Mein Rahoon Ya Na Rahoon, Tu Mujhme Kahin Baki Rehna - Aa Jao Saarey - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

187

Views

28k

Users

19

Likes

202

Frequent Posters

asmaanixx thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: najma123

Hey, thanks a lot for the detailed explanation!! Really, thanks a lot. As far as the treatment of the actors is concerned, it was SHIT. Horrible. And Mini being right in S1, was more in tune but making her something like a shining misery in S2 is šŸ‘ŽšŸ¼ However, there are some posts on the Forum that talk about how Babita's core was the same and it took a turn for the worse. And I stand by that, even though it was a shit story to watch, and see a beautiful show fall apart, I personally could very well relate to the progression, having watched the entire serial, for the most part, I felt more than Babita, HS' character took a back seat. And, even though it wasn't nice or happy to watch it, personally, I could relate to Babita's complicated character well, and maybe it's perceived as ruin by some, or the makers wanted it to be that way. Or, they wanted to show the complication and it came off as ruin. I don't know. But I believe, Babita as a character brought it upon her and though obviously the last couple of episodes were actually shit, well. Can't say much. I was super saddened to watch today's scenes with HS man. SO SAD it was. Also, when he did call her, how come Mini has no idea about a sister? How is that even possible?

Also, if there was a rift between Paridhi and PH, what about AD? Why was his character axed.?

You're welcome.

There were better ways to present the opposing viewpoints between Minnie and Babita. Instead of giving valid reasons for both sides, they continuously created situations where Babita will be wrong and Minnie right.

As for Babita's personality change, it's subjective. I personally don't agree that the end product that we got of hers was her basic nature all along. The degree to which her flaws were emphasized was done solely to victimize Minnie and create a drift between mother-daughter so that Minnie can have a ton of emotional baggage to carry for Season Two.

HS did take a backseat. There were many situations that could have been avoided if HS had been allowed to act. Case in point: the burning of the letter. He very well could have ran forward to grab it instead of standing back and letting it burn to ash.

In regards to what the writers intended, I don't even want to know anymore. Apparently, whatever we had seen in the first two hundred episodes, was not what they had intended and we had read into something else entirely. Whatever their goal was, they missed the mark in executing the tracks properly. Again, this is a subjective opinion and this is how I feel. I don't want to presume to know what the other forum members think or feel.

In the end, Babita was purposely set up to be sole the reason for her home breaking. Or at least, her home with Minnie.

I'm not entirely sure what's going on between Minnie and Arya. We were initially under the assumption that Minnie never came home in five years but she at least knew about her sister. Perhaps not wanting to interfere in her Babes' new family, she didn't come home. However, today we found out that she visited at least once and the last time she went back was three years ago. So, she had to have met Arya when she was perhaps two or three years old. Arya not remembering Minnie makes sense. But for Minnie to be surprised upon knowing Arya doesn't.

I can't even posit my other theory because Minnie coming home defeats it. Either way, we'll know more tomorrow.

I don't think there was a rift between the PH and Aniruddh. When Rajita Sharma (the writer) gave her statement, she had mentioned how Hanita's story line was finite. If there wasn't any good material for HS to perform, then Aniruddh may not have wanted to keep going. As it is, his character wasn't doing much so I'm not sure what they may have had in store for him post leap.

Also, I don't think Aniruddh has any malice towards the PH. There may have been some initial hurt and pain, but I believe he has now reached a stage where he is filled with nothing but gratitude. He's more thankful for all the love and appreciation he's getting and is proud of the work he has left behind. Now, he's working on a new project so there's that. :)

Edited by asmaanixx - 6 years ago
yoyogagirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#73

Did you see Ashnoor’s insta story? Cake cutting chal Rahi hai and the cake has Mini and Arya’s picture. It doesn’t look right without AD and PS šŸ˜’

How we thought 300 epi celebration will have 4 people’s picture on the cake. Alas šŸ’”

asmaanixx thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#74

@the FB vid:

1. They were clearly feeding the lines to Arya. I could hear the lady whispering them to her. Idk how the PH is able to work with a kid so young. It surely must take them forever to get through just one scene.

2. Not one mention of Aniruddh & Paridhi or Hanita. šŸ¤”

3. The label half-sister - I don't like.

4. Phir se soulmates? I already hated this stupid concept ab toh aur bhi nafrat hogayi.

asmaanixx thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: LoveInAutumn26

Did you see Ashnoor’s insta story? Cake cutting chal Rahi hai and the cake has Mini and Arya’s picture. It doesn’t look right without AD and PS šŸ˜’

How we thought 300 epi celebration will have 4 people’s picture on the cake. Alas šŸ’”

I only saw the story with the cake, not the cutting itself. But yeahh, it just feels so wrong.

Ek member bar toh gaya but at what cost? 🄺

It's just not the same feeling anymore. Jo bhi charm thi uss mein, woh khatam hogayi.

yoyogagirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: asmaanixx

@the FB vid:

1. They were clearly feeding the lines to Arya. I could hear the lady whispering them to her. Idk how the PH is able to work with a kid so young. It surely must take them forever to get through just one scene.

2. Not one mention of Aniruddh & Paridhi or Hanita. šŸ¤”

3. The label half-sister - I don't like.

4. Phir se soulmates? I already hated this stupid concept ab toh aur bhi nafrat hogayi.

I know. I could hear the lady giving cues to Arya. It’s definitely difficult to shoot with a child actor, and esp if she is another lead who will have almost equal SS as Ashnoor.

Paridhi and Ashnoor used to do these live chats and it would be so smooth and nice. With Aniruddh later on, it was so much fun to see them interact. Ahhh well.

Ashnoor/Mini could have mentioned something about Hanita, or AD and PS.

I don’t know why they are fixating on half-sisters label. Are they telling us Mini-Arya are only connected through Babita since both have the same mother. Again, writers telling us HS-Mini never became father-daughter. Whatever!

I hate this soulmate crap they keep throwing at us. Just STFU with it already šŸ™„. And I thought Mickey was her soulmate, what happened to that?!?!

yoyogagirl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: asmaanixx

I only saw the story with the cake, not the cutting itself. But yeahh, it just feels so wrong.

Ek member bar toh gaya but at what cost? 🄺

It's just not the same feeling anymore. Jo bhi charm thi uss mein, woh khatam hogayi.

Yeah I was talking about that picture only. It feels wrong without AD and PS. Its that void, empty feeling. Oh well gotta move on 🄺

asmaanixx thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: LoveInAutumn26

I know. I could hear the lady giving cues to Arya. It’s definitely difficult to shoot with a child actor, and esp if she is another lead who will have almost equal SS as Ashnoor.

Paridhi and Ashnoor used to do these live chats and it would be so smooth and nice. With Aniruddh later on, it was so much fun to see them interact. Ahhh well.

Ashnoor/Mini could have mentioned something about Hanita, or AD and PS.

I don’t know why they are fixating on half-sisters label. Are they telling us Mini-Arya are only connected through Babita since both have the same mother. Again, writers telling us HS-Mini never became father-daughter. Whatever!

I hate this soulmate crap they keep throwing at us. Just STFU with it already šŸ™„. And I thought Mickey was her soulmate, what happened to that?!?!

Well, they insinuated that in today's episode too. Minnie was more heartbroken and distraught over Babes in the first half of the episode, not HS. Yes, she got incredibly emotional when she spoke to HS over the phone, but I don't know. He was still just her Hanuman Uncle, not her father.

Loll, Idek wanna know what they think of soulmates. It'll probably be as twisted as their understanding of rest of the relationships.

asmaanixx thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: LoveInAutumn26

Yeah I was talking about that picture only. It feels wrong without AD and PS. Its that void, empty feeling. Oh well gotta move on 🄺

I know. Just gotta take it one day a time now. Can't think about what could have been, should have been or whatnot. There's literally no point to it. In the end, KK wohi karega jo KK ko karna hai.

shazam1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: asmaanixx

Well, they insinuated that in today's episode too. Minnie was more heartbroken and distraught over Babes in the first half of the episode, not HS. Yes, she got incredibly emotional when she spoke to HS over the phone, but I don't know. He was still just her Hanuman Uncle, not her father.

Loll, Idek wanna know what they think of soulmates. It'll probably be as twisted as their understanding of rest of the relationships.

I took solace in what Minnie told her friend- that parents say things which make you emotional. At least she used the word ā€œparentā€ for HS😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".