Kurban (2009): wtf was that? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Lord_Voldemort

Islamophobic movie.

Why? Because they showed Muslim terrorists? By that logic, any movie showing Hindu mob lynching should be Hinduphobic, right?

A great film, though I was disappointed Because I expected it to be a lot better.

Saif Ali Khan was outstanding , Kareena & Vivek were also great.

Kareena was damn beautiful in it.

It was a cliche

It could’ve been better but alas. But so much passion between Saif and Kareena

Originally posted by: Mahisa22

Why? Because they showed Muslim terrorists? By that logic, any movie showing Hindu mob lynching should be Hinduphobic, right?

If EVERY Hindu character was shown only as a mob luncher, and no good Hindu characters than yes, that would be Hindu-phobic.

Coz that's what Kurbaan had, with the exception of Vivek. You know Pakistan made a movie called Khuda Ke Liye that was about terrorists and Muslim terrorists, but it was very well received. Coz it was balanced. It showed good Muslims as well.

This was nice

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ryY2Pspj1xU

RASIYA was the only jam from that soundtrack. I didn't like the rest of the tracks.

But the film on the other hand was AMAZING. Rensil D'Silva displayed some TALENT. Although I keep forgetting to check out his other work.

Not to mention it's one of Kareena Kapoor's best PERFORMANCES. Top 10 for sure, maybe Top 5.

Originally posted by: desigal90

If EVERY Hindu character was shown only as a mob luncher, and no good Hindu characters than yes, that would be Hindu-phobic.

Coz that's what Kurbaan had, with the exception of Vivek. You know Pakistan made a movie called Khuda Ke Liye that was about terrorists and Muslim terrorists, but it was very well received. Coz it was balanced. It showed good Muslims as well.

Why is it mandatory to show good Muslims when the movie is about terrorists? Would it be mandatory to show 'good Hindus' while making a movie on say, mob lynchers?

Originally posted by: Mahisa22

Why is it mandatory to show good Muslims when the movie is about terrorists? Would it be mandatory to show 'good Hindus' while making a movie on say, mob lynchers?

It’s not

Movies are never meant to be taken as anything other time pass

Tho sometimes the wrong person reads too much into them. That’s why sometimes these stereotypes shouldn’t be pushed

kareena was really pretty and finely dressed in the first half.

both kurban and newyork were copied from hollywood film arlington road. what amuse us here is despite being family aditya chopra and karan johar werent aware of the fact that they were making the same film investing crores of rupees.

I like Ali Maula song from this film. Haven't watched the film though. Just didn't appeal to me.