Originally posted by: inlieu
Aside from the non-stop loud bgm everything was perfect in the episode.
In a different situation, Pallavi might have felt betrayed but he had made it clear from the beginning that he was going to protect Keerti. I just don't think she expected him to go that extent. Never mind the fact that she was careless about the pen.
I have always wanted to see Raghav hear directly from Pallavi how she felt as a woman, as a new bride, when her dreams also died the night Mandaar died, how she had to deal with the aftermath, and how she was hurting all this time, something she's never really discussed. So glad we got that today. She wasn't verbose but said just enough for us to understand which aspects of her widowhood had been tough for her to handle and how important closure was. It had the same vibe as the maar daalo mujhe Raghav scene.
Raghav's reaction showed that he had understood all this a long time ago, even before today's confrontation. If you think back to how he's been burdened by guilt since he first found out about Mandaar's accident, it all makes sense. He'd foreseen all this, which is why what's happening now is not a surprise but hurts both of them just as he had expected it to. I could understand why he was struggling to look her in the eye or stand in the hall and see her in tears.
I loved how they showed both characters hurting, while contrasting their ways of expressing themselves. Pallavi was letting out all her pent-up emotions and concerns, while Raghav's was quieter, fewer words and to the point, but still conveying the main ideas he was struggling with.
I'm glad he brought up the abortion fiasco and drew parallels like we were doing here. One thing that many people don't mention in that regard is that the abortion also involved the loss of an innocent life. Of course the repercussions for the rest of the family were different. This is not a debate about being pro-choice or against, that is a matter for another discussion, perhaps another thread. It's just a fact and that's what they subtly brought it in today. I liked that he didn't disparage Amruta or BWA but was focusing more on what Pallavi's mindset was when she tried to keep it under wraps. The 'crimes' are different but that wasn't the point. It was their drive to protect their families that he compared. Like Amruta relied on BWA or Pallavi, Keerti seems to be overconfident that her brother will save her from punishment. I wonder if she's playing on his guilt about what happened 10 years ago or if she genuinely believes she deserves to be saved.
It was good to see Pallavi asking Raghav if she wasn't his family too. I don't think she got it that when he talked about saving his family, he was including her too. If Keerti goes to jail, Raghav will be mentally and emotionally finished, as will Amma from the looks of things. What family can he offer her then? He is in a completely different headspace but since he's never really discussed this with her, she hasn't seen that perspective. I understand her being goal-oriented and wanting to punish the offender, it makes sense and it's the morally right thing to do, but ironically, as she was talking about him learning about relationships from her but not about standing by the truth, she failed to see that even when it comes to the truth, there are two sides to the coin. In this situation, it's not quite black and white as she believes it to be.
Damn, both of them are in such a tight spot it hurts to see them this way.
I might get bashed for this but I still want to say something about Pallavi's outburst today. She made it sound as if he didn't care about her emotions and that what he was doing to protect Keerti was totally steamrolling over her pain. That was not the case and I was glad to hear that expressed in his quiet main tumhara dard samajhta hai Pallavi, followed by him explaining how he couldn't take another destruction in his family while already battling with the guilt and trauma of the death of his family members. I had always felt that he still has a loooooooooooooooong way to go before he can overcome the trauma of losing his father and brother, and that reconciling with Amma wouldn't be enough, but I am so glad that they touched upon that today, albeit briefly.
Everyone's been talking about the effect of all this on Keerti's life or Raghav's or Pallavi's or the Ds, but what about Amma? How is she going to feel losing another child this time to a prison sentence? I found her initial reaction natural because she was completely caught off guard, but I also loved how she calmed down in the room to think things through and pay closer attention to what was happening around. her Props to Jaya for asking Raghav to help Pallavi, she didn't disappoint. It takes a LOT to make that kind of judgment call, that too in such a short period of time. I think her first reaction was aimed at the TRP audience who would've expected such a thing from her and potentially see her turn against her bahu, but the follow up was for the core audience of the show.
I am wondering if Raghav will change his mind about Keerti because of what Amma says or because he has already made up his mind but is keeping his cards close to his chest. Knowing his nature, either of those would make sense.
So it looks like Pallavi finds a way to barge into jail but something has also happened that makes Raghav feel ok about telling her what happened that night when she probes him for details. I think these two work best when the have these meaningful discussions. I wish Pallavi had done so from the start with Raghav instead of bulldozing through his actions in her efforts at getting justice, but I also understand that she's struggling to handle her emotions right now and is focusing on the end, not the means.
I don't want to talk about Keerti because I'm reserving my judgement about her motivations until the truth is out. I feel as if what Raghav told Pallavi plus Keerti's reaction in the precap is what will make Pallavi start to think about the other side of the coin that she hasn't considered. I also think that through this track, Pallavi will start to be more accepting of the fact that rather than truth being an absolute, one can be on any point on the spectrum. What happened on that night is a fact, but how the people involved felt and reacted to it is not black or white.
Jean ❤️
Such a great breakdown of the episode! I've been frequenting these daily threads less and less these past few days, and I've really missed breaking these episodes down with you.
I agree with a lot of what you've written here.
On Raghav, I will be upfront in saying I don't condone his approach, at all. That said, I do understand it completely, and it is what I expected, so I'm not surprised. I may not be able to justify him, I understand perfectly. I've been pretty vocal about Pallavi getting unwarranted hatred in the past, today I feel the level of flak Raghav has been getting is as uncalled for. Unfortunately, what's happening is Raghav is suffering the fall out of Kirti's (frankly, despicable) behavior, which isn't fair to him because we know how Kirti is acting, but Raghav doesn't. What's happened is that audience tide has turned against Kirti, hugely, and since Raghav has her back, he's facing the fallout as well. It's a little unfortunate to see a fandom so polarized right now, but it's also expected, I guess, in a track like this.
I wanted to reserve judgment on Kirti as well- as you know, I've adored the girl from day 1, so I'm not able to go all out in hating her, but her behaviour has been quite upsetting. At this point, the best case scenario is that she was just a passenger in the car, and not behind the wheel- she's still complicit though. I can understand panicking and running away in the moment, especially if she and/or Sunny were under the influence, but they did leave him to die. The least she could have done is called for an ambulance anonymously. And if the precap is anything to go by, she's even taunting the wife of the man she killed about how she's going to get away with it. I agree that there's a lot more to the story right now- why does Amma believe she was in Guntur (it's a 6 hour drive from Hyderabad, so I doubt she could have just slipped away- CVs messed up, or something more)? Can she drive or not? How does Sunny figure into all this? How does Ved? But that said, it's hard for me to sympathise with her right now- any sympathy I feel is carrying over from the immense goodwill she earned with me in the past. I am dreading a conclusion to this which boils down to 'it was all Sunny's fault, evil Sunny', and I'm afraid that's where it's heading.
On Pallavi, she's the one I'm unable to find at fault in this situation TBH. Probably the only thing I've found annoying was both her and Farhad nicely telling Kirti where the confession was, and that she kept the pen with her and not with Farhad. That was dumb. I'm also dreading whatever gun pointing tamasha she's about to cause at the police station, but I'll contain my annoyance till it actually plays out. Her husband was killed, and the man she's now married to is actively blocking her from seeking justice, so I don't blame her for bulldozing. She's being far more empathetic that I would expect someone in that situation would be, and I've been rooting for some selfishness from her for a while, so I can't not cheer her on when she's finally doing it. Yes, I do wish she'd handled it a bit more elegantly with Jaya, but I'm willing to forgive that because of what she's dealing with right now from the bhai-behen. Though she doesn't speak much, the helplessness and desperation for justice is quite palpable.
On RaghVi- I actually didn't Raghav him bringing up the abortion thing, because I don't find the situations comparable wrt Pallavi taking the blame onto herself then and Raghav doing it now. Firstly, while I absolutely know it was neither your intent nor Raghav's, comparing abortion to a crime makes me uncomfortable. And second, well, Pallavi didn't jump up to take the blame onto herself, it was pinned on her and she did make attempt after attempt to disprove the allegation, which she did do with her family in the privacy of her bedroom. Considering Mansi's marriage, an innocent in the situation, was on the line, I think what she took issue with was Raghav's approach of the very public spectacle. She was primarily shielding an innocent Mansi, and not Amrutha, and even if it was Amrutha, she was covering her from social stigma, and not the well-deserved, legal and moral, consequences of a crime. That said, I was not on Pallavi's side when she was behaving that way- Raghav's name had been dragged publicly, and he had every right to clear it publicly as well. Similarly, I can't support Raghav now, no matter how much my heart hurts for the impossibly hard situation he's in.
"If Keerti goes to jail, Raghav will be mentally and emotionally finished, as will Amma from the looks of things. What family can he offer her then?"
I agree completely with what you've written here. But if Pallavi has to let go, and pretend to be happy family with the person responsible for Mandaar's death, her pain, her family's struggles, she will be emotionally finished too, and then what marriage will she be offering?
I'm so very glad we got a one-on-one between RaghVi today, I may sound like a broken record now, but their communication issues will be their downfall, and today at least felt like a step in the right direction. We've spoken before about wanting to know about Pallavi's experience of being widowed in such a traumatic situation. I was annoyed when they played a song over Pallavi sharing the last time, and I'm glad we got a glimpse of it today. Every word she said pierced my heart, and I'm pretty sure it pierced Raghav's too, but his response came across as rather insensitive to me. It was basically, "I get you, and I know you're in a terrible situation, but too bad, this is what it's gonna be, find a way to make peace with it." As audience members, we get a lot more insight into Raghav than Pallavi does, and while we do understand how strongly he feels for Pallavi, she doesn't. And after today, I won't blame her if she shuts down further and is less inclined to share- she's not really being made to feel heard, and opening up has been a challenge for her anyway.
Same with his insistence that if she needs to see punishment being served, he's happy to serve himself up on a silver platter. Again, from his perspective, I don't think there could be a bigger indication of how much he values her. The fact that he's putting himself on the line, it's proof that she features in the short list of people he values above his own self along with Jaya, Kirti and Farhad. Else he has enough and more resources to close this entire thing off without anyone being punished, and she won't be able to do a thing about it. But if I look at it from her perspective, it feels emotionally manipulative. He knows she'd never let him take the fall for such a big crime when he's not at fault, so by constantly putting himself on the line, there's a sense of 'drop this or else..' Frankly, this plan of his has seemed quite stupid ever since she found out he was trying to frame himself as the culprit, and isn't the culprit himself.
I know this is long already, but I'll make a last point- I don't think she's feeling betrayed, really, but rather disappointed and hurt. You're right, I doubt she realized he'd go this far, but all of us watching did. I'm glad in some sense that this is happening, as heart-wrenching as it is to watch. I always felt she was falling too hard, too fast, especially considering none of the lines he's crossed before their wedding were ever really addressed- the truck incident comes to mind. I was hoping she'd have some reservations, but I guess it was in character for her to go all in. I am hoping this will make her pull back a little.
Edited by aye-masakalii - 4 years ago