Kangana arguing with scientist on twitter - Page 9

Nothing I repeat nothing should stop you from sharing your opinion and thoughts on any topic you have limited knowledge about, you don't have to be an expert.

That is such a wrong message to send, in my POV.

It's like telling people not to open their mouth if you are not an expert, why not???

I strongly believe you should, the more question and opinions one puts forth, it leads to more discussions, debates, and more knowledge and research.

How can anyone think this is a serious respectful debate between a layman and professional? Kangana referred to this Dr. as Dr. Doolittle. She's not only ignorant but so proud of her paucity of knowledge as to be demeaning.

Originally posted by: Tede_naina

your sarcasm always makes me 🤣

I am glad to know that.

Originally posted by: desigal90

Some scientist with a PhD is being schooled by "science student with private tuitions in psychology".

"I know about grey matter, neurons and their interactions through electrical events n neurotransmitter, I have been a science student, have done a project on brain where I constructed 3D model of human brain, I have also taken private tuitions of human psychology 🙂" - Kangana scientific Ranaut

Is she really arguing with a scientist with a PhD? And her defense is private tuitions in psychology? Challo, from now on, no need for engineers, doctors, lawyers who spend years studying and garnering their degrees. Let everyone just take private tuitions in any subject 😂

How on brand for you to comment on education while Saif Ali Khan has multiple times mentioned Eugenics even though studies have shown that IQ and Eugenics have been proved wrong. Try not defending that next time.

Someone who consistently posts about how intellectual they are while discussing Eugenics is a complete moron to me. Saif Ali Khan is a racist. Much more dangerous than loud and obnoxious Kangana.

Originally posted by: tina59

Oh I find it amusing, bcoz on one hand, they call her attention seeker who does it for attention, but who gives her attention, by posting her every tweet , the very people who hate her "attention seeking".

This really amuses me, coz I as a fan do not post so much about her as her haters. I guess that says a lot, also the fact that most of the forum runs with her posts.

But please continue, its interesting and fascinating

Tinaji you know very well why don’t you post “as much”

Cause most of the time what she talks is baseless, hate mongering BULLSHIT.

You very conveniently post half edited statements to make her look better. Much like when you and even kangana herself only posted one line from ssr lawyer statement... you didn’t post the article where he said kangana is on her own trip furthering personal agenda

Originally posted by: tina59

Not necessarily, that is your opinion on the matter. She is debating on the diagnostic methods applied to identify mental illness and there is nothing wrong in sharing a perspective based on how much you know on the matter.

Again, if it is foolish, she will be trolled and offered counter-arguments and trolled anyway but should that stop one from coming forward and sharing what they think they know on the subject matter or issues on her own twitter handle where is allowed to.

My answer is NO, it should not stop you.

No u are wrong....if the subject matter is such that it can cause death or a serious disability then its better to keep ur mouth shut if you are not a subject matter expert....because as a celebrity there are lots of impressionable minds and gullible minds following you.....and your one wrong advise can be a matter a life and death...so any celebrity who is not an SME needs to STFU ...I don't care if its my favorite SRK or ur favorite Kangna......her rant on depression was one such rant....what if a 14 year old child decided not to tell her parents about her depression to her parents after listening to Kangna....and killed herself after a week...who is going to take responsibility?? Kangna aur jinhone usko sir per chadhaya hua hua...unhone toh turant haath jhaad lena hai...het I am not a psychiatrist I was giving my opinion...u shouldn't have listened to me.....well she was a 14 year old...a impressionable and gullible mind...those are the kinds of people I am scared for when ....these nakli doctors/psychiatrist talk as if they know everything...

Originally posted by: tina59

Nothing I repeat nothing should stop you from sharing your opinion and thoughts on any topic you have limited knowledge about, you don't have to be an expert.

That is such a wrong message to send, in my POV.

It's like telling people not to open their mouth if you are not an expert, why not???

I strongly believe you should, the more question and opinions one puts forth, it leads to more discussions, debates, and more knowledge and research.

This is typical. You defend the indefensible by changing the argument. Kangana did not give her opinion or admit she was expressing her limited knowledge. She stated as fact easily disproven falsities. She never said or implied it was only her opinion and in fact listed “credentials” to support her “expertise.” When called on it she resorted to name-calling and belittling.

In general everyone should be able to freely share opinions but in high stakes esoteric fields, maybe you really shouldn’t. Without question you should not be pretending to be an expert on a very misunderstood charged topic that can, literally, be life and death.

Oh well. Kangu trying to incorporate Bolly ki quota as they usually do.

Bollywood's Genetics and DNA Expert ~ Saif Ali Khan

Bollywood's Warren Buffet ~ SRK

Bollywood's Duryodhan ~ Salman (with his 101 rishtedaars)

Bollywood ki working mom ~ Kareena

Bollywood ka Bheesma Pitama ~ Big B

Bollywood ka Tommy Bhaiyya (Tom Hanks) ~ Aamir

Bollywood's modern Manoj Kumar ~ Akshay

Bollywood ka Shakuni ~ KJo

Bollywood's Eklavya ~ SSR

Bollywood's psychologist/Draupadi ~ Deepika

Bollywood's eccentric genius ~ Anurag Kashyap

Bollywood's Meryl Streep ~ Alia

Bollywood's Arjun ~ Ranbir Kapoor

Bollywood's Drona Acharya ~ Naseer Saab

Bollywood's Nehru ~ Mahesh Bhatt

Bollywood's Indira Gandhi ~ Pooja Bhatt

Bollywood's Satre ki beti ~ Sara Ali Khan

Bollywood's Roger Ebert ~ Rajeev Masand

Bollywood ki Slavic beauty ~ Soni Razdan

Bollywood's misunderstood savior Karna ~ HR

It'd be fine if Kangu were Bollywood ki civil rights advocate but Bollywood ki Stephen Hawking is too much.

😕

Originally posted by: SaayaOfKaaya

Oh well. Kangu trying to incorporate Bolly ki quota as they usually do.

Bollywood's Genetics and DNA Expert ~ Saif Ali Khan

Bollywood's Warren Buffet ~ SRK

Bollywood's Duryodhan ~ Salman (with his 101 rishtedaars)

Bollywood ki working mom ~ Kareena

Bollywood ka Bheesma Pitama ~ Big B

Bollywood ka Tommy Bhaiyya (Tom Hanks) ~ Aamir

Bollywood's modern Manoj Kumar ~ Akshay

Bollywood ka Shakuni ~ KJo

Bollywood's Eklavya ~ SSR

Bollywood's psychologist/Draupadi ~ Deepika

Bollywood's eccentric genius ~ Anurag Kashyap

Bollywood's Meryl Streep ~ Alia

Bollywood's Arjun ~ Ranbir Kapoor

Bollywood's Drona Acharya ~ Naseer Saab

Bollywood's Nehru ~ Mahesh Bhatt

Bollywood's Indira Gandhi ~ Pooja Bhatt

Bollywood's Satre ki beti ~ Sara Ali Khan

Bollywood's Roger Ebert ~ Rajeev Masand

Bollywood ki Slavic beauty ~ Soni Razdan

Bollywood's misunderstood savior Karna ~ HR

It'd be fine if Kangu were Bollywood ki civil rights advocate but Bollywood ki Stephen Hawking is too much.

😕

OMG. How did you come up with the list? I am not sure if I agree with it, but mazaa aagaya padhte padhte. :)