Re-living YRHPK journey // Episodic Discussion Thread 2 - Page 71

Originally posted by: suryavni

Yup the pre marital courtship was the flagship track...

And I think they messed up that too...

Here it just shows that how Misht's attempt to know her partner failed..

Leaving aside Abirs love track

She never got to know Kunal as her partner..

It would have been nice if the rishtha was straight up and she got to know Kunal and then decide he was not for her..

Other than summerising her opinion on the words he used on their gd day..

BM pushing mishnal and praising Meenu..🤣

Meenu so knew about Abeer's plan.

Bro scene...OVER MY HEAD..

Kuku scene was good where Kuhu asserted her individuality..

As an all in fan of nach baliye here ..I loved the whole thing❤️

I agree, mishti never really got to have a courtship with kunal. They did try to show it with some little scenes here and there like kunal sending flowers through uma patel and him asking her to fix an appointment before meeting him or his phone always being engaged. But yeah, that wasn't courtship.

Writers were trying to explore many things at the same time, I feel. They were trying to stick to the original concept of the show i.e. courtship, they also wanted to address adopted/foster kids's life, they were also experimenting with siblings(?) bond, they were establishing meenu's character and they were also trying to show mishbir love story itna sab hoga toh mess toh hoga hi na.

Hehe yeah, this was the first nach if we dont count the rap wala dance i guess. 😆

Originally posted by: Sumaiya27

I completely agree. Naanu definitely failed in raising meenu. I can't believe maamu and meenu are siblings raised in the same house: they are polar opposites

Yeah in these initial episodes all characters had their own flavour and no one was just standing as an extra

Yeah, wish kaushal mamu had a little firm spine and meeny was little more human.

Yup, all they needed was to take one track at a time. But they opened so many tracks at once and then it got messed up. koi na, at least later they mostly focused on mishbir love story i guess?

Originally posted by: m4manju

Yeah, wish kaushal mamu had a little firm spine and meeny was little more human.

Yup, all they needed was to take one track at a time. But they opened so many tracks at once and then it got messed up. koi na, at least later they mostly focused on mishbir love story i guess?

no yaar they never cared about mishbir love story The producer himself said this is a sibling story 😡

Originally posted by: Sumaiya27

I think the pre-marital courtship worked in a way because mishti did find out that kunal is not right for her. She also ended up doing courtship with abir indirectly

But I agree, abir shouldn't have faked everything on behalf of kunal

@bold

This was a wrong message..

Indirect courtship Kya hota Hein...??

Abir was expressing his dormant/suppressed feelings and his own self through his actions..

And Mishti never knew what he was feeling ??

She thinks flowers and shayari as part of courtship??

Idk...!

Meaningful Conversation never happened between either Mishbir or Mishnal before Mishnal toota gd.

🤷

Originally posted by: m4manju

I agree, mishti never really got to have a courtship with kunal. They did try to show it with some little scenes here and there like kunal sending flowers through uma patel and him asking her to fix an appointment before meeting him or his phone always being engaged. But yeah, that wasn't courtship.

Writers were trying to explore many things at the same time, I feel. They were trying to stick to the original concept of the show i.e. courtship, they also wanted to address adopted/foster kids's life, they were also experimenting with siblings(?) bond, they were establishing meenu's character and they were also trying to show mishbir love story itna sab hoga toh mess toh hoga hi na.

Hehe yeah, this was the first nach if we dont count the rap wala dance i guess. 😆

True, there were trying to do so many things at once and ended up making a khichdi

There were other dances like mishku's piya piya and mishti's dance at the kutch utsav 😆

Originally posted by: Sumaiya27

no yaar they never cared about mishbir love story The producer himself said this is a sibling story 😡

wtf 😔 but it was much later no? like after mishbir wedding (or whatever it was), after that it turned into sibling story no?

khair, what's done is done now.

Originally posted by: Sumaiya27

True, there were trying to do so many things at once and ended up making a khichdi

There were other dances like mishku's piya piya and mishti's dance at the kutch utsav 😆

Oh right. But i think kutch wala more of singing with little stage performance.

piya piya ko i watched on 1.5 so bhul gayi 🤣

Yeah and luckily some bites of this 'khichdi' are still good so we spend all these nights discussing them 😆

Originally posted by: suryavni

@bold

This was a wrong message..

Indirect courtship Kya hota Hein...??

Abir was expressing his dormant/suppressed feelings and his own self through his actions..

And Mishti never knew what he was feeling ??

She thinks flowers and shayari as part of courtship??

Idk...!

Meaningful Conversation never happened between either Mishbir or Mishnal before Mishnal toota gd.

🤷

idk what makers were trying to show with the courtship..maybe they were trying to make way for mishnal rivalry and make kunal hate mishti?

Originally posted by: m4manju

wtf 😔 but it was much later no? like after mishbir wedding (or whatever it was), after that it turned into sibling story no?

khair, what's done is done now.

no he was always thinking of it as a sibling show that's why kuku tracks were always shoved in between mishbir's tracks even though both fandoms didn't like it. Then during the lockdown many people were requesting makers to change that but see what we got instead

yeah what's done is done..we can't do anything about it now

Originally posted by: suryavni

@bold

This was a wrong message..

Indirect courtship Kya hota Hein...??

Abir was expressing his dormant/suppressed feelings and his own self through his actions..

And Mishti never knew what he was feeling ??

She thinks flowers and shayari as part of courtship??

Idk...!

Meaningful Conversation never happened between either Mishbir or Mishnal before Mishnal toota gd.

🤷

Yeah mishti got played actually and it was like 'the joke is on you babe' 😔 the broken mishnal goddhana because of wrong reasons and meenu's interference messed it up otherwise it would have been nice to see how actually fruitful pre marrital courtship was.

I dont think she considered shayri and flowers as courtship, even before her GD with kunal, she wasn't sure she was ready but she said yes anyway.