Yeh Rishtey Hai Pyaar Ke Live Updates/EDT 17 Sep 2020 - Page 39

Originally posted by: Su94

Bold: Ya, heard of this. If ever laws, logic were applied in the show...

Italic:Kunal could go whichever way the writers choose depending on which pair they want to separate:siblings or couple.

Track should be called hashtag Change of Equations. Which would be interesting were it some courtroom drama or a reality show par yahan..

Kya raita failega. Itna drama I can't stomach please. Especially when it's gonna mean more dukh for MishBir.

PS:Also, we shouldn't forget Meenu, who dictates her own laws. As much as she hates Mishti and doesn't care to see her suffer the consequences, she will never let the child be called "Not Abir's." Drama ghar tak hi restrict kar denge where Kuhu's curse will come true. Plus, Kuhu is doing all this to ensure KuKu can stay on in RJV house forever.

Su, let me PM you so I can say something if I say it here I might get into trouble

Why would Abir leave Mishti to fight a custody battle on her own; he wanted kids; this would be his baby too; he might have said that he cannot take a child away from a mother that keeps the baby in her womb for 9 months BUT can he watch Mishti, his Mishti, who cannot have babies suffer in silence?

These two will probably give KuKu the baby and be happy with being addressed as Abir papa and Mish mommy.

Also, if the court, which looks at safeguarding children before all else, is told that Kuhu went along with this for selfish reasons (which Meenakshi is capable of seeing Abir in distress) then the court will give MIshBir the baby.

This plot has not been researched at all; creative liberties can only be taken up to an extent. No wonder GA has doctors on its writing team.

Like I said, someone please tell the writers:

1. I might fangirl but I aint a dimwit

2. This show is most likely not aimed at people who can critical analyse; i am actually offended that I am grouped into "online fans"; let me shut up before i turn into a SNOB.

3. I am watching this show for one person ONLY

Originally posted by: Stardust91

Su, let me PM you so I can say something if I say it here I might get into trouble

Why would Abir leave Mishti to fight a custody battle on her own; he wanted kids; this would be his baby too; he might have said that he cannot take a child away from a mother that keeps the baby in her womb for 9 months BUT can he watch Mishti, his Mishti, who cannot have babies suffer in silence?

These two will probably give KuKu the baby and be happy with being addressed as Abir papa and Mish mommy.

Also, if the court, which looks at safeguarding children before all else, is told that Kuhu went along with this for selfish reasons (which Meenakshi is capable of seeing Abir in distress) then the court will give MIshBir the baby.

This plot has not been researched at all; creative liberties can only be taken up to an extent. No wonder GA has doctors on its writing team.

Like I said, someone please tell the writers:

1. I might fangirl but I aint a dimwit

2. This show is most likely not aimed at people who can critical analyse; i am actually offended that I am grouped into "online fans"; let me shut up before i turn into a SNOB.

3. I am watching this show for one person ONLY

I agree with all of your points.

But if the show would go the way we want, this whole bachha track wouldn't have been started in the first place.

Originally posted by: Su94

I agree with all of your points.

But if the show would go the way we want, this whole bachha track wouldn't have been started in the first place.

So from what i have noticed on SM, a LOT of writers/PHs look down upon online fans because there is a lot of trolling, a lot of nonsense said. a lot of fan wars, too much noise.

This is why it is not in my nature to message anyone from a show EVER. EVER. Like end my show; i'll be sad BUT i will never message them.

I feel the YRKKH writer is a sincere person from what I have seen on SM; however that has nothing to do with this show.

i understand that you should ask what you want or else how do you know; but that ship has long sailed.

The TRPs were talking to the writers; and yet this track carried on; either they have shot a lot of it and now cannot change it halfway or they have gone too far along and it is not easy to return

Originally posted by: Stardust91

So from what i have noticed on SM, a LOT of writers/PHs look down upon online fans because there is a lot of trolling, a lot of nonsense said. a lot of fan wars, too much noise.

This is why it is not in my nature to message anyone from a show EVER. EVER. Like end my show; i'll be sad BUT i will never message them.

I feel the YRKKH writer is a sincere person from what I have seen on SM; however that has nothing to do with this show.

i understand that you should ask what you want or else how do you know; but that ship has long sailed.

The TRPs were talking to the writers; and yet this track carried on; either they have shot a lot of it and now cannot change it halfway or they have gone too far along and it is not easy to return

Bold:Have to give them credit for keeping the track open ended in case they might have to salvage it later on, like hopefully now. The story became unpredictable as a result along with the characters, where we were praising one episode and bashing the following one. Like a see saw.

Italic:I suppose that they also know that the online fans are a meagre percentage of the TV viewers. Number of people with hotstar subscriptions who watch the show(especially at 6am with simultaneous commentary on SM platforms:fb, twitter, IF) isn't a reliable yardstick to judge the popularity of the show or if whether what we want is the general consenus.

But I still think they don't entirely ignore or overlook what we want either. Because they also have no other outlet than SM platforms to get feedback. A lot of times they surprise us by incorporating scenes on fan requests. And a lot of celeb interviews(not specific to YRHPK) mein they confessed to acknowledging online fan comments and suggestions and trying to see if they can work any of them into the shows.

I know that on IF, people have been unanimously against this surrogacy track but there are some odd ones on Twitter who are not entirely against it either. Maybe they are blindly loyal to the show and don't want people discouraged from watching, losing viewership.

This track has still not reached a concrete conclusion and online SM fans are definitely the reason.

PS: Some might say that PS show includes romantic scenes on fan requests but ours doesn't. I honestly wouldn't want to go there as what the actors are comfortable with portraying must be respected. I 90% watch for the story and am okay with compromising on the 10%. I find Twitter embarrassing with trending "you can do it Abir/Mishti" hashtags . Come on, leave them alone if they didn't want to spice up the IT sequence like other lead couples.

These guys are unique because their equation is beautiful. Anyway, whole other topic that people already went into intense details about, comparing AM to other show leads. I just wanted to state that if we think that our PH/writers aren't listening to us online fans over requests for romantic scenes, it has got nothing to do with them considering or not considering our opinions on tracks. I just brought it up because lack of intimate moments are one of the major reasons for trolling the show, even more than the tracks. If you notice, in a lot of shows with shitty tracks, people still remain glued to them because the writers throw in hot scenes.

Originally posted by: Su94

Bold:Have to give them credit for keeping the track open ended in case they might have to salvage it later on, like hopefully now. The story became unpredictable as a result along with the characters, where we were praising one episode and bashing the following one. Like a see saw.

Italic:I suppose that they also know that the online fans are a meagre percentage of the TV viewers. Number of people with hotstar subscriptions who watch the show(especially at 6am with simultaneous commentary on SM platforms:fb, twitter, IF) isn't a reliable yardstick to judge the popularity of the show or if whether what we want is the general consenus.

But I still think they don't entirely ignore or overlook what we want either. Because they also have no other outlet than SM platforms to get feedback. A lot of times they surprise us by incorporating scenes on fan requests. And a lot of celeb interviews(not specific to YRHPK) mein they confessed to acknowledging online fan comments and suggestions and trying to see if they can work any of them into the shows.

I know that on IF, people have been unanimously against this surrogacy track but there are some odd ones on Twitter who are not entirely against it either. Maybe they are blindly loyal to the show and don't want people discouraged from watching, losing viewership.

This track has still not reached a concrete conclusion and online SM fans are definitely the reason.

PS: Some might say that PS show includes romantic scenes on fan requests but ours doesn't. I honestly wouldn't want to go there as what the actors are comfortable with portraying must be respected. I 90% watch for the story and am okay with compromising on the 10%. I find Twitter embarrassing with trending "you can do it Abir/Mishti" hashtags . Come on, leave them alone if they didn't want to spice up the IT sequence like other lead couples.

These guys are unique because their equation is beautiful. Anyway, whole other topic that people already went into intense details about, comparing AM to other show leads. I just wanted to state that if we think that our PH/writers aren't listening to us online fans over requests for romantic scenes, it has got nothing to do with them considering or not considering our opinions on tracks.

Bold - Yes because Bhavna LISTENS to fan requests; even when there was a third angle, she had the leads confessing their love ASAP and turned it into a jealousy track because of the amount of backlash. She still laughs about the backlash on her lives with her lead actors to this day. However, can you imagine that this third angle track got immensely high TRPs.

I do not think PS lead couple SRs were like Balaji telefilms or ALTBalaji lead couples IT. Just that their show revolves around them. However, I get asked MANY times not to bring them up so like i said. Await my PM.

I think people need to WATCH a scene before they make comments on how scenes on other leads are. Let us remember that this is DKP and not Balaji Telefilms.

Can I just PM you on this topic; may be better lest someone arrives and asks us to stop the comparisons.

I have glanced through some messages that online fans send and they are embarrassing; they are also at times weird (for lack of a better word). Those messages make me CRINGE. Like i said if I say anything more I will come across as a SNOB so best to not.