Originally posted by: Khushbooloves
I was very disappointed with Madhuri Dixit not dancing in the song.. for so long I didn't have heart to watch Alia in that song. But finally when I watched... It was not even average. Sadly I didnt like Tabah ho gaye too due to the steps.
I didn't mind the steps, though from what Saroj Khan implied, the execution of the whole choreography had to be slowed down in order to accommodate the last-minute change of the pace of the song.
I did mind the awful editing of the sequence (the pointless crosscuts almost ruined Madhuri's performance + the director clearly had no idea how to showcase dance), and the soulless, vignette-like scenes didn't cohere into a story with satisfying dramatic tension and emotional truth. I guess that's what happens when a hack producer employs mediocre yes-people.
20