Khuda Aur Mohabbat 3| Discussion Thread #3 - Page 58

Originally posted by: rivaanvira

Which novel? I do not know any novels though, never read any urdu novels.

Me neither - But isnt KAM1 based on HM novel of the same name?

Yes, Ishqiya had the worst written female lead (Humna) and the actress I do not know had a single expression in every other scene, and it was painful to see the show seeking sympathy for her. Feroze-Hania had an amazing chemistry though, even the characters they played had similarities in their traits. I think the show has been so famous because of the crackling chemistry.

Yeah I saw some episodes but didnt like the Humna female. But have been thinking of watching it for FK & Hania's chemistry only

Yes Mir Hadi's journey was beautiful and he did not deserve the girl, a justified ending. But the show even though titled as kHAANI, seemed like a Mir Hadi's journey, the character Khaani had no growth post 5th episode I think and I thought the focus was too much on Mir Hadi's ishq, guilt and redemption. But whatever it was, it was good.

I didnt really enjoy Sana's screaming in the show .. I was cringing at it most of the time.

Infact my mom was totally blown by FK's acting in it..

everyone is confused that whether they will delete the train station scene, that was one of the most beautifully shot scenes, and if they delete that one also

Nahiiiii - the last thing I want is that scene to be deleted !! But I dont know how they will incorporate it either

I do not know anything about KAM1, so cannot answer you sorry

Yes you can watch Ishqiya, it is more like a guilty pleasure, but Hamna might try your human heart and brain's patience 🤪

Sana's scream, as in Khaani giving baddua in that 'Mir Hadi azaaad' scene? I thought she did well though, also both of their lines are so iconic, from azaad to barbaad, kind of how it happened in the show. Okay so even your mom was blown by his acting? One of my friend and her dadi was watching the show, and my friend told me that Dadi was blown away by this munda's acting 🤣, and Dadi predicted that Hadi would kill Khaani's husband to win her back, Dadi was high on ITV soaps though.🤣

I do not have any thing to say, that teaser 2 was my favorite, and fans of this show waited so long for that sequence, if they delete it, it will be unfair, why show it in the teaser if it was not meant to be shown

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

I detest any kind of ITV shows, like please not interested. I really do not have the patience and time to watch the shows, the last hindi show I watched was Bepannah just because Harshad was marvelous and again it was lowkey a male centric but the way the handled the whole EMA track , it was 🤢

ITV's problem is they start with such promising arcs for male leads and it goes down just the way temperature in my place during fall.🤣

Nah re even i got pissed off with thei false promises ..

The last I saw was Jennifer Winget's Behadh .. started off very well but they just killed it completely later due to channel politics .. Since then been off it. Prefer web-series .. at least they culminate on fixed episodes

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

I do not know anything about KAM1, so cannot answer you sorry

Yes you can watch Ishqiya, it is more like a guilty pleasure, but Hamna might try your human heart and brain's patience 🤪

Sana's scream, as in Khaani giving baddua in that 'Mir Hadi azaaad' scene? I thought she did well though, also both of their lines are so iconic, from azaad to barbaad, kind of how it happened in the show. Okay so even your mom was blown by his acting? One of my friend and her dadi was watching the show, and my friend told me that Dadi was blown away by this munda's acting 🤣, and Dadi predicted that Hadi would kill Khaani's husband to win her back, Dadi was high on ITV soaps though.🤣

Ha ha .. Dadi's predictions !! Oh I love her !!

I do not have any thing to say, that teaser 2 was my favorite, and fans of this show waited so long for that sequence, if they delete it, it will be unfair, why show it in the teaser if it was not meant to be shown

Lets wait & watch I guess

Yes, Farhad definitely is the more complicated character if compared with Mir Hadi. Also, Mir Hadi was presented as a larger than life persona, whereas Farhad is presented as someone who has probably failed in every step of his life, be it academics, parents' expectations, love and even now he failed his basic good ness too, it is traumatizing to be in such a state for anyone, and I believe the journey we will see will be great, it is more like abandoning the materialistic pleasures to please the God. Over here, I also feel he will wear Mahi's earring bead as an amulet only after the guilt hits him hard.

@bold: Yes, that journey will be soul-touching!! Actually, in one of teh OST snippet, he is wearing the bead as an amulet .. not sure whether its before guilt or after guilt

I am sure writer just tried to calm down the extreme reactions upon the baddua, like people behaved as if this was the last episode where Feedi won and mahi lost, like calm down guys, all he meant was the journey just started. But i do not agree with the writer's points of Nahid and Sajal, it did not show up in the episodes, so we cannot just assume within ourselves. But the writer clearly mentioned that Feedi will experience different stages of love, I do not know whether i should trust him or not

Yes to err is human, and Feedi is a hSomeuman, who is flawed, who is hurt, who is aimless too, and now whether the divine power forgives him is yet to be seen.

Arey this story is only flawed - with flawed characters, editors, story writer, director ... Sab !!

Waise when Allah/God forgives, they bring you closer to him ..

Yes, if he would have let her go without the curse, it would still mean that a heart was broken, and God has seen it, even in real life there are many incidents when someone's intentional/unintentional words or actions hurts you so much that it leaves you shattered and God gives everything back as karma even though you do not ask for it loud. This scenario is similar too, Mahi's unintentional or even silly prank led to someone's honest ending up heart broken, God has seen it and even without Feedi's curse mahi would've got it back. However, Feedi asking for that destruction made it insensitive because again just because a dog bites me, I cannot bite it back, same theory applies here, he was still the better man and he should have stayed true to his values at least, he broke the code here and he will repent for it, he was not literally responsible for anything Mahi will go through, but yes the impact of his curse will always sustain and make both of them miserable.

I guess that was the whole reason why he has to fall to that bottom of the pit to be able to detach himself from everyone & everything and finally seek solace in God !! He wont find that peace until he realizes the destruction he caused, albeit unknowingly through that curse, for her. Its like sometimes you have to fall to learn to walk without falling again

Seems like a competition of who eats their words faster here.. The fact that she will pine for him and he will try his best to hide from her will be ironic though. Like at one stage of their lives, he would do anything to get noticed by her and now he will hide from that face, I think he will also believe that he is not capable of her, or worthy of her as she had already said. But she will tell him that 'he was the better man' ..

Somewhere his guilt that his curse caused her suffering will make him hide from her or not want to meet her. Even though she would want him back or his forgiveness

At least I am not taking it very seriously, do not know about others.. But i do not like any negativity and I avoid it, I love discussing the characters but not dissing them though.

Infact I am enjoying this conversation. Since PB days, I havent indulged in so much chit-chat about characters without getting overwhelmed by it

I cnnot tolerate negative comments and hence I refrain from commenting on IF or any social media platform.. not my cup of tea

I think you are right, Mahi has already seen that whatever he did, it was only for her validation, and I felt that his departure news did not relieve her, it was more like she wanted him to leave to get some peace but his absence is bothering her more now. Sajal opening her mouth to Mahi could only happen if both Sajal and Mahi are crying for their Devdas together..

🤣Sajal & Mahi crying like Paro & Chadramukhi for their Devdas

But anyways - yes she wanted him to leave so that she could be at peace. but ironically it has made her more restless now that he is gone .. ab kahan bhejegi Fakeera ko aur kaise?!?!

That is it na, he is not God but only a normal human being with feelings , why did people expect him to behave like one who can never commit anything wrong, the reactions are so extreme that it seemed like everyone expected Feedi to kiss Mahi's feet after the humiliation, like why , they had already established that he was blind and terribly delusional, he never had his own brain to process too. That is what I could say to justify his actions..

Thats the problem with most viewers .. they skip most stages of character love and jump staright to last few stages - worship & madness - their fav can never be wrong

the trick is to 101 ways to torture the male lead . By the way, I am glad at least watching a show where male lead has more agni pariksha than female lead, no matter what, somehow Feedi will be connected to Mhai's in laws too, I am telling you

Haan doesnt he become the friend of Sikandar & peer baba for Tooba. I hope he doesnt become the junior peer baba to their amma .. Oh please nahi 😆

ZGH type of shows can work at any time I think, such shows are just rare and will always find an audience.

Haan .. Those were some shows in those days .. ab to sab saas-bahu, naagin & commercialization pe hi tika hua hai .. Waise the saas-bahu bug has also hit some latin american show too ..

Originally posted by: rivaanvira

Yes, Farhad definitely is the more complicated character if compared with Mir Hadi. Also, Mir Hadi was presented as a larger than life persona, whereas Farhad is presented as someone who has probably failed in every step of his life, be it academics, parents' expectations, love and even now he failed his basic good ness too, it is traumatizing to be in such a state for anyone, and I believe the journey we will see will be great, it is more like abandoning the materialistic pleasures to please the God. Over here, I also feel he will wear Mahi's earring bead as an amulet only after the guilt hits him hard.

@bold: Yes, that journey will be soul-touching!! Actually, in one of teh OST snippet, he is wearing the bead as an amulet .. not sure whether its before guilt or after guilt

I am sure writer just tried to calm down the extreme reactions upon the baddua, like people behaved as if this was the last episode where Feedi won and mahi lost, like calm down guys, all he meant was the journey just started. But i do not agree with the writer's points of Nahid and Sajal, it did not show up in the episodes, so we cannot just assume within ourselves. But the writer clearly mentioned that Feedi will experience different stages of love, I do not know whether i should trust him or not

Yes to err is human, and Feedi is a hSomeuman, who is flawed, who is hurt, who is aimless too, and now whether the divine power forgives him is yet to be seen.

Arey this story is only flawed - with flawed characters, editors, story writer, director ... Sab !!

Waise when Allah/God forgives, they bring you closer to him ..

Yes, if he would have let her go without the curse, it would still mean that a heart was broken, and God has seen it, even in real life there are many incidents when someone's intentional/unintentional words or actions hurts you so much that it leaves you shattered and God gives everything back as karma even though you do not ask for it loud. This scenario is similar too, Mahi's unintentional or even silly prank led to someone's honest ending up heart broken, God has seen it and even without Feedi's curse mahi would've got it back. However, Feedi asking for that destruction made it insensitive because again just because a dog bites me, I cannot bite it back, same theory applies here, he was still the better man and he should have stayed true to his values at least, he broke the code here and he will repent for it, he was not literally responsible for anything Mahi will go through, but yes the impact of his curse will always sustain and make both of them miserable.

I guess that was the whole reason why he has to fall to that bottom of the pit to be able to detach himself from everyone & everything and finally seek solace in God !! He wont find that peace until he realizes the destruction he caused, albeit unknowingly through that curse, for her. Its like sometimes you have to fall to learn to walk without falling again

Seems like a competition of who eats their words faster here.. The fact that she will pine for him and he will try his best to hide from her will be ironic though. Like at one stage of their lives, he would do anything to get noticed by her and now he will hide from that face, I think he will also believe that he is not capable of her, or worthy of her as she had already said. But she will tell him that 'he was the better man' ..

Somewhere his guilt that his curse caused her suffering will make him hide from her or not want to meet her. Even though she would want him back or his forgiveness

At least I am not taking it very seriously, do not know about others.. But i do not like any negativity and I avoid it, I love discussing the characters but not dissing them though.

Infact I am enjoying this conversation. Since PB days, I havent indulged in so much chit-chat about characters without getting overwhelmed by it

I cnnot tolerate negative comments and hence I refrain from commenting on IF or any social media platform.. not my cup of tea

I think you are right, Mahi has already seen that whatever he did, it was only for her validation, and I felt that his departure news did not relieve her, it was more like she wanted him to leave to get some peace but his absence is bothering her more now. Sajal opening her mouth to Mahi could only happen if both Sajal and Mahi are crying for their Devdas together..

🤣Sajal & Mahi crying like Paro & Chadramukhi for their Devdas

But anyways - yes she wanted him to leave so that she could be at peace. but ironically it has made her more restless now that he is gone .. ab kahan bhejegi Fakeera ko aur kaise?!?!

That is it na, he is not God but only a normal human being with feelings , why did people expect him to behave like one who can never commit anything wrong, the reactions are so extreme that it seemed like everyone expected Feedi to kiss Mahi's feet after the humiliation, like why , they had already established that he was blind and terribly delusional, he never had his own brain to process too. That is what I could say to justify his actions..

Thats the problem with most viewers .. they skip most stages of character love and jump staright to last few stages - worship & madness - their fav can never be wrong

the trick is to 101 ways to torture the male lead . By the way, I am glad at least watching a show where male lead has more agni pariksha than female lead, no matter what, somehow Feedi will be connected to Mhai's in laws too, I am telling you

Haan doesnt he become the friend of Sikandar & peer baba for Tooba. I hope he doesnt become the junior peer baba to their amma .. Oh please nahi 😆

ZGH type of shows can work at any time I think, such shows are just rare and will always find an audience.

Haan .. Those were some shows in those days .. ab to sab saas-bahu, naagin & commercialization pe hi tika hua hai .. Waise the saas-bahu bug has also hit some latin american show too ..

yes .. exactly, like he had to hit rock bottom and do some metamorphic damage to regain the virtues he had, it will be exciting if they do not mess up with the screen play and editing anymore.

mahi and sajal crying together ke devdas nahi raha abb yehi baki rehgaya tha dekhneko 🤣.. it is funny because the writer already said that devdasiyat hai iss story mein, lekin itni devdasiyat bhi I did not expect, but Mahi's paro run will be a guilty pleasure to fans , imagine Feedi himself would faint too seeing Mahi losing her shit for him 🤣

About both Tooba's char and sikka following and Feedi playing hide and seek with Tooba's characte rin the OST makes me 🤣.. On top of that Tooba's character was playing hide and seek with Feedi even before he turned into the saint outfit, like WTH was happening there, I wonder if Tooba's character will make some kind of promise to Mahi to bring back her lost lover 🤔🤣.. And why is Feedin running away from Tobba, he doe snot even know her, and should not even know her right? 😳

Sikka going to Feedi for some healing and Feedi saying main kya madad karoo, mujhe khudko khudki baddua laggayi yaar 🤣.. Also, I am sure Taimoor's amma will also run after Feedi for some kind of madness, or may be Mahi ki khushiyan🤣.. All in all, Feedi ko chain milne se raha, on top of that Nazim shah would send his hench men to back stab Feedi, abhi karta toh samajh aata lekin future mein kyu karega ye nahi janti.. I have a very huge gut feeling that Mahi will hold a microphone and announce it in whole bhawalpur that she loves Feedi, that can explain why everyone is running after the homeless and useless man continuously 🤪

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

Some indian critic in twitter praised Feroze. He watches KAM3 I guess..LOL

Rohitt Jaiswal


@rohitjswl01

·

Best scene till now from #KhudaAurMohabbat.... I can feel his pain... Terrific actor he I must say...

This scene was really best wow acting

I knew it! Iqra is pregnant 😆

Originally posted by: SteFanSalvaTor

Which novel? I do not know any novels though, never read any urdu novels.

Yes, Ishqiya had the worst written female lead (Humna) and the actress I do not know had a single expression in every other scene, and it was painful to see the show seeking sympathy for her. Feroze-Hania had an amazing chemistry though, even the characters they played had similarities in their traits. I think the show has been so famous because of the crackling chemistry.

Yes Mir Hadi's journey was beautiful and he did not deserve the girl, a justified ending. But the show even though titled as kHAANI, seemed like a Mir Hadi's journey, the character Khaani had no growth post 5th episode I think and I thought the focus was too much on Mir Hadi's ishq, guilt and redemption. But whatever it was, it was good.

everyone is confused that whether they will delete the train station scene, that was one of the most beautifully shot scenes, and if they delete that one also

😡😡 mai katal kar dungi unka

But as he is same dress i feel she will come to meet him its there last meeting

Mere sunhare duppate wala run😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

Kha liye makers maaf nahi karungi

Originally posted by: Ash_Smash

I knew it! Iqra is pregnant 😆

Aare wah congo to the couple

Originally posted by: FarhaadkiMahi

😡😡 mai katal kar dungi unka

But as he is same dress i feel she will come to meet him its there last meeting

Mere sunhare duppate wala run😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

Kha liye makers maaf nahi karungi

Yes possible, it was still night when Feedi left, so it is possible that Mahi gets up and visits him for the last time and she will probably seek for an apology.