Being Holmes T19 (Sheep pg 4, Answers, Theories, Leaderboard pg 25) - Page 19

Originally posted by: dusk2dawn

Hello ji sab ko salaam namaste..

Finally done with 2nd dose of covid vaccination ..😆

15 min baitha diya hai humko..🤣

Idhar akele baithe kya karu socha chalo sabko hi bol doon..😆

Congratz on getting vaccinated for the second time. 🤗 Please take care.

Guess what, I signed for Shibz's sheep game. 😆

Originally posted by: Ariyatogether

Take care🤗

Great..be a good sheep nd let us win🤣

😆 Ya 5 more minutes and I am going out. 😆
aise kaise competition tagda hona chaahiye😉

Originally posted by: hasini009

Google baba jawab nahi diya toh aapse puch sakte na. kyunki you are the shepherd. Shepherd ka farz hota hai sabhi sheep ko ek direction mein le jane ka🤣

jis shepherd se aap sampark karna chahte hai, woh iss waqt FAWS ke khayaalon mein vyast hai, kripya game khatam hone ke baad koshish kare

Originally posted by: Ariyatogether

Achha hua pehle clear kr diya..kal maine Zeal bahut curse kiye the Hollywood dale ke liye🤣Use mat batana🤫😆

Usne easy dale the 😆

They were lil predictable

Itna curse mat karo 😆

Originally posted by: tournesol

Tod do hadhe, Beyhadh ho jao. You can do it. 😂😂

hey bhagwaan mere🤣 I was quaoting faisal, you made it about Maya🤣

Originally posted by: Minionite

That will come with finale. Warna everyone will know who ranked where. 😎

Leaderboard nahi toh R6 hi sahi. Excluding BP 1 and BP 2😆

Originally posted by: tournesol

Congratz on getting vaccinated for the second time. 🤗 Please take care.

Guess what, I signed for Shibz's sheep game. 😆

Awesome ab aayega maza bhed chaal mein.. 😆

thank you dear. Keeping spirits high ghar jaa kar so jaungi. 🤣

Originally posted by: Radiant_Eyes_

Usne easy dale the 😆

They were lil predictable

Itna curse mat karo 😆

Yep the to thode predictable coz jeetne wale ans maine soche the fir kuch aur daal diya😆Nhi kr rhi kal hi kiya tha bas🤣

For Round 6, I present to you a sample of the answers that I had accepted as evidence acceptable in a court of law. Note that these aren't the only answers. I just chose the answers that at least 30 to 40% of players submitted and am sharing them here. There was a lot of other evidence presented outside this.

1) The weapon at the crime scene was one piece of evidence that most people here gave in some capacity. One it was Emil’s own gun with his fingerprints on it (an allowable inference) and with gunpowder on his fingers (again an allowable inference). Two the gun was close to the victim in a position that would usually indicate suicide.

2) Warning signs of sorts – The EMA, which disturbed Emil and gave him a lot of trouble. He has also dealt with a lot of such cases before and knows that they don’t end well because it not only kills a person, but humanity as well.

3) A few people also noted that in the evidence, it was found that Emil enjoyed secrets and puzzles, which also adds to the fact that he killed himself and set up the scene like a murder.

4) In general, the crime scene had too much evidence just lying around and setting up Emma and John Rockfort as the murderers. If they had really killed Emil, then they would have made every effort to hide this fact, not set themselves up.

5) Blood spatter indicates that it was a close contact wound and given that it was on the left hand side and Emil was right-handed, this proves that Emil shot himself. Note that this is a very brief summary. The few people who argued this had a paragraph of details and inferences that led up to this point.

6) A few people made an inference that Emil’s fingers had soot on them which would come from burning paper. This inference was allowed as well.

7) No signs of a struggle. The shoe was far away from the body, which meant it either had to be taken off or come off in a struggle. But there were no signs of a struggle in the room, which means that it came off by itself. Given the rest of the evidence so far proves suicide, it means that Emil took the shoe off himself.

8) The only evidence that someone else was in the room was the blood on the book and if the murderer had wiped away all evidence of him/her being there, why did they leave the blood on the book? Also the blood was older than Emil’s death which meant it was deposited there at a different time.

9) Emma’s statement also proves suicide. She originally lied about Emil not having a gun and then told the truth. If she was the murderer, she would never have accepted that Emil had a gun and would instead have posited that the gun wasn’t Emil’s. She lied because she wanted the insurance money which she couldn’t get if Emil’s death was proven a suicide.

With permission from the player, I also present these 2 pieces of evidence as is. My friend was highly impressed with these submissions and said that in many ways these could be used as is in a court of law. Also the way this player got these details from a very small case was brilliant. I will not reveal who this player was, but if they wish to come forward themselves then that is their wish.

Gun and Shoe : The Gun was registered under Emil’s name . And according to Emma, Emil kept the Gun in his Study’s safe. And the Key to the Safe was hidden in his Shoe, while Emma admitted to the knowledge of Key hiding place and the Gun, she also stated that Emil has a habit of taking it out on Wednesday’s only to clean it. And the Shoe was found without the key far away from the body

Inferences and Crazy Theory : Emil held the key to the safe with in his person(Shoe) and according to the witness statements recorded by Watson and the Player, Emma was alone with Emil at the night of the Murder. Emma or anyone couldn’t have overpowered Emil and took his shoe out while he was alive, so that they can open the Safe to get the Gun in the first place. If Emil had been alive when Emma or anyone took the Key from him. It doesn’t make sense that he would simply sit and get himself shot. Based on the Crime Picture where his body was on the Chair. And The forensics didn’t find that the body was moved either based on the blood spatter which is in accordance with the gunshot wound.

And if Emma already took out the Key from him without his knowledge, there was no need for her to take the shoe from his dead body after killing him, as she already have the key with her. If the murder was premeditated, and the Gun was with Emma long before so she can shoot Emil by surprise, then the Shoe need not be removed from his body.

But If the Murder was on impulse, then Emma or anyone couldn’t have possibly removed Emil’s shoe without him putting up a fight, and the fact they were able to shoot him while he was still sitting in his chair is highly unlikely for a possible Murder Scenario, while leads to the fact that Emil death couldn’t be a murder as the Crime scene and the murder weapon accessibility is questioned.

Further inferences can be drawn upon the following above statements that the only other person who had easy access to the weapon remain Emil and the chances are that it was indeed a Suicide.

The Robber (Missing Nature Photo and Legal Documents, New key): Someone had broken into Emil’s study and turn that room upside down. In the process leaving behind three more clues for the detectives to find.

Inferences and Crazy Theory 2 : The Robber who broke in to the house could either be the murderer or someone sent by the Murderer. And his Objective was supposed to be searching for some evidence that points towards them. The Prime Suspect of the case are Emma, John and Jimmy

But the key which leads to the truth of Jimmy being a terrorist was left in the table for the detectives to find, Similarly the legal documents were thrown around the floor as if pointing the detective interest towards them and the message hidden by Emil, even if one could assume that those were mistakes made by the Thief. The missing Photo was an altogether different case.

The only thing the person who broke into Emil’s study seemed to have stolen is the Photo in the Shelf. But according to Watson’s statement, the detective had already removed the Original Photo from the Crime Scene and Replaced it with Nature Photo. But the Robber had stolen the nature Photo which has no connection to the case as it held no clue either to point towards Emil’s murderer or anything related the Murder Suspects.

Which leads to the Suspicion, the robber has been specifically assigned to steal the Original photo in the first place but stole the nature photo without realizing that it has been replaced before which means the Robber couldn’t possibly be the murderer as he lacks the knowledge about the evidences.

But the Point to be noted is that all the action of the Robber only lead to more evidence found easily by the detectives. The legal documents were left behind on the floor, to garner the interest of the detective, so did the Key which led to the information regarding Jimmy and finally even though the Picture stolen by the thief had been wrong, it only made the detectives focus on the Original picture which was the one that held another hidden message from Emil.

Since It was highly likely that the Robber was not the Murderer, as he or she left behind evidence against them and took the one photo that actually had nothing to do with the case. And if someone hired them to find the evidence against them, he wasn’t doing his job properly either as he left behind all the evidence and stole something unrelated to the case for no reason

So the only other alternate is that someone paid the Robber to ransack the house, steal the picture and leave behind or highlight the Evidences that had Emil hidden message, and who likely to know more about the hidden messages then Emil, himself. Which means it could be Emil who hired the Robber prior to his death.

So that all the evidence he created will likely be found including the hidden message that stated Emma was Cheating with him and that they were planning his death. So the suspicions could fall on John and Emma.

Which leads to proof this could be a pre-planned event, but unlike the possibility of Premeditated Murder, it could be Emil motive to have revenge for his Wife affair and thus making his Suicide look like a Murder by creating hidden messages and Proof that could act as a evidence even after his death.

Originally posted by: Ariyatogether

Mere words ko tod marod diya😡🤣

Tumhare Dil ki baat thi 🤣

Mujhe samjh gayi 😂🤣