Aarohi

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

It seems Star wanted to axe YRKKH.

THE CHANNEL are doing very well in copying and converting regional content into itv versions.

Accordingly, Icche Nodee, Kartikeya Priyam and Korkotu were supposed to come in different time slots. One them was meant as YRKKH replacement.

Icche Nodee makers had finalised Rhea Sharma and some web portals mentioned that on the basis of SM engagement there were plans to approach Harshad for the remake. Rhea's look test was done.

I guess RS did not want to loose his slot or the show, after a number of meetings he does retain the slot but Icche Nodee becomes YRKKH 3.

No one is talking about the remake anymore, Rhea as such is anti social and there is no statement from her side too even the Production House refused to comment.

Logically a new show based on Icche Nodee would have been a better option..

It Is k ind of dicey as the writer is just following the original. The Birla family are full of rebels and there are no YRKKH vibes.

The writer has to concentrate on the Goenka's, reduce Aarohi's obsession, get a dada or dadi for the Birla's and tone the negative atmosphere which essentially was the key feature of Icche Nodee.

If we leave everything aside then in 2019, RS had YRHPK on board with Shaheer and Rhea as leads. He brought back Maheshwari's but infused sibling rivalry and jealously. THIS WASN'T THE CASE AS KUHU AND MISHTI WERE ON VERY GOOD TERMS WHEN THEY WERE LITTLE.

In the spin off their relationship was toxic.

The show did not get the reqd numbers and shut down after a year of being on air.

The writer has to watch the OG YRKKH episodes if he wants to retain trp audiences

I agree now it's no longer yrkkh, and I feel really nostalgia while remembering old yrkkh episodes, specially with Hina and Karan