5 years of no contact - Page 3

Originally posted by: inlieu

@bold, I think so too. It changed his life in a major way and both he and the audience knows it. These writers are creative enough to come up with something awesome if they want to and all his backstory is yet to be explored. But they did show two bodies when Minnie entered the haveli so I don't know... Maybe it's only in flashbacks or in her dreams/imagination where he guides her during tough times or something. I know audiences will be over the moon and he'd love it too, but he loves his craft too much to belittle it or himself for a bit part that makes no sense.

Well, whatever he's going to do, I am fine with it as long as I get to see his awesome performances and hope he's happy. If this were an EK show we'd have a HUGE door open for him to walk back (well, for once in my life I wish such a thing were possible) but this isn't that kind of show or writing so forget that.

I might sound like a crazy fan here but what they did to AD is unacceptable. Also they have hurt my feelings by calling housewives stupid and I am not at all okay with a 15 year old playing 23 year old woman.

Originally posted by: inlieu

@bold ... that's what I was thinking too! Ye zaalim PH. Aakhir zaroorat padh hi gayi na HS ki!

Sirf HS hi inki naiyya paar kara sakta hai.

Originally posted by: inlieu

AD/HS is just bait to keep us intrigued long enough to have our questions answered and then for us to be actually involved in the new story arc to want to watch the entire season. LOL! Kuch bhi.

It's his personal choice, but I'd rather he stay away from this show unless they offer him something meaty. At one point fans will get tired of asking for HS but if they continue to do so, KK might just go ahead and do it. Who knows?! But I don't see him coming back except in flashbacks, unless they go EK style and have him turn up one day saying he'd lost his memory after the accident or was in a coma and finally woke up. In which case I'd rather AD gave this a wide berth.🤣

I know and the idiot in me is still watching it just for him even though I know better.

Given how he's going off to detox himself of HS, I don't think he'll come back for long term. Varna, what's the point of recreating yourself if you're just gonna sink back into the skin of the same character you already played.

If that's how they decide to bring back HS, then I wanna know what idiot proclaimed him to be dead in the first place. Japanese kushti ki parade laga de Minnie uss par.

Originally posted by: inlieu

@bold, I think so too. It changed his life in a major way and both he and the audience knows it. These writers are creative enough to come up with something awesome if they want to and all his backstory is yet to be explored. But they did show two bodies when Minnie entered the haveli so I don't know... Maybe it's only in flashbacks or in her dreams/imagination where he guides her during tough times or something. I know audiences will be over the moon and he'd love it too, but he loves his craft too much to belittle it or himself for a bit part that makes no sense.

Well, whatever he's going to do, I am fine with it as long as I get to see his awesome performances and hope he's happy. If this were an EK show we'd have a HUGE door open for him to walk back (well, for once in my life I wish such a thing were possible) but this isn't that kind of show or writing so forget that.

The only thing that's solid in PB is death. Agar koi mar gaya toh woh mar gaya. Bafas aane ka koi chance nayi.

That being said, there are so many other ways they can incorporate him. Flashbacks is the obvious one, then there's also the written medium. Letters has played a huge role in S1, whether it was Babita dictating HS' feelings for Imarti, her reading between the lines of Imarti's letter, Ashok writing a letter to both HS and Minnie and then the final burning of it. Falling along these lines, HS might have gotten down to finally dictating his thoughts and feelings with a pen. Him not mailing them is a different matter but him releasing those pent up emotions is what's most important. Then, one way or another, they reached the intended recipient - Minnie and perhaps Arya.

We also have the visual medium. Undoubtedly, he would have made lots of videos of Arya, wanting to capture each and every little moment of hers. Her first steps, her first words, her laughter and giggles, her childish antics - everything. We can see glimpses of them in this format.

Then there's also his work. Surely over the years, he must have made so many speeches, which will then undoubtedly go recorded. Policies he must have made around the station, little notes and doodles, all the trophies highlighting all the work he has accomplished. Not to mention the innumerable stories of all the people whose lives he has touched by simply existing.

There is honestly so much that the writers can do to keep his essence alive in the show. They just need to be smart about it.

Originally posted by: Jiarao

I too am happy with whatever he decides but I don't want him to come back to the show even for flashbacks or dream sequences. If he comes back people will continue watching the show and makers will think they won. Though I love Ashnoor and wish best for her I want season 2 be a flop.

I might sound like a crazy fan here but what they did to AD is unacceptable. Also they have hurt my feelings by calling housewives stupid and I am not at all okay with a 15 year old playing 23 year old woman.

This evn I find wierd always not only today...children are so innocent and someone who is 15 is a kid ... we all (pertaining to all watching pbs) could be having children nieces sisters cousins of that age and we treat them like kids ..as for us they are sweet little children growing up into adulthood ...why do these tv ppl spoil that equation...15 to 17 is ok but 15 to 23 is too much to bear ...8 years more than real age ...a kid turned into an adult...and thn Make the person do all romantic scenes aswell...earlier that actress some Hansika Motwani suddenly became an adult same with Balika vadu actress ...now is Ashnoor to be made to follow same path ...why can’t they simply take a 21 or same age actress to play that part ...won’t it be more convincing aswell plus justified for the role since your thought process at a certain age is different and 15 to 23 is not even a generation gap ...it is more than that ....plus it is moving from a very young age to adulthood ...not convincing

Originally posted by: inlieu

@bold, I think so too. It changed his life in a major way and both he and the audience knows it. These writers are creative enough to come up with something awesome if they want to and all his backstory is yet to be explored. But they did show two bodies when Minnie entered the haveli so I don't know... Maybe it's only in flashbacks or in her dreams/imagination where he guides her during tough times or something. I know audiences will be over the moon and he'd love it too, but he loves his craft too much to belittle it or himself for a bit part that makes no sense.

Well, whatever he's going to do, I am fine with it as long as I get to see his awesome performances and hope he's happy. If this were an EK show we'd have a HUGE door open for him to walk back (well, for once in my life I wish such a thing were possible) but this isn't that kind of show or writing so forget that.

I don’t think anyone of thm whether Paridhi or HS shud come back ...typical Ekta Kapoor drama (though already it is the same now aswell )..maybe because I never really liked hs or Paridhi alone ..it was their characters which were lovable so was the family bond and the mother daughter bond ...the story has been spoilt yes now it will not matter much Evn if they show them coming back ...as anything can happen in tv serials ...if S2 does not work maybe they can try that aswell ...as they have anyways not shown faces ..but then what will they show ....again Babita starting her business with Mini ...the story which never developed continues now ...actually nothing will work for them now ....they have to stick to what they have planned and try to make it better ...audience will have to forget S1 to absorb this season otherwise will be difficult fir them to get viewers ...but can someone tell me if there was mention of Micky and his whereabouts ...Could be he is busy so might an entry in another episode

Originally posted by: Jiarao

I too am happy with whatever he decides but I don't want him to come back to the show even for flashbacks or dream sequences. If he comes back people will continue watching the show and makers will think they won. Though I love Ashnoor and wish best for her I want season 2 be a flop.

I might sound like a crazy fan here but what they did to AD is unacceptable. Also they have hurt my feelings by calling housewives stupid and I am not at all okay with a 15 year old playing 23 year old woman.

Yeah, I see your point. He is probably better off moving on to projects where the team respect him and especially his talent and most importantly, gives him his due.

As for the feelings that KK have hurt, the list is quite long. Their take on housewives was ridiculous, not to mention insinuating that men who support their wives' wish to be homemakers are henpecked/joru ka ghulaam/doing ji hazuri or that their sole purpose is to earn money and nothing else.

Their concepts of identity and labels in relationships are warped. Not just in the surname matter but also in what they did with the whole baap nahin ban paya thing. There are millions of kids who would love to have a father like HS. Matlab, kuch bhi... they have belittled the emotions of a father which I really really was disappointed by after they showed Ashok and Dadu as failures, as well as HS' father. My dad is a key part of my life and to see such poor representation of good fathers, especially when 2 of the leads have daddy issues, was just pathetic.

Originally posted by: asmaanixx

I know and the idiot in me is still watching it just for him even though I know better.

Given how he's going off to detox himself of HS, I don't think he'll come back for long term. Varna, what's the point of recreating yourself if you're just gonna sink back into the skin of the same character you already played.

If that's how they decide to bring back HS, then I wanna know what idiot proclaimed him to be dead in the first place. Japanese kushti ki parade laga de Minnie uss par.

I don't know. I trust him to make good decisions. For now, he can enjoy this lovely break with his lovely wife and come back with a dhain si entry, as per your request, Gur! 😉

Originally posted by: asmaanixx

The only thing that's solid in PB is death. Agar koi mar gaya toh woh mar gaya. Bafas aane ka koi chance nayi.

That being said, there are so many other ways they can incorporate him. Flashbacks is the obvious one, then there's also the written medium. Letters has played a huge role in S1, whether it was Babita dictating HS' feelings for Imarti, her reading between the lines of Imarti's letter, Ashok writing a letter to both HS and Minnie and then the final burning of it. Falling along these lines, HS might have gotten down to finally dictating his thoughts and feelings with a pen. Him not mailing them is a different matter but him releasing those pent up emotions is what's most important. Then, one way or another, they reached the intended recipient - Minnie and perhaps Arya.

We also have the visual medium. Undoubtedly, he would have made lots of videos of Arya, wanting to capture each and every little moment of hers. Her first steps, her first words, her laughter and giggles, her childish antics - everything. We can see glimpses of them in this format.

Then there's also his work. Surely over the years, he must have made so many speeches, which will then undoubtedly go recorded. Policies he must have made around the station, little notes and doodles, all the trophies highlighting all the work he has accomplished. Not to mention the innumerable stories of all the people whose lives he has touched by simply existing.

There is honestly so much that the writers can do to keep his essence alive in the show. They just need to be smart about it.

WORD... I was just thinking about him leaving behind letters or a memoir to express what he could not do verbally, perhaps his own version of Dear Diary. It would be awesome for Minnie to finally learn what she meant to him that way, especially since her departure was triggered because of Ashok's letter.

@bold... yes, just his existence was extremely valuable.

Originally posted by: inlieu

Yeah, I see your point. He is probably better off moving on to projects where the team respect him and especially his talent and most importantly, gives him his due.

As for the feelings that KK have hurt, the list is quite long. Their take on housewives was ridiculous, not to mention insinuating that men who support their wives' wish to be homemakers are henpecked/joru ka ghulaam/doing ji hazuri or that their sole purpose is to earn money and nothing else.

Their concepts of identity and labels in relationships are warped. Not just in the surname matter but also in what they did with the whole baap nahin ban paya thing. There are millions of kids who would love to have a father like HS. Matlab, kuch bhi... they have belittled the emotions of a father which I really really was disappointed by after they showed Ashok and Dadu as failures, as well as HS' father. My dad is a key part of my life and to see such poor representation of good fathers, especially when 2 of the leads have daddy issues, was just pathetic.

I haven't heard anything more ridiculous than this baap nahi ban paaya thing. I will never understand the logic behind this. For that matter I haven't understood the purpose of this story even after watching it for200 episodes . I used to think it was Babitha's emancipation and Mini's journey to hope. Now I know it's not the case.

What they wanted to tell us?. If you have any idea please enlighten me Jean. I am feeling quite stupid for watching a story for around 200 days without understanding what the writer wanted me to know. I have read countless stories but such thing has never happened before.