V-S. throw them in the garbage can - Page 2

Arre if we throw every MD and singer judge in the garbage then who is left😊? We need them for reality shows to survive.

There is no such thing as unbiased judgement. Every one gets influenced by some or the other factors which we may or may not like.

I love Shaky as judge 😛 . Vishal i am not sure 😉

Farah has improved as judge since II days 😳

I think VS and Javed Akhtar are one of the best judges in the reality shows..

To err is Human..(Not everytime the judges will be right..) However in Regards to Prajakta issue.. I think the reason she was given a second chance was because it was the first week of show.. and prajakta is definitely a good singer and top contender for the title.. However if one remember she was judged purely on her singing and nothing else..

Second count.. She was genuinely sick and to pull of the song 'tere bin nahin' it takes alot of courage.. ppl fail to do so when they are perfectly fine.. VS know if a person has the potential to go on ..Thus their grades.. I still think they are the best judges by far 😊

Originally posted by: princess1_43

I think VS and Javed Akhtar are one of the best judges in the reality shows..

To err is Human..(Not everytime the judges will be right..) However in Regards to Prajakta issue.. I think the reason she was given a second chance was because it was the first week of show.. and prajakta is definitely a good singer and top contender for the title.. However if one remember she was judged purely on her singing and nothing else..

Second count.. She was genuinely sick and to pull of the song 'tere bin nahin' it takes alot of courage.. ppl fail to do so when they are perfectly fine.. VS know if a person has the potential to go on ..Thus their grades.. I still think they are the best judges by far 😊

Now I am going to be DA and say will judges do that for all the good singers and give them chance twice????

I like Prajakta and think she is good singer too. But we don't want this to come back as a big issue when some other good singer is not given 2nd chance and is eliminated. That is where all the drama and hungama starts IMHO. Judges are there to be fair and mark contestant in a way which will not raise an issue in future for themselves.

I could be wrong here but my commonsense tells me I might have a point here 😳 😃

ahahhaaa, VS aree one of the best judges, they wudnt give prajakta 10 marks for no reason, they would know that its not fair,

soo i think that they probably heard her rehearsing before the show, and she probably sang it REALLY well that time,, sooo yeahh 😛

Eventhough I do not agree with them giving Prajakta a second chance during the first week and then giving 10 this week, I still like them and want them to stay as judges.

Shekhar can leave if he wants to but Vishal needs to stay 😆 Heck, I don't even want Amit Tandan eliminated.....so don't come attacking me now on Shekhar leaving if he wants.....it should be obvious that I don't know what I am writing here 😆 ...but but but...Vishal stays...KDNBKD 😉

^^^^ GRRRRRRRRRRRRR im attacking u fr ur post above

dhishum dhishum dhishum
😆

I would call VS a good judge only if i see Prajakta singing in their next movie. They have given her a blanket judgment of being a good singer. I am surprised that VS have followed II-1 (they have mentioned Amit Sana's Kisna Hai) , how come they missed Prajakta and did not use her voice later ?

I'm wishing one of the singer's throat would be bad this week and also forgets their lyrics at the same time. Than we will have a Issue here. V👎🏼S👎🏼- they can go kiss my a** if they want to. who cares if their the best judges. If You want Real Competition in the SHOW. BRING IT ON!!! LOSERS or leave for sympathy. 😳

Originally posted by: Maya_M

Arre if we throw every MD and singer judge in the garbage then who is left😊? We need them for reality shows to survive.

There is no such thing as unbiased judgement. Every one gets influenced by some or the other factors which we may or may not like.

were talking about straight forward judgment here. Farah gives a better scores than VS. It should strictly be based on good singing. These Singers have already had the experience from another reality show. 🤔🤔 Prajkta should know better than.