Mahabharat Retelecast Discussion Thread 6 - Page 114

Originally posted by: Andy3456

Parshuram didn't give Krishna Sudarshan Chakra!!! He got Surdarshan Chakra and Kaumadiki Gada by Agni Dev during Khandavdahan along with Arjun who got Gandiva.

I was referring to what was shown in BRC MB😆

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

I was referring to what was shown in BRC MB😆

Yes got it. BRC showed wrong

Mama with her babies... 😭😭

https://www.instagram.com/p/CC6V8qFHPmQ/?igshid=4t107g5xrhbf

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

I don't know if BRC was accurate enough but this is what was shown and I think it's logical. When Ram was there, dharma reigned. Again when Krishna is here, dharma would be re-established

Yh but they tried to show it was an exception. Maybe he saw rare talent and Karna impressed him enough. Even now we have many mentors who take up one or two protegee as an exception.

Do you really think Dharma was re-established by Krishna's time?? Janmayey's Nagmedh Yagya and abduction if Yadav women after Yadavs deaths is a clear example of what Dharma was established

When did they show Karna as an exception? Bheeshm and Drona had learnt from him as well. Aside he didn't reach out to Karna, Karna reached out to him, that could be possible only if he was humanly reachable, now Parashuram isn't even humanly reachable, why would he do that if he was still alive??? Why didn't he join universities like Taxshila or Nalanda

Actually I have now started thinking that BRC was the worst show, since it had 80% things accurate, general people automatically believed that even the rest 20% would be true.

That's why completely false things like

Andhe ka Putra Andha

Drona rejecting Karna for even basic education

Gandhari's Divya Drishti to Duryodhan n steel body

Subhadra abducting Arjun

Have become completely acceptable by public

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Do you really think Dharma was re-established by Krishna's time?? Janmayey's Nagmedh Yagya and abduction if Yadav women after Yadavs deaths is a clear example of what Dharma was established

When did they show Karna as an exception? Bheeshm and Drona had learnt from him as well. Aside he didn't reach out to Karna, Karna reached out to him, that could be possible only if he was humanly reachable, now Parashuram isn't even humanly reachable, why would he do that if he was still alive??? Why didn't he join universities like Taxshila or Nalanda

Your discounting the age factor and/or circumstances. Again talking of Bheeshm and Drona atleast 2-3 generation passed between them and Karna.

Even when Krishna was present in MB time did he intervene in any events? He did propose alternatives but choice was always left to the mortals. Our actions are our responsibility not the Gods. It can't deny the existence of the immortal 7 in as much it doesn't confirm their existence but I do believe they exist.

Most of the scriptures say that God always intervenes when adharm is at its peak so it can be destroyed and a new order can be established. Maybe we are heading towards that peak?

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Actually I have now started thinking that BRC was the worst show, since it had 80% things accurate, general people automatically believed that even the rest 20% would be true.

That's why completely false things like

Andhe ka Putra Andha

Drona rejecting Karna for even basic education

Gandhari's Divya Drishti to Duryodhan n steel body

Subhadra abducting Arjun

Have become completely acceptable by public

Draupadi vilification and Karna whitewashing is the worst outcome of the popular MB adaptations.

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

Mama with her babies... 😭😭

https://www.instagram.com/p/CC6V8qFHPmQ/?igshid=4t107g5xrhbf

For the last time😭

The tale of three Queen's..

https://www.instagram.com/p/CCm8d4UnbUK/?igshid=1le396mnon07v

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

Your discounting the age factor and/or circumstances. Again talking of Bheeshm and Drona atleast 2-3 generation passed between them and Karna.

Even when Krishna was present in MB time did he intervene in any events? He did propose alternatives but choice was always left to the mortals. Our actions are our responsibility not the Gods. It can't deny the existence of the immortal 7 in as much it doesn't confirm their existence but I do believe they exist.

Most of the scriptures say that God always intervenes when adharm is at its peak so it can be destroyed and a new order can be established. Maybe we are heading towards that peak?

So you mean to say that someone who was capable till two Yugas after his birth, suddenly got aged after one Yuga? Yes Karna was 2 generation after Bheeshm n Drona but is it anywhere Mentioned that Karna was the only student of Parashuram at that time? Even if he was, as I said he went to Parashuram and not vice versa so this simply means that Parashuram was approachable for people back then, so why not in Kaliyuga?

If God intervened only when Adharma reaches peak, then the level of Adharma was much more during invaders reign than during the rules of Jarasangh, Shishupal or Duryodhan

And yes Krishna did intervene in the events, most of the war strategies were given by Krishna, Hanuman joined Arjun whenever he fought, he met Bheem n guided him, so why not do that in Kaliyuga? We all know that even if Kauravas has ruled, the Adharma wouldn't have been to the level as it was during the reign of the invaders, so why Krishna thought Dwapar as the time of Dharma ki haani and Hanuman took it onto himself to ensure Arjun's victory back then, but thought of ignoring in Kaliyug? And Hanuman helped him without being asked for help by Arjun

See it is impossible to disprove a thing, you can never disapprove if I say that there is a white crow or pink elephant in this universe, but we know that nothing suggests that there could be one.

So yes we can not prove that 7 immortals don't exist but nothing absolutely nothing suggests that they could