Rockstar - a gem or a dud?

What's your opinion on the movie Rockstar? Do you feel it is one of Imtiaz's better movies?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9DQINKZxWE

it was an awesome movie........that is the only movie of RK which I really liked and also liked his character in it......

Originally posted by: anjs

it was an awesome movie........that is the only movie of RK which I really liked and also liked his character in it......

his best 3 performances I think are:

1. Rocket Singh

2. Rockstar

3.Wake Up Sid

I just loved his acting in Rockstar!

A great movie,, RK at his best. The flaw in the movie is Nargis Fakri who is a pain to watch! Otherwise its a good movie with the best song collections.

dud for sure boring ass movie

Best music album of last decade , that and Ranbir's acting is enough to make me sit through for another watch.

Unpopular opinion. Didn’t like Rockstar at all- neither the movie, nor RK’s acting, nor Imtiaz’s direction, nor the overrated music!

I personally disliked all Imtiaz’s movies from Rockstar onwards. His earlier movies were much better. Then again I already know that I’m in the minority over here.

Didn't like the movie much but boy, how phenomenal was Ranbir in it.

Ambitious failure with a lot of phony angst. Great OST though.

It falls somewhere in-between those two extremes though I liked it 😎