Put forum members into Hogwarts houses. - Page 13

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Also Hermoine lead her to the centaurs. That part is important because if she was indeed raped well, Hermoine is also responsible isnt it. That's too dark and completely destroys the character.

Centaurs are good people ! 😭

Hermione too wasn't a saint. She's a pretty dark character. Burning up her teacher's cloak at age of 11. Giving Marietta a permanent SNEAK mark on her face. Probably ruined her life just because the girl was looking out for herself.

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Also Hermoine lead her to the centaurs. That part is important because if she was indeed raped well, Hermoine is also responsible isnt it. That's too dark and completely destroys the character.

Yes Hermione can be ruthless at Times. She captured Rita Skeeter in her fly form in a jar n blackmailed her to leave journalism for a year or else she'd give her out as an unregistered animagus. But she's not twisted enough to lead another woman to get raped. Just no.

Also that sneak mark on Marietta wasn't permanent was it? It'd heal with Time?in sixth book Harry noticed the marks were very faded

Let's leave this topic. Does anyone think Harry Ginny were not developed well?

Originally posted by: Looney86

Hermione too wasn't a saint. She's a pretty dark character. Burning up her teacher's cloak at age of 11. Giving Marietta a permanent SNITCH mark on her face. Probably ruined her life just because the girl was looking out for herself.

There goes my childhood ..

Originally posted by: Charaiveti

Yes Hermione can be ruthless at Times. She captured Rita Skeeter in her fly form in a jar n blackmailed her to leave journalism for a year or else she'd give her out as an unregistered animagus. But she's not twisted enough to lead another woman to get raped. Just no.

Also that sneak mark on Marietta wasn't permanent was it? It'd heal with Time?in sixth book Harry noticed the marks were very faded

It looked faded because of heavy makeup. JK has said in some interview that the mark is permanent.

Dayyuum Kya discussion chal rahi hai 🤔

Originally posted by: Charaiveti

yep it'd make all the lead characters look like twisted jerks

Twisted jerks would be an understatement. They all would deserve Azkaban and dementors themselves. Esp Hermoine.

Originally posted by: Looney86

It looked faded because of heavy makeup. JK has said in some interview that the mark is permanent.