For me it's not the age difference per se the problem, just how HS looked the same age anf played her father figure... The comparison makes it off for me. I'd have liked a guy who looked Mickey's or Bobby's age more for her I guess 🤔
That makes sense and it's the same for me. Even though Mickey and Bobby were older than Minnie, it had worked. Their relationship was believable and if they had eventually progressed to romance, I would've been fine with it. With Neil, there is something off. If they had wanted to go with someone mature for Minnie (I.e., someone in their late twenties versus early), that still would've made sense since Minnie would've sought out someone who is more mature and settled rather than flaky and still undecided.