Kabir Singh or Gully Boy? - Page 5

^^ them both are wonderful actors!! No denying it!! Shahid is getting his due appreciation!! Shahid was always underrated... may be the kind of scripts he selects... but from haider I can see a lot of change in his selection! And ranveer is also doing great with selection of scripts! That is evident with his movies already!

Originally posted by: sherlockthor

gully boy he was a cheater

kabir singh he was abusive

i don't know what's worse

performance wise I think gully boy

Just because a character is flawed(like most of us), doesn't make him less relatable. I guess we are not looking for perfection (that would be too boring anyways).

Originally posted by: Thug-Leader

Murad cheated on Safeena two times though, once entertained the flirting girl and than hooked up with Sky, and the female Kabir Singh was beating up everyone for him.

And whenever he got caught, he blamed everything on her possessiveness. Okay even if I agree with you on KS and agree that he was the worst piece of shit ever existed. Murad for me was no better, a liar, a criminal and dishonest, just because he eas polite, doesn't make him any better than KS.

Most of us lie and are dishonest to an extent depending on what we are dealing with ... at times we do becoz we are confused, scared and don't know how to face a situation ... Same happened with Murad! ... But anyways .. your opinion and your liking! ... But Murad a criminal how?! .. (-I don't remember this bit from the movie at all)!

Originally posted by: 4thPrincoholic

Most of us lie and are dishonest to an extent depending on what we are dealing with ... at times we do becoz we are confused, scared and don't know how to face a situation ... Same happened with Murad! ... But anyways .. your opinion and your liking! ... But Murad a criminal how?! .. (-I don't remember this bit from the movie at all)!

Wasn't he stealing cars?

Just talking about the movie Kabir Singh could have been better masala had it shown Shahid's post addiction transformation to a better human... Performance wise Shahid was better but for movie I'll chose GB

Originally posted by: Thug-Leader

Wasn't he stealing cars?

Thought it was the other person he used to hang with! ... Don't remember much about him stealing ... regardless privileged KS vs slum boy Murad ... self explanatory!

Dekhi tou mein ne dono nahi hain but from the overall reactions I have seen, Shahid's received more praise

Not a ranveer fan but will go for gully boy..

Had already watched arjun reddy so there was no surprise element in 'kabir singh' for me

Originally posted by: MarcoPolo008

How can you even compare the two

In what universe is arjun reddy a better movie than gullyboy ?

Like how ?

Kabir Singh is better for sure..Gully Boy seemed like a rip off of 8 Mile. Zoya always tries too hard to make her movies "western" and loses the unique appeal of BW