For discussion: Can a terrorist child be denied medical treatment? - Page 2

Originally posted by: KootyPai

Terrorist's child should definitely be treated. There's no dilemma about that. But it's difficult to think that way when someone loses their loved ones.It's not easy to think rationally at that time. I can understand the mob. They are wrong. No doubt. But their minds too are clouded by grief of losing their loved ones.

But I'm totally against treatment of terrorists. They are scrums of the Earth and they deserve to die

The ones who loose loved ones are not generally the ones on the streets & in front of hospitals creating scenes throwing stones and all. The ones who loose loved ones will be immediately attending to them or taking care of last rites or else too saddened by grief & in shock. Their anger will be an after thought a day or two later

The ones out on the street are mostly not even related to the ones who have died. they just are there to create trouble

Not only from the point of view of humanity that all people deserve basic treatment another fact is that family members or even terrorists are an important part of police investigation. They are the ones who can give leads later on. So even if one is angry the fact is all they should be kept alive for interrogation in such a situation. Even Kasab was treated and then interrogated for further information. Those asking for the non-treatment of the terrorists child are basically brainless in my opinion. 🥱

Originally posted by: braveheartdoc

Thank you all for the unanimous opinion. Even I believe the same but for doctors it's also a fearful situation just like it's shown in the show that the public finds the doctor as the culprit and they get to face the wrath and insulted. Is that fair for someone who saves lives😕

You are right, in our state a few days ago a junior doctor's head was severely injured by an angry mob for the death of a patient. All the junior doctors from various hospitals across the state went on a strike in protest. Doctors do face difficulties.

Not only brainless but soulless public who want death or child

Why only a terrorist's child? Even a terrorist also should not be denied of medical tretment. Its the law. And i respect this. A patient is a patient. He's above age, sex, race, religion, cast and terrorism.

Originally posted by: Sparklingstar22

You are right, in our state a few days ago a junior doctor's head was severely injured by an angry mob for the death of a patient. All the junior doctors from various hospitals across the state went on a strike in protest. Doctors do face difficulties.

That's a very frequent thing nowadays and we work in this fear regularly. It's a very stressful environment for us😒

Originally posted by: naq5

The ones who loose loved ones are not generally the ones on the streets & in front of hospitals creating scenes throwing stones and all. The ones who loose loved ones will be immediately attending to them or taking care of last rites or else too saddened by grief & in shock. Their anger will be an after thought a day or two later

The ones out on the street are mostly not even related to the ones who have died. they just are there to create trouble

Mostly theyr e a group of people who love to create a trouble for their pity interest. They're nowhere emotionally related to the deceased or their families.

For the police ,Sanya is the most important witness in the bomb blast, so treating her injuries and saving her life is important for them.They can get more information from her! That applies to a real terrorist too. May be in real cases they take the patient to a government hospital and also provide heavy security . But here for the drama the pt is in sanjivani, so the police should be providing the hospital and doctors protection. That’s from law point of view alone. And as Dr juhi said there are courts to decide that who’s innocent or guilty. As doctors they just have to treat the patient.

In real life too we see mob violence and vigilante justice, lawyers being threatened and attacked for representing a terrorist or a criminal, hospitals ransacked or doctors are attacked if the patient died in their care, people take law into their hands without finding out the actual facts

An innocent child needs a fair treatment regardless of her background.

But in current situation of Sid and Ishani, I feel they can't proceed with a heroic act if Sanjivani board members have already taken a call and denied operation. In order to save girls life, they could have jeopardize their own, Sanjivani & as well as fellow doctors life. Moreover situation was like riots, what if angry mob have attacked and killed them if police and our government isn't providing security to our doctor for treating terrorist daughter.

I really liked what juhi said in Friday's episode!!!

It is up to court n Police to do justice....it's their job!!! Doctors job is to save lives.... irrespective of caste, gender etc!!!! Even if she is guilty....its not public who can give her punishment!!!

She should be treated....it's what doctors take oath of!!!