Please...... can we have less of her? - Page 2

Wonder what reaction the judges will have if these comments were posted on their twitters?? especially Neha. Will she step down after reading the comments or tone down??!!

Originally posted by: Ashley.Tisdale

Can we have no more of her.

There are so many more talented people in the music industry who deserve that seat. Neither her comments are helpful nor does her being there make any sense.

Esp when there were guests like Pyareji, Javed Akhtar, Jatin-Lalit, Sonu Nigam have graced the stage...then there's Neha.

Idk what's wrong with the creative team. Get newer and better judges. This is getting monotonous af.

Neha can’t even sing properly without a synthesizer. Almost all contestants sings better than her. She is unfit and underserving to be a judge at this level.

Originally posted by: ~Raina~

True, as much as I like Vishal (because he doesn’t get into hysterics), he doesn’t seem to understand classical music. He prefers more modern music.

I have absolutely no words for Neha. She’s just famous for being famous. She butchers every song she sings. How can she judge another?

While I’d like to believe HR understands different genres of music better than the other two, he is too dramatic at times.

There are so many better suited people to call, some of whom I’ll list.

Udit Narayan

Kumar Sanu

Alka Yagnik

Shaan

Shreya Ghoshal

Sunidhi Chauhan

Kavitha Krishnamoorthy

Rajesh Roshan

Sonu Nigam

Shankar Mahadevan

Ismail Darbar

Sajid Khan

Vishal Bhardwaj

Jaspinder Narula

Sadhna Sargam

Arijit Singh

Add Abhijeet.

I'd like a fresh new judge panel on this show to revamp it a little.

Abhijeet

Shaan

Shreya/Sunidhi/Jas Narula

Originally posted by: nads_rocks

Add Abhijeet.

I'd like a fresh new judge panel on this show to revamp it a little.

Abhijeet

Shaan

Shreya/Sunidhi/Jas Narula

Even Monali Thakur did pretty well in saregamapa li champs

Originally posted by: mickymouse21

Even Monali Thakur did pretty well in saregamapa li champs

I don’t like Monali as a judge. I remember her in rising star, and many contestants were better than her.
they didn’t have her back for season 2

Originally posted by: mickymouse21

Even Monali Thakur did pretty well in saregamapa li champs

Monali Thakur will just be another Neha Kakkar type of judge.

Both were contestants on Indian Idol and so I rather not see her judging the same show she once participated in.

I think this show needs a much more versatile and neutral type of judge.

Abhijeet is a no nonsense type and he would make a better critic and speak out where it needs.

Shaan would be good choice as he wont be all gaga and standing ovations type of judge.

A female I think at this current time only 2 come to mind, either Sunidhi again or Shreya.

Originally posted by: nads_rocks

Monali Thakur will just be another Neha Kakkar type of judge.

Both were contestants on Indian Idol and so I rather not see her judging the same show she once participated in.

I think this show needs a much more versatile and neutral type of judge.

Abhijeet is a no nonsense type and he would make a better critic and speak out where it needs.

Shaan would be good choice as he wont be all gaga and standing ovations type of judge.

A female I think at this current time only 2 come to mind, either Sunidhi again or Shreya.

Actually i have seen Monali judging saregamapa lil champs 2014 where arunita was contestant.

I felt she was not bad and also she is definately not like neha

No chances of having Neha less or going.

Neha Kakkar says Indian Idol is a 'cult show' and ... - Pinkvilla

Neha says “I won't do any other reality show other than Indian ...

Originally posted by: Ms.S.K.

No chances of having Neha less or going.

Neha Kakkar says Indian Idol is a 'cult show' and ... - Pinkvilla

and

Neha says “I won't do any other reality show other than Indian ...

Koi aur show karegi to usko nikal ne ke chances hai on public demand 😂

But ye to uske jeeju ka show hai...yaha pe permanent post pe hai woh 🤪

Abhi kuch saalon baad indian idol ki Mahaguru banegi woh.. singhasan lagega uske liye alag se 🤓

Originally posted by: mickymouse21

Koi aur show karegi to usko nikal ne ke chances hai on public demand 😂

But ye to uske jeeju ka show hai...yaha pe permanent post pe hai woh 🤪

Abhi kuch saalon baad indian idol ki Mahaguru banegi woh.. singhasan lagega uske liye alag se 🤓

Right, since her brother in law is in charge I doubt she's going anywhere soon 🤪

We're gonna get the same old gibberish comments, overacting, lip-syncing, her pretending to be some glam heroine.