Originally posted by: Kalma007
I loooooveeed the SR scene as well.
That being said, the difference btw the two situations you described is: Malhar in their first marriage mistreated/punished her a lot thinking she helped SamThu and refused to believe otherwise... and that wasn't the only case where she had to prove her innocence.
Kalyani here is only asking a question, is hurt seeing him with a pregnant wife... understandable things when you love someone who seems to have moved on and who you think shot you and they won't clear the MU nor tell you why they did it. Kalyani isn't actively involved in making his life hell, her family is doing it for their own reasons without involving her because they know she won't partake in such nonsense against someone she still has strong feelings for. So, as someone who watched both tracks, it's not the same thing, as Kalyani isn't spending most of her time planning how to punish Malhar... accusing him when the topic comes up of shooting her and wanting answers or of Pillu's death is hurtful to Mallard but isn't comparable to the kind of creative torture Malhar put her thru in the first few months of their marriage. Not saying one hurts more than the other, but she does try to avoid him, knowing it won't lead to good things (and I suspect now that Anu has touched the Madhuri subject and made comparisons, she will be even more determined to avoid him, especially if and when she finds out about Mrunal/Avni's father).
Kallu's emotions and feelings are in right place.
In season 1 situation even after it was proved that she didn't help samptrav, mallu used to misteat her, like during anupriya's brother's track, atul's Nexcelats wala track, he thought kallu hurt swara and in many other situations. I used like completely support her in that.
In season 2 also i understand that shez managed everything alone for 5 years, lost son, living with MU that mallu shot her and been searching for anupriya etc.
And yeah that's obvious that when u see someone u love with another woman no one can handle their emotions.
But here kallu's behavior, emotions and dialogues contridict in most of the scenes and so are anupriya's
Like kallu says she thinks that mallu blames her for pillu's death so he shot her dead. When mallu didn't utter a word in fact in that shooting scene she was accusing was accusing him for losing pillu. Now again in the precap she clearly accused malhar. If we think it in the way that in that situation she was carried away by her feelings thinking of avni and malhar's relation and their baby. Even the other individual standing in front has feelings emotions and Everything right! And she hasn't thought that what imapct it wound have on the father when clearly accusing a father or his son's death! That's very illogical for me and also it contridicts with her previous dialogues etc.
And also the dialogue that she says 'why didn't u wait for me' doesnt' make sense as mallu never knew she was alive so whom and how he will wait for.
And also her dialogue talking about mallu' ego doesn't make sense as mallu never did anything in ego, like he is proud to salute to kallu,happy to be her bodyguard, he holded anupriya's legs asking why she is leaving him in rachit's track, he kneeled down in front of AS for the sake of moksh when he was in jail (season 1)
Also in season 1 malhar didn't know kalyani properly till they spent time together after their marriage
But here kalyani knows him completely. what kind person malhar is and how he is. She even fell in love with him. Still thinking that malhar would shoot her deliberately wanting her to die. And if she believes that he went to such extent and shot her cuz he blames her for losing moksh then how can she say that cuz of his ego they lost moksh..
All her dialogues, statements and emotions are contradicting with each. I donno what to say. That's why i feel that it's very illogical.
Edited by Chandu_500 - 5 years ago
Anupamaa
